You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the best painting based on another painting?

By YPB Team

Every canvas here answers an older picture: a few as tributes, more as arguments, one or two as outright jokes.

  1. Olympia (Manet, after Titian) — ranked #11
    Olympia (Manet, after Titian)
    Manet's 1863 nude, shown at the 1865 Salon and now in the Musée d'Orsay, takes the pose of Titian's Venus of Urbino and puts a black cat where Titian had a dog.
    1000pts
  2. Study after Innocent X (Bacon, after Velázquez) — ranked #22
    Study after Innocent X (Bacon, after Velázquez)
    Francis Bacon's 1953 screaming pope (Des Moines Art Center) works from reproductions of Velázquez's portrait and borrows the scream from a still of Battleship Potemkin.
    822pts
  3. Las Meninas series (Picasso, after Velázquez) — ranked #33
    Las Meninas series (Picasso, after Velázquez)
    In 1957 Picasso painted 58 works in Cannes, 45 of them on Velázquez's Las Meninas — the whole scene or single figures — and in 1968 gave the set to the Museu Picasso in Barcelona.
    701pts
  4. Le Déjeuner sur l'herbe (Manet, after Raphael) — ranked #44
    Le Déjeuner sur l'herbe (Manet, after Raphael)
    The seated trio in Manet's 1863 picnic (Musée d'Orsay) copies a group of river gods and a nymph from Marcantonio Raimondi's engraving of Raphael's Judgment of Paris.
    701pts
  5. Bedroom at Arles (Lichtenstein, after Van Gogh) — ranked #55
    Bedroom at Arles (Lichtenstein, after Van Gogh)
    Roy Lichtenstein's 1992 painting redraws Van Gogh's bedroom at Arles in his comic-book outlines and Benday dots, as part of his late Interiors series.
    701pts
  6. Venus of Urbino (Titian, after Giorgione) — ranked #66
    Venus of Urbino (Titian, after Giorgione)
    Titian's 1538 nude in the Uffizi repeats the pose of the Dresden Sleeping Venus, a picture begun by Giorgione and finished by the young Titian.
    615pts
  7. Sixty Last Suppers (Warhol, after Leonardo) — ranked #77
    Sixty Last Suppers (Warhol, after Leonardo)
    Warhol's 1986 canvas repeats a black-and-white image of Leonardo's Last Supper sixty times, part of a series commissioned by the dealer Alexander Iolas for a Milan show.
    615pts
  8. Napoleon Leading the Army (Wiley, after David) — ranked #88
    Napoleon Leading the Army (Wiley, after David)
    Kehinde Wiley's 2005 canvas in the Brooklyn Museum keeps the pose of David's Napoleon Crossing the Alps and puts a young Black man in camouflage and Timberlands on the horse.
    449pts
  9. Women of Algiers, Version O (Picasso, after Delacroix) — ranked #99
    Women of Algiers, Version O (Picasso, after Delacroix)
    The last of 15 variations Picasso painted in 1954–1955 on Delacroix's 1834 Women of Algiers; it sold at Christie's in 2015 for $179.4 million.
    449pts
  10. Adam and Eve (Rubens, after Titian) — ranked #1010
    Adam and Eve (Rubens, after Titian)
    Rubens copied Titian's Adam and Eve in Madrid in 1628–1629, adding a red parrot in the tree; both versions hang in the Museo del Prado.
    449pts
  11. The Execution of Maximilian (Manet, after Goya) — ranked #1111
    The Execution of Maximilian (Manet, after Goya)
    Manet's 1868–1869 version in the Kunsthalle Mannheim builds the 1867 execution of the Mexican emperor on the firing-squad composition of Goya's The Third of May 1808.
    449pts
  12. Le Déjeuner sur l'herbe (Picasso, after Manet) — ranked #1212
    Le Déjeuner sur l'herbe (Picasso, after Manet)
    Picasso's version of 30 July 1961 (Louisiana Museum of Modern Art, Humlebæk) belongs to a series of 27 paintings he made on Manet's picnic between 1959 and 1962, alongside drawings, maquettes and prints.
    449pts
  13. Archaeological Reminiscence (Dalí, after Millet) — ranked #1313
    Archaeological Reminiscence (Dalí, after Millet)
    Dalí's panel of 1933–1935 at the Dalí Museum in St. Petersburg, Florida, turns the praying couple of Millet's Angelus into two towering stone ruins.
    449pts
  14. Flowering Plum Orchard (Van Gogh, after Hiroshige) — ranked #1414
    Flowering Plum Orchard (Van Gogh, after Hiroshige)
    Van Gogh's 1887 oil copy of a Hiroshige woodblock print (Van Gogh Museum) brightens the colours and adds a border of Japanese characters taken from other prints.
    449pts
  15. The Siesta (Van Gogh, after Millet) — ranked #1515
    The Siesta (Van Gogh, after Millet)
    Painted at Saint-Rémy in 1889–1890 from a black-and-white print after Millet (Musée d'Orsay), it belongs to a group of copies Van Gogh called translations into colour.
    0pts
  16. Mona Lisa, Age Twelve (Botero) — ranked #1616
    Mona Lisa, Age Twelve (Botero)
    Fernando Botero painted Leonardo's sitter as an inflated child in 1959, on a canvas over two metres tall that the Museum of Modern Art acquired in 1961.
    0pts
  17. A Modern Olympia (Cézanne, after Manet) — ranked #1717
    A Modern Olympia (Cézanne, after Manet)
    Cézanne's small 1873–1874 answer to Manet's Olympia (Musée d'Orsay) adds a dark-suited visitor watching the nude and was shown at the first Impressionist exhibition in 1874.
    0pts
  18. Pietà (Van Gogh, after Delacroix) — ranked #1818
    Pietà (Van Gogh, after Delacroix)
    Van Gogh painted this 1889 Pietà (Van Gogh Museum) at Saint-Rémy from a lithograph of Delacroix's painting, reworking the black-and-white print in yellow and blue.
    0pts
  19. Massacre in Korea (Picasso, after Goya) — ranked #1919
    Massacre in Korea (Picasso, after Goya)
    Picasso's 1951 painting on plywood in the Musée national Picasso-Paris sets armoured soldiers against naked women and children, following the layout of Goya's The Third of May 1808.
    0pts

Comments