Reputation and production drift apart more often than highlight reels admit. This is the uncomfortable version of the list.
1Tim TebowHeisman winner whose 2011 Broncos run sparked Tebowmania, though he completed under 48 per cent of his passes and soon left the league.1000pts
2Jared GoffRams first overall pick who reached Super Bowl LIII but managed only three points, and was traded to Detroit two years later.684pts
3Eli ManningGiants quarterback who beat unbeaten New England in Super Bowl XLII and won a second ring four years later.633pts
4Donovan McNabbEagles quarterback who reached five NFC Championship Games but won only one, losing Super Bowl XXXIX to New England.633pts
5Russell WilsonSeahawks quarterback who won Super Bowl XLVIII as a second-year starter.573pts
6Joe NamathJets icon whose Super Bowl III guarantee made him a legend and a Hall of Famer despite throwing more interceptions than touchdowns in his career.573pts
7Baker MayfieldFirst overall pick who rebuilt his career in Tampa Bay after several stops.573pts
8Tony RomoCowboys quarterback with strong numbers and no deep playoff run.500pts
9Matt RyanFalcons MVP who led a 28-3 Super Bowl lead that did not hold.500pts
10Patrick MahomesChiefs quarterback with three Super Bowl titles and three Super Bowl MVPs before turning 30.500pts
11Kirk CousinsLong-time starter known for big contracts and strong regular-season numbers.500pts
12Carson WentzMVP front-runner in 2017 who never regained that form after injury.500pts
13Troy AikmanCowboys quarterback with three Super Bowl rings whose modest passing numbers are often credited to Emmitt Smith, Michael Irvin and a dominant offensive line.500pts
14Terry BradshawFour-time Super Bowl winner whose 51.9 per cent career completion rate leads critics to credit the Steel Curtain defence for the Steelers' titles.500pts
15Andrew LuckColts first overall pick named alongside Eli Manning as most overrated in an anonymous poll of NFL players before he retired at 29.500pts
16Jay CutlerStrong-armed Bears quarterback whose talent outpaced his team results.444pts
17Tom BradySeven-time Super Bowl champion who spent 20 seasons in New England before winning a seventh ring in Tampa Bay.444pts
18Ben RoethlisbergerSteelers quarterback who won two Super Bowls and was famously hard to bring down.444pts
19Joe FlaccoRavens quarterback whose 2012 postseason run ended in a Super Bowl MVP award.444pts
20Mark SanchezJets quarterback who reached two AFC Championship games early and faded quickly.444pts
21Dak PrescottCowboys quarterback and former fourth-round pick who became a long-term starter.444pts
22Philip RiversChargers quarterback with huge career numbers and no Super Bowl appearance.0pts
23Trent DilferRavens quarterback who won Super Bowl XXXV behind a record-setting defence and was released by Baltimore that same offseason.0pts
24Andy DaltonBengals quarterback who reached the playoffs repeatedly without winning a game there.0pts
25Dan FoutsAir Coryell passing leader in San Diego whose prolific regular seasons never produced a Super Bowl appearance and a losing playoff record.0pts
26Matthew StaffordLions quarterback who piled up passing yards for 12 seasons in Detroit without winning a single playoff game before his Rams title.0pts
27Carson PalmerFirst overall pick in 2003 who lost both of his playoff starts in Cincinnati before a late-career revival with the Arizona Cardinals.0pts
28Josh AllenBills quarterback voted the league's most overrated in a survey of more than 100 NFL players despite his huge passing and rushing numbers.0pts
Photo credits
- Tim Tebow — User:Sports Spectrum, CC BY-SA 4.0
- Jared Goff — Jeffrey Beall, CC BY 4.0
- Eli Manning — Alexander Jonesi, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Donovan McNabb — Rachel Lynne Smith, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Tony Romo — Keith Allison, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Patrick Mahomes — Jeffrey Beall, CC BY 4.0
- Troy Aikman — Leahdi, CC BY-SA 3.0
- Terry Bradshaw — The ASI Show, CC BY 2.0
- Andrew Luck — Keith Allison from Hanover, MD, USA, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Joe Flacco — Erik Drost, CC BY 4.0
- Mark Sanchez — All-Pro Reels from District of Columbia, USA, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Dak Prescott — Gage Skidmore, CC BY-SA 3.0
- Trent Dilfer — Rick Munroe, CC BY-SA 4.0
- Andy Dalton — Jeffrey Beall, CC BY 4.0
- Dan Fouts — Rex Lilly, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Matthew Stafford — Sewageboy, CC BY-SA 4.0
- Carson Palmer — FOX Sports, CC BY 3.0
- Josh Allen — All-Pro Reels, CC BY-SA 2.0
Comments 2
Eli Manning took two Super Bowl MVPs off New England, which makes him the difficult name on a ballot headed by Joe Flacco's contract: https://youpick.best/articles/tom-brady-vs-patrick-mahomes-ranked
YP
ypb-teamAug 21Supporting cast or January exits? Mahomes and Allen face both charges on a list that also tries Brady and Eli Manning: https://youpick.best/articles/mahomes-vs-allen-ranked
YP
ypb-teamOct 28

























