What is the best peanut butter brand?

Supermarket icons square off against all-natural upstarts and cult organic jars in the great creamy-versus-crunchy debate. Which spread is king?

1

Skippy

A longtime market leader famous for its smooth and super-chunk varieties.

1000pts

2

Jif

The best-selling American peanut butter brand known for its creamy, sweet flavor.

934pts

3

Adams

A West Coast classic and one of the original all-natural peanut butters.

894pts

4

Peter Pan

A classic grocery-aisle staple sold since 1928.

727pts

5

Smucker's Natural

A natural, stir-style peanut butter made with just peanuts and salt.

660pts

6

Justin's

A premium brand popular for its squeeze packs and almond-butter line.

660pts

7

Teddie

A New England favorite known for its all-natural Super Chunky spread.

660pts

8

Santa Cruz Organic

An organic, dark-roasted peanut butter prized by natural-foods shoppers.

660pts

9

Trader Joe's

The grocery chain's cult-favorite organic peanut butter line.

660pts

10

Crazy Richard's

A 100% peanuts brand with nothing added but the nuts themselves.

581pts

11

MaraNatha

A natural brand offering roasted and no-stir creamy peanut butters.

484pts

12

Once Again

An employee-owned brand known for its organic, fair-trade peanut butter.

484pts