Rings are the easy argument. The harder one is whether a single flawless afternoon should outweigh a decade of them.
1Joe Montana49ers icon who went 4-0 in Super Bowls and never threw an interception in one.1000pts
2Tom BradySeven-time Super Bowl champion who spent 20 seasons in New England before winning a seventh ring in Tampa Bay.809pts
3Troy AikmanCowboys quarterback who won three Super Bowls in four years in the 1990s.772pts
4Terry BradshawSteelers quarterback who won four Super Bowls in six seasons during the 1970s dynasty.711pts
5Patrick MahomesChiefs quarterback with three Super Bowl titles and three Super Bowl MVPs before turning 30.668pts
6John ElwayBroncos quarterback famous for the Drive, who finally won back-to-back titles at the end of his career.668pts
7Peyton ManningFive-time MVP who won Super Bowls with both the Colts and the Broncos.619pts
8Bart StarrPackers quarterback who won the first two Super Bowls and five NFL titles under Vince Lombardi.619pts
9Drew BreesSaints quarterback who retired as the NFL's all-time completions leader and won Super Bowl XLIV.500pts
10Russell WilsonSeahawks quarterback who won Super Bowl XLVIII as a second-year starter.500pts
11Ben RoethlisbergerSteelers quarterback who won two Super Bowls and was famously hard to bring down.500pts
12Joe NamathJets quarterback who guaranteed and delivered the Super Bowl III upset over Baltimore.500pts
13Nick FolesBackup who beat Tom Brady in Super Bowl LII and took the MVP award.451pts
14Steve YoungLeft-handed 49ers quarterback who threw six touchdowns in Super Bowl XXIX.394pts
15Eli ManningGiants quarterback who beat unbeaten New England in Super Bowl XLII and won a second ring four years later.394pts
16Phil SimmsGiants quarterback whose 22-of-25 passing in Super Bowl XXI remains a record for accuracy.394pts
17Kurt WarnerUndrafted grocery-store clerk who became an MVP and won Super Bowl XXXIV with the Rams.394pts
18Doug WilliamsFirst Black quarterback to win a Super Bowl, throwing four touchdowns in one quarter of Super Bowl XXII.394pts
19Aaron RodgersFour-time MVP whose Packers career included a Super Bowl XLV title.0pts
20Jim PlunkettRaiders quarterback who won two Super Bowls after being written off earlier in his career.0pts
Photo credits
- Troy Aikman — Leahdi, CC BY-SA 3.0
- Terry Bradshaw — The ASI Show, CC BY 2.0
- Patrick Mahomes — Jeffrey Beall, CC BY 4.0
- John Elway — All-Pro Reels, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Steve Young — SAB0TEUR, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Eli Manning — Alexander Jonesi, CC BY-SA 2.0
Comments 1
Joe Montana went 4-0 in these games and threw no interceptions across 122 attempts, so seven rings and three do not settle it: https://youpick.best/articles/tom-brady-vs-patrick-mahomes-ranked
YP
ypb-teamAug 21


























