Hall of Fame careers with one gap in the trophy case. Some came close four times, others never played a postseason snap.
1Calvin JohnsonLions receiver who set the season receiving yards record and retired at 30 without a playoff win.1000pts
2Josh AllenBills quarterback and 2024 MVP whose playoff runs have ended four times against Kansas City.909pts
3Larry FitzgeraldCardinals receiver whose late touchdown in Super Bowl XLIII was answered by Pittsburgh.636pts
4Earl CampbellOilers running back who lost back-to-back AFC title games to the Steelers.636pts
5LaDainian TomlinsonChargers running back and 2006 MVP who never reached a Super Bowl.636pts
6Barry SandersLions running back who retired on the eve of the 1999 season, 1,457 yards short of the career rushing record.500pts
7Jim KellyBills quarterback who lost four straight Super Bowls from the 1990 to 1993 seasons.500pts
8Dick ButkusBears linebacker of 1965 to 1973 who never played in a postseason game.500pts
9Dan MarinoDolphins quarterback who reached one Super Bowl, in his second season, and never returned.444pts
10Bruce SmithCareer sacks leader who played in all four of Buffalo's Super Bowl losses.444pts
11Warren MoonHall of Fame quarterback who won five Grey Cups in Canada and no Super Bowl.444pts
12Cris CarterVikings receiver whose 1998 team went 15-1 and lost the NFC title game.444pts
13Dan FoutsChargers quarterback of the Air Coryell offense who never reached a Super Bowl.444pts
14Philip RiversChargers quarterback who started 240 straight games and never reached a Super Bowl.444pts
15Tony GonzalezTight end who played 17 seasons for the Chiefs and Falcons and won one playoff game.0pts
16J. J. WattThree-time Defensive Player of the Year who never got past the divisional round.0pts
Photo credits
- Calvin Johnson — Gage Skidmore, CC BY-SA 3.0
- Josh Allen — All-Pro Reels, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Larry Fitzgerald — Keith Allison from Hanover, MD, USA, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Earl Campbell — TankedBevo of ShaggyBevo.com, CC BY 2.5
- LaDainian Tomlinson — original: U.S, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Barry Sanders — Greg2600, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Dick Butkus — Alan Light, CC BY 2.0
- Dan Marino — Unknown author, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Bruce Smith — VaMedia, CC BY 2.0
- Warren Moon — Warren Moon Press Conference | Oilers Tribute Week, CC BY 3.0
- Cris Carter — MN National Guard, CC BY 3.0
- Dan Fouts — Rex Lilly, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Philip Rivers — Behind Enemy Lines: Titans at Colts, CC BY 3.0
- Tony Gonzalez — Erik Drost, CC BY 2.0
- J. J. Watt — Denverjeffrey, CC BY 4.0
Comments 1
Seven playoff wins and no Super Bowl start, the most for any quarterback per NFL Research, is why Allen stands next to Marino here: https://youpick.best/articles/mahomes-vs-allen-ranked
YP
ypb-teamOct 28
























