You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the best candy for baking?

By YPB Team5 votes

Chips, toffee bits, mints and whole candy bars, each one chopped into somebody's cookie dough.

  1. Chocolate chips — ranked #11
    Chocolate chips
    Semi-sweet morsels behind the classic chocolate chip cookie.
    1000pts
  2. Heath Bar — ranked #22
    Heath Bar
    Toffee bits for cookies, blondies and ice cream cakes.
    960pts
  3. Oreo — ranked #33
    Oreo
    Crushed for pie crusts and cookies-and-cream everything.
    832pts
  4. Reese's Peanut Butter Cups — ranked #44
    Reese's Peanut Butter Cups
    Chopped into brownies, cookie bars and peanut butter pies.
    704pts
  5. Kit Kat — ranked #55
    Kit Kat
    Wafer bars lined up around layer cakes.
    576pts
  6. Andes Mints — ranked #66
    Andes Mints
    Thin mint layers that melt into frosting for mint cookies.
    576pts
  7. Marshmallows — ranked #77
    Marshmallows
    Puffed sugar for s'mores bars, rice treats and rocky road.
    499pts
  8. York Peppermint Patty — ranked #88
    York Peppermint Patty
    Mint patties hidden inside brownies.
    411pts
  9. Snickers — ranked #99
    Snickers
    Folded into cheesecakes, brownies and the Midwest's Snickers salad.
    411pts
  10. Reese's Pieces — ranked #1010
    Reese's Pieces
    Candy-shelled peanut butter bits for cookies and bars.
    411pts
  11. Butterfinger — ranked #1111
    Butterfinger
    Crushed over pies and cupcakes for peanut butter crunch.
    411pts
  12. Rolo — ranked #1212
    Rolo
    Caramel-filled chocolates baked into pretzel bites and cookies.
    310pts
  13. Twix — ranked #1313
    Twix
    Cookie-and-caramel pieces for cheesecake and bars.
    310pts
  14. M&M's — ranked #1414
    M&M's
    Pressed into cookies for color and crunch.
    192pts

Photo credits

Comments 1

Snickers salad, a Midwestern potluck dish of chopped bars and apples, against a cup that goes into brownies and pies: https://youpick.best/articles/reeses-vs-snickers-ranked

YP
ypb-team
Oct 16