You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 34 Greatest NFL Playoff Quarterbacks of All Time

By YPB Team

January is a different sport. These are the men whose seasons got longer while everyone else went home.

  1. Patrick Mahomes — ranked #11
    Patrick Mahomes
    Chiefs quarterback with three Super Bowl titles and three Super Bowl MVPs before turning 30.
    1000pts
  2. Aaron Rodgers — ranked #22
    Aaron Rodgers
    Four-time MVP whose Packers career included a Super Bowl XLV title.
    975pts
  3. Eli Manning — ranked #33
    Eli Manning
    Giants quarterback who beat unbeaten New England in Super Bowl XLII and won a second ring four years later.
    848pts
  4. Joe Namath — ranked #44
    Joe Namath
    Jets quarterback who guaranteed victory over the Colts in Super Bowl III, delivered it and was named the game's MVP.
    807pts
  5. Ben Roethlisberger — ranked #55
    Ben Roethlisberger
    Steelers quarterback who won two Super Bowls and was famously hard to bring down.
    732pts
  6. Terry Bradshaw — ranked #66
    Terry Bradshaw
    Steelers quarterback who won four Super Bowls in six seasons during the 1970s dynasty.
    709pts
  7. John Elway — ranked #77
    John Elway
    Broncos quarterback famous for the Drive, who finally won back-to-back titles at the end of his career.
    684pts
  8. Steve Young — ranked #88
    Steve Young
    Left-handed 49ers quarterback who threw six touchdowns in Super Bowl XXIX.
    684pts
  9. Troy Aikman — ranked #99
    Troy Aikman
    Cowboys quarterback who won three Super Bowls in four seasons in the 1990s and was named Super Bowl XXVII MVP.
    631pts
  10. Russell Wilson — ranked #1010
    Russell Wilson
    Seahawks quarterback who won Super Bowl XLVIII as a second-year starter.
    570pts
  11. Tom Brady — ranked #1111
    Tom Brady
    Seven-time Super Bowl champion who spent 20 seasons in New England before winning a seventh ring in Tampa Bay.
    570pts
  12. Peyton Manning — ranked #1212
    Peyton Manning
    Five-time MVP who won Super Bowls with both the Colts and the Broncos.
    500pts
  13. Jalen Hurts — ranked #1313
    Jalen Hurts
    Eagles quarterback who set a Super Bowl quarterback rushing record in LVII and won Super Bowl LIX as MVP.
    500pts
  14. Johnny Unitas — ranked #1414
    Johnny Unitas
    Colts quarterback whose drives won the 1958 championship game in overtime, the game remembered as the Greatest Game Ever Played.
    500pts
  15. Drew Brees — ranked #1515
    Drew Brees
    Saints quarterback who retired as the NFL's all-time completions leader and won Super Bowl XLIV.
    500pts
  16. Brett Favre — ranked #1616
    Brett Favre
    Iron-man Packers quarterback who started 297 consecutive games and won three straight MVPs.
    462pts
  17. Jim Plunkett — ranked #1717
    Jim Plunkett
    Raiders quarterback who won two Super Bowls, taking Super Bowl XV MVP after starting the season on the bench.
    462pts
  18. Roger Staubach — ranked #1818
    Roger Staubach
    Cowboys quarterback who won two Super Bowls and coined the term Hail Mary.
    462pts
  19. Kurt Warner — ranked #1919
    Kurt Warner
    Undrafted grocery-store clerk who became an MVP and won Super Bowl XXXIV with the Rams.
    462pts
  20. Joe Flacco — ranked #2020
    Joe Flacco
    Ravens quarterback who threw 11 touchdowns without an interception in the 2012 playoffs and was named Super Bowl XLVII MVP.
    417pts
  21. Bart Starr — ranked #2121
    Bart Starr
    Packers quarterback who won the first two Super Bowls and five NFL titles under Vince Lombardi.
    417pts
  22. Joe Montana — ranked #2222
    Joe Montana
    49ers icon who went 4-0 in Super Bowls and never threw an interception in one.
    417pts
  23. Otto Graham — ranked #2323
    Otto Graham
    Browns quarterback who reached his league's championship game in all ten professional seasons and won seven titles.
    417pts
  24. Sid Luckman — ranked #2424
    Sid Luckman
    Bears quarterback who ran the T-formation to four NFL titles, including the 73–0 championship rout of Washington in 1940.
    417pts
  25. Bob Griese — ranked #2525
    Bob Griese
    Dolphins quarterback who led Miami to back-to-back Super Bowl wins, including the victory that completed the perfect 1972 season.
    364pts
  26. Matthew Stafford — ranked #2626
    Matthew Stafford
    Rams quarterback who won four playoff games in his first Los Angeles season, capped by the winning drive in Super Bowl LVI.
    364pts
  27. Nick Foles — ranked #2727
    Nick Foles
    Backup Eagles quarterback who beat the Patriots in Super Bowl LII as MVP and caught the famous Philly Special touchdown.
    364pts
  28. Ken Stabler — ranked #2828
    Ken Stabler
    Raiders quarterback known for late playoff comebacks, who won Super Bowl XI and threw the Sea of Hands winner against Miami.
    364pts
  29. Doug Williams — ranked #2929
    Doug Williams
    Washington quarterback who threw four touchdowns in one quarter of Super Bowl XXII and was the first Black quarterback to win it.
    0pts
  30. Bobby Layne — ranked #3030
    Bobby Layne
    Lions quarterback whose late-game heroics and swagger led Detroit to back-to-back NFL championships in 1952 and 1953.
    0pts
  31. Len Dawson — ranked #3131
    Len Dawson
    Chiefs quarterback who won Super Bowl IV as MVP after leading his franchise to three AFL championships.
    0pts
  32. Phil Simms — ranked #3232
    Phil Simms
    Giants quarterback who completed 22 of 25 passes in Super Bowl XXI, a record completion rate that earned him the MVP award.
    0pts
  33. Jim Kelly — ranked #3333
    Jim Kelly
    Bills quarterback who led Buffalo to four consecutive Super Bowls in the early 1990s with the fast-paced K-Gun offence.
    0pts
  34. Joe Burrow — ranked #3434
    Joe Burrow
    Bengals quarterback who won the 2021 AFC Championship at Kansas City to take Cincinnati to Super Bowl LVI in his second season.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments 1

Forty-eight postseason games against five Super Bowls in seven seasons as a starter, and this ranking rewards both things at once: https://youpick.best/articles/tom-brady-vs-patrick-mahomes-ranked

YP
ypb-team
Aug 21