What is the best regional American pizza style?

By YPB Team

Coal-fired ovens in Connecticut, blue steel pans in Detroit, cracker crust under Provel in St. Louis. Same three ingredients, thirteen arguments.

  1. Chicago deep-dish — ranked #11
    Chicago deep-dish
    Baked in a high-sided pan with cheese under the sauce, thick enough to eat with a knife and fork.
    1000pts
  2. New York-style — ranked #22
    New York-style
    Wide, foldable hand-tossed slices with a thin crust, sold by the slice across the five boroughs since the early 1900s.
    882pts
  3. California-style — ranked #33
    California-style
    Thin-crust pizza built around non-traditional toppings, popularised in the 1980s by Chez Panisse and Wolfgang Puck.
    794pts
  4. Neapolitan-American — ranked #44
    Neapolitan-American
    The imported original: soft, blistered, wood-fired and finished in ninety seconds, now made in every US city.
    661pts
  5. Grandma pie — ranked #55
    Grandma pie
    Thin rectangular pizza pressed into an oiled sheet pan, a Long Island home-kitchen style that went commercial.
    529pts
  6. St. Louis-style — ranked #66
    St. Louis-style
    Cracker-thin crust topped with processed Provel cheese and cut into small squares rather than wedges.
    448pts
  7. Quad City-style — ranked #77
    Quad City-style
    Malt-laced crust with lean sausage ground into a spiral and slices cut into long strips.
    353pts
  8. Colorado mountain pie — ranked #88
    Colorado mountain pie
    A thick braided crust served with a side of honey, invented in the Rockies for altitude and appetite.
    353pts
  9. Tavern-style — ranked #99
    Tavern-style
    Chicago's other pizza: cracker-crisp, cut into squares, and the version the city actually orders most.
    241pts
  10. New Haven apizza — ranked #1010
    New Haven apizza
    Charred, oblong coal-fired pies from Connecticut, traditionally ordered plain with grated cheese or topped with white clam.
    241pts
  11. Detroit-style — ranked #1111
    Detroit-style
    Rectangular pizza baked in blue steel pans with cheese pushed to the edges to form crisp caramelised corners.
    240pts
  12. Sicilian-style — ranked #1212
    Sicilian-style
    Thick, airy square slices descended from sfincione, common in Italian-American bakeries on the East Coast.
    240pts
  13. Ohio Valley-style — ranked #1313
    Ohio Valley-style
    A Steubenville original where cold cheese and toppings are added after the crust and sauce come out of the oven.
    240pts

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first!

0/1000