You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the best classic American candy?

By YPB Team

Several of these predate the radio, and a few still taste like it.

  1. Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar — ranked #11
    Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar
    The 1900 bar that made milk chocolate affordable in America.
    1000pts
  2. Peeps — ranked #22
    Peeps
    Marshmallow chicks made by Just Born since 1953.
    900pts
  3. Candy corn — ranked #33
    Candy corn
    A Halloween kernel made since the 1880s.
    900pts
  4. Tootsie Roll — ranked #44
    Tootsie Roll
    A chewy chocolate roll first sold in New York in 1907.
    866pts
  5. Good & Plenty — ranked #55
    Good & Plenty
    Candy-coated licorice, one of the oldest US brands.
    692pts
  6. Bit-O-Honey — ranked #66
    Bit-O-Honey
    Honey-flavored taffy with almond bits, from 1924.
    680pts
  7. Mounds — ranked #77
    Mounds
    Coconut and dark chocolate, sold since 1921.
    680pts
  8. Butterfinger — ranked #88
    Butterfinger
    A flaky peanut butter bar introduced in 1923.
    600pts
  9. Snickers — ranked #99
    Snickers
    A Chicago-made peanut bar launched by Mars in 1930.
    507pts
  10. Baby Ruth — ranked #1010
    Baby Ruth
    A 1920 peanut and caramel bar from Chicago.
    507pts
  11. Cracker Jack — ranked #1111
    Cracker Jack
    Caramel corn with a prize, sung about at ballparks.
    400pts
  12. Necco Wafers — ranked #1212
    Necco Wafers
    Chalky pastel discs dating back to 1847.
    400pts
  13. M&M's — ranked #1313
    M&M's
    Candy-coated chocolates first sold to soldiers in 1941.
    400pts
  14. Milky Way — ranked #1414
    Milky Way
    Frank Mars's first national hit, from 1923.
    273pts
  15. Almond Joy — ranked #1515
    Almond Joy
    Coconut, almonds and milk chocolate since 1946.
    273pts
  16. Reese's Peanut Butter Cups — ranked #1616
    Reese's Peanut Butter Cups
    Peanut butter cups invented in Hershey, Pennsylvania, in 1928.
    273pts
  17. Circus Peanuts — ranked #1717
    Circus Peanuts
    Orange, banana-flavored marshmallow peanuts from the 1800s.
    0pts

Comments