You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 14 Greatest Indianapolis Colts Players of All Time

by YPB Team

From Baltimore-era legends to Lucas Oil Stadium stars, this franchise's history spans Hall of Famers and record-breaking rookies alike. Who tops your list?

  1. Peyton Manning — ranked #11
    Peyton Manning
    Four-time NFL MVP quarterback who led the Colts to a Super Bowl title and set franchise passing records.
    1000pts
  2. Johnny Unitas — ranked #22
    Johnny Unitas
    Pioneering quarterback who won three NFL championships and redefined the passing game.
    829pts
  3. Andrew Luck — ranked #33
    Andrew Luck
    Franchise quarterback known for gritty performances and a surprise early retirement.
    609pts
  4. Gino Marchetti — ranked #44
    Gino Marchetti
    Dominant defensive end considered one of the greatest pass rushers of the pre-merger NFL.
    473pts
  5. Eric Dickerson — ranked #55
    Eric Dickerson
    Hall of Fame running back who brought his explosive rushing style to Indianapolis in the late 1980s.
    473pts
  6. Lenny Moore — ranked #66
    Lenny Moore
    Hall of Fame halfback and flanker who starred for the franchise's championship teams in Baltimore.
    387pts
  7. Robert Mathis — ranked #77
    Robert Mathis
    Relentless outside linebacker who paired with Dwight Freeney to form a fearsome pass-rush duo.
    387pts
  8. Marvin Harrison — ranked #88
    Marvin Harrison
    Hall of Fame wide receiver and one of Peyton Manning's most prolific targets.
    284pts
  9. Edgerrin James — ranked #99
    Edgerrin James
    Powerful running back who led the NFL in rushing twice in his early Colts career.
    284pts
  10. Dwight Freeney — ranked #1010
    Dwight Freeney
    Dominant pass rusher famous for his signature spin move off the edge.
    284pts
  11. Adam Vinatieri — ranked #1111
    Adam Vinatieri
    Clutch placekicker who became the franchise's all-time leading scorer after years with the Patriots.
    284pts
  12. Quenton Nelson — ranked #1212
    Quenton Nelson
    Dominant offensive guard regarded as one of the best linemen of his generation.
    284pts
  13. Raymond Berry — ranked #1313
    Raymond Berry
    Hall of Fame receiver renowned for precise route-running in the franchise's Baltimore era.
    0pts
  14. Dallas Clark — ranked #1414
    Dallas Clark
    Versatile tight end who was a key red-zone target during the team's Super Bowl run.
    0pts

#Football578#Players574#NFL52#Indianapolis Colts1

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first!

Make your own rankingAny question with 2–50 answers. AI fills in options and pictures in a minute.Create →Add rankings to your siteEmbed any ranking. Your readers vote right on your page.How it works →