You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 26 Greatest Comeback Quarterbacks in NFL History

By YPB Team

Down three scores in the fourth quarter is where reputations get made, or quietly buried.

  1. Patrick Mahomes — ranked #11
    Patrick Mahomes
    Chiefs quarterback with three Super Bowl titles and three Super Bowl MVPs before turning 30.
    1000pts
  2. Joe Montana — ranked #22
    Joe Montana
    49ers icon who went 4-0 in Super Bowls and never threw an interception in one.
    698pts
  3. Peyton Manning — ranked #33
    Peyton Manning
    Five-time MVP who won Super Bowls with both the Colts and the Broncos.
    665pts
  4. Eli Manning — ranked #44
    Eli Manning
    Giants quarterback who beat unbeaten New England in Super Bowl XLII and won a second ring four years later.
    664pts
  5. John Elway — ranked #55
    John Elway
    Broncos quarterback famous for the Drive, who finally won back-to-back titles at the end of his career.
    626pts
  6. Josh Allen — ranked #66
    Josh Allen
    Bills quarterback known for combining a huge arm with punishing running.
    626pts
  7. Dan Marino — ranked #77
    Dan Marino
    Dolphins quarterback with one of the quickest releases ever, who never won a Super Bowl.
    626pts
  8. Frank Reich — ranked #88
    Frank Reich
    Bills backup who led the biggest comeback in NFL history from 32 points down.
    582pts
  9. Tom Brady — ranked #99
    Tom Brady
    Seven-time Super Bowl champion who spent 20 seasons in New England before winning a seventh ring in Tampa Bay.
    582pts
  10. Ben Roethlisberger — ranked #1010
    Ben Roethlisberger
    Steelers quarterback who won two Super Bowls and was famously hard to bring down.
    530pts
  11. Andrew Luck — ranked #1111
    Andrew Luck
    Colts quarterback who rallied Indianapolis from 28 points down to beat Kansas City in a January 2014 wild-card game, then the second-largest playoff comeback ever.
    530pts
  12. Joe Burrow — ranked #1212
    Joe Burrow
    Bengals quarterback who rallied Cincinnati from 18 points down at Kansas City to win the AFC Championship Game and reach Super Bowl LVI.
    476pts
  13. Brett Favre — ranked #1313
    Brett Favre
    Iron-man Packers quarterback who started 297 consecutive games and won three straight MVPs.
    476pts
  14. Ken Stabler — ranked #1414
    Ken Stabler
    Raiders quarterback nicknamed the Snake whose late drives produced the Sea of Hands playoff win over Miami and the Holy Roller in the 1970s.
    419pts
  15. Philip Rivers — ranked #1515
    Philip Rivers
    Chargers quarterback who engineered more than two dozen fourth-quarter comebacks across 17 seasons in San Diego, Los Angeles and Indianapolis.
    419pts
  16. Matthew Stafford — ranked #1616
    Matthew Stafford
    Strong-armed quarterback who won Super Bowl LVI in his first season with the Rams.
    419pts
  17. Johnny Unitas — ranked #1717
    Johnny Unitas
    Colts quarterback who threw touchdowns in 47 straight games and defined the position's early era.
    419pts
  18. Aaron Rodgers — ranked #1818
    Aaron Rodgers
    Four-time MVP whose Packers career included a Super Bowl XLV title.
    419pts
  19. Drew Brees — ranked #1919
    Drew Brees
    Saints quarterback who retired as the NFL's all-time completions leader and won Super Bowl XLIV.
    419pts
  20. Kirk Cousins — ranked #2020
    Kirk Cousins
    Vikings quarterback who led the largest comeback in NFL history, rallying Minnesota from 33 points down to beat Indianapolis in December 2022.
    419pts
  21. Trevor Lawrence — ranked #2121
    Trevor Lawrence
    Jaguars quarterback who threw four first-half interceptions and then led Jacksonville back from 27-0 down to beat the Chargers in a January 2023 playoff game.
    419pts
  22. Jim Harbaugh — ranked #2222
    Jim Harbaugh
    Colts quarterback nicknamed Captain Comeback in 1995, when his late rallies carried Indianapolis to within a dropped Hail Mary of the Super Bowl.
    419pts
  23. Roger Staubach — ranked #2323
    Roger Staubach
    Cowboys quarterback who won two Super Bowls and coined the term Hail Mary.
    0pts
  24. Bart Starr — ranked #2424
    Bart Starr
    Packers quarterback who led the final drive of the 1967 Ice Bowl in sub-zero cold, scoring the winning quarterback sneak in the closing seconds.
    0pts
  25. Bobby Layne — ranked #2525
    Bobby Layne
    Lions quarterback of the 1950s credited with pioneering the two-minute drill, including a last-minute winning drive in the 1953 NFL Championship Game.
    0pts
  26. Russell Wilson — ranked #2626
    Russell Wilson
    Seahawks quarterback who overcame four interceptions and a 19-7 deficit late in the 2014 NFC Championship Game to beat Green Bay in overtime.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments 1

Frank Reich was a backup when he turned 35-3 into 41-38 on 3 January 1993, and almost nobody names him before the 28-3 game: https://youpick.best/articles/tom-brady-vs-patrick-mahomes-ranked

YP
ypb-team
Aug 21