Old-school gunslingers meet modern-era tacticians in this all-time quarterback debate spanning seven decades. Where do you stand?
1Tom BradySeven-time Super Bowl champion widely considered the greatest quarterback in NFL history, winning titles with the New England Patriots and Tampa Bay Buccaneers.1000pts
2Patrick MahomesThree-time Super Bowl champion with the Kansas City Chiefs and multiple MVP winner who has become the face of the modern NFL.888pts
3Brett FavreThree-time MVP and Super Bowl XXXI champion with the Green Bay Packers, famous for his iron-man consecutive starts streak of 297 games.846pts
4Joe MontanaFour-time Super Bowl champion with the San Francisco 49ers, known for his poise under pressure and never losing a Super Bowl appearance.821pts
5Peyton ManningTwo-time Super Bowl champion and five-time MVP who revolutionized the quarterback position with his pre-snap reads and audibles for the Colts and Broncos.714pts
6John ElwayTwo-time Super Bowl champion with the Denver Broncos and five-time Super Bowl participant, known for his rocket arm and comeback victories.714pts
7Aaron RodgersSuper Bowl XLV champion and four-time MVP with the Green Bay Packers, known for his exceptional accuracy and clutch performances.643pts
8Eli ManningNew York Giants quarterback who twice beat Tom Brady's Patriots in the Super Bowl, earning MVP honours in Super Bowls XLII and XLVI.643pts
9Kurt WarnerFormer grocery clerk who won two MVP awards, led the St. Louis Rams to victory in Super Bowl XXXIV and later took Arizona to its first Super Bowl.601pts
10Drew BreesNew Orleans Saints quarterback who led the team to Super Bowl XLIV victory and broke numerous NFL passing records during his career.601pts
11Joe NamathNew York Jets quarterback famous for guaranteeing Super Bowl III victory, a brash personality who brought star power to the AFL.553pts
12Terry BradshawPittsburgh Steelers quarterback who won four Super Bowls in six seasons in the 1970s and was MVP of Super Bowls XIII and XIV.553pts
13Jim KellyBuffalo Bills Hall of Famer who ran the K-Gun no-huddle offence and led his team to four consecutive Super Bowl appearances.553pts
14Ken StablerOakland Raiders left-hander nicknamed 'the Snake', the 1974 MVP and Super Bowl XI champion famed for his calm in late-game comebacks.500pts
15Johnny UnitasLegendary Baltimore Colts quarterback who redefined the position in the 1950s and 60s, holding multiple passing records for decades.500pts
16Dan MarinoMiami Dolphins quarterback who set numerous passing records in his era and is considered the greatest QB never to win a Super Bowl.500pts
17Roger StaubachDallas Cowboys quarterback who won two Super Bowls and is considered one of the greatest leaders in NFL history, earning the nickname 'Captain America'.500pts
18Warren MoonUndrafted quarterback who won five straight Grey Cups in Canada before throwing for more than 49,000 NFL yards and entering the Hall of Fame.459pts
19Josh AllenBuffalo Bills quarterback and 2024 MVP whose arm strength and power as a runner make him one of the most prolific touchdown scorers at the position.459pts
20Fran TarkentonMinnesota Vikings and New York Giants quarterback who was a three-time NFC champion and held numerous passing records upon retirement.459pts
21Sammy BaughWashington's 'Slingin' Sammy' won two NFL titles and led the league in passing six times, transforming the forward pass in the 1930s and 1940s.459pts
22Troy AikmanDallas Cowboys quarterback who won three Super Bowls in four seasons in the 1990s, earning MVP honours in Super Bowl XXVII.459pts
23Len DawsonKansas City Chiefs quarterback who won three AFL titles and was MVP of Super Bowl IV against the Minnesota Vikings.412pts
24Ben RoethlisbergerPittsburgh Steelers quarterback who won Super Bowls XL and XLIII and threw for more than 64,000 yards in 18 seasons with one franchise.412pts
25Otto GrahamLed the Cleveland Browns to ten straight championship games from 1946 to 1955, winning seven titles across the AAFC and NFL.357pts
26Sid LuckmanChicago Bears quarterback who mastered the T-formation and won four NFL championships in the 1940s, including the 73-0 rout of Washington in 1940.357pts
27Bart StarrGreen Bay Packers quarterback who won five NFL titles under Vince Lombardi and was MVP of the first two Super Bowls.357pts
28Dan FoutsSan Diego Chargers Hall of Famer who led the NFL in passing yards four straight seasons as the trigger man of 'Air Coryell'.357pts
29Bobby LayneDetroit Lions quarterback who won three NFL championships in the 1950s and was famed for his leadership and late-game comebacks.357pts
30Lamar JacksonBaltimore Ravens dual-threat quarterback and two-time MVP (2019, 2023) who holds the record for most rushing yards in a season by a quarterback.357pts
31Steve YoungSan Francisco 49ers left-hander who won two MVP awards and threw a record six touchdown passes in Super Bowl XXIX.0pts
32Sonny JurgensenHall of Famer with the Eagles and Washington, regarded as one of the purest passers of his era, who led the NFL in passing yards five times.0pts
Photo credits
- Tom Brady — Barcex, CC BY-SA 4.0
- John Elway — All-Pro Reels, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Aaron Rodgers — All-Pro Reels, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Eli Manning — Alexander Jonesi, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Terry Bradshaw — The ASI Show, CC BY 2.0
- Dan Marino — Unknown author, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Warren Moon — Warren Moon Press Conference | Oilers Tribute Week, CC BY 3.0
- Josh Allen — All-Pro Reels, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Troy Aikman — Leahdi, CC BY-SA 3.0
- Ben Roethlisberger — Erik Drost, CC BY 2.0
- Dan Fouts — Rex Lilly, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Lamar Jackson — Maryland GovPics, CC BY 2.0
- Steve Young — SAB0TEUR, CC BY-SA 2.0
Comments 1
Thirteen names, and the argument underneath them is whether titles or peak seasons are the thing being counted, with Tom Brady and Brady vs Mahomes both on the ballot.
YP
ypb-teamAug 21


























