You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the best Halloween candy?

by YPB Team

Chocolate bars have the numbers, but the fruit chews have the true believers. One bowl, no settled order.

  1. Reese's Peanut Butter Cups — ranked #11
    Reese's Peanut Butter Cups
    Milk chocolate cups filled with salty-sweet peanut butter, the most requested candy in American trick-or-treat bags.
    1000pts
  2. Jolly Rancher — ranked #22
    Jolly Rancher
    Long-lasting hard candies in loud fruit flavors that outlive the rest of the haul by weeks.
    608pts
  3. Snickers — ranked #33
    Snickers
    A nougat, caramel and peanut bar under milk chocolate, routinely voted the most satisfying full-size handout.
    518pts
  4. Sour Patch Kids — ranked #44
    Sour Patch Kids
    Sugar-dusted gummy figures that hit sour first and sweet second, a modern Halloween-bowl staple.
    481pts
  5. Twix — ranked #55
    Twix
    A shortbread cookie topped with caramel and dipped in chocolate, sold in twin bars made for splitting.
    440pts
  6. Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar — ranked #66
    Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar
    The plain American chocolate bar that has been handed out on Halloween for more than a century.
    394pts
  7. Starburst — ranked #77
    Starburst
    Square chewy taffy squares in four fruit flavors, famous for the pink one everyone trades for.
    341pts
  8. Swedish Fish — ranked #88
    Swedish Fish
    Red lingonberry-flavored gummy fish, a chewy outsider that quietly has a devoted following.
    341pts
  9. Almond Joy — ranked #99
    Almond Joy
    Shredded coconut and a whole almond under dark chocolate, a polarizing but fiercely defended favorite.
    341pts
  10. Nerds — ranked #1010
    Nerds
    Tiny tangy crystals sold in a two-chamber box, a texture unlike anything else in the bowl.
    281pts
  11. Milky Way — ranked #1111
    Milky Way
    Whipped nougat and caramel in milk chocolate, the softer cousin of the classic American candy bar.
    281pts
  12. M&M's — ranked #1212
    M&M's
    Candy-shelled chocolate lentils that top national surveys as the best-selling Halloween candy in the United States.
    212pts
  13. Kit Kat — ranked #1313
    Kit Kat
    Crisp wafer fingers coated in milk chocolate, prized for being shareable and easy to eat by the handful.
    212pts
  14. Skittles — ranked #1414
    Skittles
    Chewy fruit-flavored pieces in a hard sugar shell, the go-to non-chocolate pick for trick-or-treaters.
    212pts
  15. Butterfinger — ranked #1515
    Butterfinger
    A crisp, flaky peanut butter core in a chocolatey coating that shatters when you bite it.
    212pts
  16. Tootsie Roll — ranked #1616
    Tootsie Roll
    A chewy cocoa-flavored log wrapped in brown and white paper, the cheapest survivor of every candy bowl.
    131pts
  17. Candy corn — ranked #1717
    Candy corn
    The tri-colored honey-and-fondant kernel that has symbolized Halloween since the 1880s and divides every candy bowl.
    131pts
  18. 3 Musketeers — ranked #1818
    3 Musketeers
    A light, airy whipped chocolate nougat bar that is the fluffiest option in the bag.
    0pts

#Brands223#Food101#Candy5#Chocolate4#Halloween5

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first!

Make your own rankingAny question with 2–50 answers. AI fills in options and pictures in a minute.Create →Add rankings to your siteEmbed any ranking. Your readers vote right on your page.How it works →