You Pick BestYouPickBest

Top 24 Improvisational NFL Quarterbacks of All Time

By YPB Team

Some of these men executed a system. Others invented one after the pocket had already collapsed.

  1. Patrick Mahomes — ranked #11
    Patrick Mahomes
    Chiefs quarterback with three Super Bowl titles and three Super Bowl MVPs before turning 30.
    1000pts
  2. Lamar Jackson — ranked #22
    Lamar Jackson
    Ravens quarterback and two-time MVP who redefined what a running quarterback can be.
    880pts
  3. Fran Tarkenton — ranked #33
    Fran Tarkenton
    Vikings quarterback who made scrambling a legitimate style decades before it was fashionable.
    746pts
  4. Russell Wilson — ranked #44
    Russell Wilson
    Seahawks quarterback who won Super Bowl XLVIII as a second-year starter.
    657pts
  5. Aaron Rodgers — ranked #55
    Aaron Rodgers
    Four-time MVP whose Packers career included a Super Bowl XLV title.
    656pts
  6. Jake Plummer — ranked #66
    Jake Plummer
    Cardinals and Broncos quarterback nicknamed Jake the Snake for his escapes, who took Denver to the 2005 AFC Championship Game.
    602pts
  7. Brett Favre — ranked #77
    Brett Favre
    Iron-man Packers quarterback who started 297 consecutive games and won three straight MVPs.
    602pts
  8. Ben Roethlisberger — ranked #88
    Ben Roethlisberger
    Steelers quarterback who won two Super Bowls and was famously hard to bring down.
    602pts
  9. Michael Vick — ranked #99
    Michael Vick
    Falcons quarterback who became the first to rush for 1,000 yards in a season.
    538pts
  10. Steve Young — ranked #1010
    Steve Young
    Left-handed 49ers quarterback who threw six touchdowns in Super Bowl XXIX.
    538pts
  11. John Elway — ranked #1111
    John Elway
    Broncos quarterback famous for the Drive, who finally won back-to-back titles at the end of his career.
    476pts
  12. Jayden Daniels — ranked #1212
    Jayden Daniels
    Commanders quarterback who won 2024 Offensive Rookie of the Year with scrambles and late heroics, including a Hail Mary win over Chicago.
    476pts
  13. Tony Romo — ranked #1313
    Tony Romo
    Cowboys quarterback famous for escaping sacks and throwing on the run, who retired holding the franchise's major passing records.
    476pts
  14. Donovan McNabb — ranked #1414
    Donovan McNabb
    Eagles quarterback who extended plays with his legs, reaching five NFC Championship Games and Super Bowl XXXIX.
    476pts
  15. Josh Allen — ranked #1515
    Josh Allen
    Bills quarterback known for combining a huge arm with punishing running.
    419pts
  16. Randall Cunningham — ranked #1616
    Randall Cunningham
    Eagles quarterback whose scrambling and punting made him one of the era's best athletes.
    419pts
  17. Vince Young — ranked #1717
    Vince Young
    Titans quarterback and 2006 Offensive Rookie of the Year whose scrambles and late comebacks made him a Pro Bowler as a rookie.
    419pts
  18. Steve McNair — ranked #1818
    Steve McNair
    Titans quarterback and 2003 co-MVP whose toughness and escapes carried Tennessee to within a yard of tying Super Bowl XXXIV.
    419pts
  19. Doug Flutie — ranked #1919
    Doug Flutie
    Undersized quarterback who improvised his way to a long career in two leagues.
    419pts
  20. Jalen Hurts — ranked #2020
    Jalen Hurts
    Eagles quarterback whose running and off-script throws powered Philadelphia to two Super Bowls, winning Super Bowl LIX as MVP.
    419pts
  21. Kyler Murray — ranked #2121
    Kyler Murray
    Cardinals quarterback and former baseball prospect known for escaping pressure.
    0pts
  22. Roger Staubach — ranked #2222
    Roger Staubach
    Cowboys quarterback who won two Super Bowls and coined the term Hail Mary.
    0pts
  23. Cam Newton — ranked #2323
    Cam Newton
    Panthers quarterback and 2015 MVP whose size and running made him the NFL's all-time leader in rushing touchdowns by a quarterback.
    0pts
  24. Archie Manning — ranked #2424
    Archie Manning
    Saints quarterback whose scrambles kept struggling New Orleans teams competitive through the 1970s and earned him two Pro Bowls.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments 2

Randall Cunningham punted for his own team and Fran Tarkenton was scrambling in the 1960s, when it counted against a quarterback: https://youpick.best/articles/tom-brady-vs-patrick-mahomes-ranked

YP
ypb-team
Aug 21

Nine months after tearing his ACL and LCL, Mahomes started the 2026 opener. He and Allen, filed here with Tarkenton and Vick as improvisers: https://youpick.best/articles/mahomes-vs-allen-ranked

YP
ypb-team
Oct 28