Chocolate bars sit next to brittle in a tin and taffy in a Halloween wrapper, all sharing one ingredient.
1Reese's Peanut Butter CupsHershey's milk chocolate cups filled with sweet peanut butter, made since 1928.1000pts
2ButterfingerA crispy, flaky peanut butter core in a chocolatey coating.898pts
3SnickersMars's 1930 bar of nougat, caramel and roasted peanuts in milk chocolate.800pts
45th AvenueCrunchy peanut butter layers in milk chocolate, first sold in 1936.675pts
5Baby RuthPeanuts, caramel and nougat in chocolate, a Chicago bar from 1920.571pts
6WhatchamacallitPeanut-flavored crisp and caramel under a chocolate coating.343pts
7Reese's PiecesPeanut butter candies in a crunchy shell, made famous by E.T.343pts
8ChunkyA thick square of milk chocolate with peanuts and raisins.343pts
9Take 5Pretzels, peanuts, caramel and peanut butter in one Hershey bar.343pts
10Peanut Butter KissesOrange-and-black wrapped peanut butter taffy tied to Halloween bags.0pts
11Peanut brittleHard sugar candy studded with roasted peanuts, a holiday tin staple.0pts




















