The 14 Greatest Indianapolis Colts Players of All Time

From Baltimore-era legends to Lucas Oil Stadium stars, this franchise's history spans Hall of Famers and record-breaking rookies alike. Who tops your list?

1

Peyton Manning

Four-time NFL MVP quarterback who led the Colts to a Super Bowl title and set franchise passing records.

1000pts

2

Johnny Unitas

Pioneering quarterback who won three NFL championships and redefined the passing game.

829pts

3

Andrew Luck

Franchise quarterback known for gritty performances and a surprise early retirement.

609pts

4

Gino Marchetti

Dominant defensive end considered one of the greatest pass rushers of the pre-merger NFL.

473pts

5

Eric Dickerson

Hall of Fame running back who brought his explosive rushing style to Indianapolis in the late 1980s.

473pts

6

Lenny Moore

Hall of Fame halfback and flanker who starred for the franchise's championship teams in Baltimore.

387pts

7

Robert Mathis

Relentless outside linebacker who paired with Dwight Freeney to form a fearsome pass-rush duo.

387pts

8

Marvin Harrison

Hall of Fame wide receiver and one of Peyton Manning's most prolific targets.

284pts

9

Edgerrin James

Powerful running back who led the NFL in rushing twice in his early Colts career.

284pts

10

Dwight Freeney

Dominant pass rusher famous for his signature spin move off the edge.

284pts

11

Adam Vinatieri

Clutch placekicker who became the franchise's all-time leading scorer after years with the Patriots.

284pts

12

Quenton Nelson

Dominant offensive guard regarded as one of the best linemen of his generation.

284pts

13

Raymond Berry

Hall of Fame receiver renowned for precise route-running in the franchise's Baltimore era.

158pts

14

Dallas Clark

Versatile tight end who was a key red-zone target during the team's Super Bowl run.

158pts