You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 20 Best Madden Cover Athletes of All Time

By YPB Team

Box-art stars of EA's football series, including the fan-vote surprises and the player whose digital version broke the game.

  1. Tom Brady — ranked #11
    Tom Brady
    Cover athlete of Madden NFL 18, then shared the Madden NFL 22 cover with Patrick Mahomes.
    1000pts
  2. Patrick Mahomes — ranked #22
    Patrick Mahomes
    Cover athlete of Madden NFL 20 and, alongside Tom Brady, of Madden NFL 22.
    757pts
  3. Lamar Jackson — ranked #33
    Lamar Jackson
    Madden NFL 21 cover athlete after his unanimous 2019 MVP season.
    680pts
  4. Calvin Johnson — ranked #44
    Calvin Johnson
    Madden NFL 13 cover athlete who then set the single-season receiving yards record.
    629pts
  5. Michael Vick — ranked #55
    Michael Vick
    Madden NFL 2004 cover star, often called the most overpowered player the series ever had.
    628pts
  6. Brett Favre — ranked #66
    Brett Favre
    Madden NFL 09 cover athlete, released the summer he left Green Bay.
    569pts
  7. Odell Beckham Jr. — ranked #77
    Odell Beckham Jr.
    Madden NFL 16 cover athlete, picked after his one-handed catch went viral.
    500pts
  8. Peyton Hillis — ranked #88
    Peyton Hillis
    Browns running back who won the fan vote for the Madden NFL 12 cover.
    500pts
  9. Larry Fitzgerald — ranked #99
    Larry Fitzgerald
    Shared the Madden NFL 10 cover after Arizona's Super Bowl run.
    500pts
  10. Ray Lewis — ranked #1010
    Ray Lewis
    Madden NFL 2005 cover, the first defensive player to front the game.
    455pts
  11. Barry Sanders — ranked #1111
    Barry Sanders
    Fan-voted cover of Madden NFL 25, the 2013 anniversary edition.
    455pts
  12. Troy Polamalu — ranked #1212
    Troy Polamalu
    Shared the Madden NFL 10 cover with Larry Fitzgerald.
    455pts
  13. Josh Allen — ranked #1313
    Josh Allen
    Cover athlete of Madden NFL 24, chosen after his breakout seasons in Buffalo.
    455pts
  14. Rob Gronkowski — ranked #1414
    Rob Gronkowski
    Madden NFL 17 cover athlete and the Patriots' record-setting tight end.
    400pts
  15. Adrian Peterson — ranked #1515
    Adrian Peterson
    Shared the 2013 anniversary edition, Madden NFL 25, with Barry Sanders.
    400pts
  16. Daunte Culpepper — ranked #1616
    Daunte Culpepper
    Madden NFL 2002 cover athlete for the Vikings.
    400pts
  17. Drew Brees — ranked #1717
    Drew Brees
    Madden NFL 11 cover athlete after the Saints' first Super Bowl title.
    0pts
  18. Eddie George — ranked #1818
    Eddie George
    Madden NFL 2001 cover athlete for the Titans.
    0pts
  19. Shaun Alexander — ranked #1919
    Shaun Alexander
    Madden NFL 07 cover athlete after his 28-touchdown MVP season.
    0pts
  20. Christian McCaffrey — ranked #2020
    Christian McCaffrey
    Cover athlete of the 2024 edition, Madden NFL 25, after his Offensive Player of the Year season.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments 1

First Bills player ever on a Madden cover: Allen in Madden NFL 24, four editions after Mahomes fronted Madden NFL 20: https://youpick.best/articles/mahomes-vs-allen-ranked

YP
ypb-team
Oct 28