You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 16 Best NFL Players Never to Win a Super Bowl

By YPB Team

Hall of Fame careers with one gap in the trophy case. Some came close four times, others never played a postseason snap.

  1. Calvin Johnson — ranked #11
    Calvin Johnson
    Lions receiver who set the season receiving yards record and retired at 30 without a playoff win.
    1000pts
  2. Josh Allen — ranked #22
    Josh Allen
    Bills quarterback and 2024 MVP whose playoff runs have ended four times against Kansas City.
    909pts
  3. Larry Fitzgerald — ranked #33
    Larry Fitzgerald
    Cardinals receiver whose late touchdown in Super Bowl XLIII was answered by Pittsburgh.
    636pts
  4. Earl Campbell — ranked #44
    Earl Campbell
    Oilers running back who lost back-to-back AFC title games to the Steelers.
    636pts
  5. LaDainian Tomlinson — ranked #55
    LaDainian Tomlinson
    Chargers running back and 2006 MVP who never reached a Super Bowl.
    636pts
  6. Barry Sanders — ranked #66
    Barry Sanders
    Lions running back who retired on the eve of the 1999 season, 1,457 yards short of the career rushing record.
    500pts
  7. Jim Kelly — ranked #77
    Jim Kelly
    Bills quarterback who lost four straight Super Bowls from the 1990 to 1993 seasons.
    500pts
  8. Dick Butkus — ranked #88
    Dick Butkus
    Bears linebacker of 1965 to 1973 who never played in a postseason game.
    500pts
  9. Dan Marino — ranked #99
    Dan Marino
    Dolphins quarterback who reached one Super Bowl, in his second season, and never returned.
    444pts
  10. Bruce Smith — ranked #1010
    Bruce Smith
    Career sacks leader who played in all four of Buffalo's Super Bowl losses.
    444pts
  11. Warren Moon — ranked #1111
    Warren Moon
    Hall of Fame quarterback who won five Grey Cups in Canada and no Super Bowl.
    444pts
  12. Cris Carter — ranked #1212
    Cris Carter
    Vikings receiver whose 1998 team went 15-1 and lost the NFC title game.
    444pts
  13. Dan Fouts — ranked #1313
    Dan Fouts
    Chargers quarterback of the Air Coryell offense who never reached a Super Bowl.
    444pts
  14. Philip Rivers — ranked #1414
    Philip Rivers
    Chargers quarterback who started 240 straight games and never reached a Super Bowl.
    444pts
  15. Tony Gonzalez — ranked #1515
    Tony Gonzalez
    Tight end who played 17 seasons for the Chiefs and Falcons and won one playoff game.
    0pts
  16. J. J. Watt — ranked #1616
    J. J. Watt
    Three-time Defensive Player of the Year who never got past the divisional round.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments 1

Seven playoff wins and no Super Bowl start, the most for any quarterback per NFL Research, is why Allen stands next to Marino here: https://youpick.best/articles/mahomes-vs-allen-ranked

YP
ypb-team
Oct 28