You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 18 Most Controversial Cars Ever Made

By YPB Team

Cars that made their engineers proud and their owners furious, sometimes in the same model year.

  1. Tesla Cybertruck — ranked #11
    Tesla Cybertruck
    A stainless-steel wedge that split opinion from the moment its window broke on stage.
    1000pts
  2. Pontiac Aztek — ranked #22
    Pontiac Aztek
    A 2001 crossover whose styling is still the standard reference for a design gone wrong.
    999pts
  3. Ford Pinto — ranked #33
    Ford Pinto
    A 1970s subcompact whose fuel-tank design became a landmark product-safety case.
    862pts
  4. Ford Mustang Mach-E — ranked #44
    Ford Mustang Mach-E
    An electric crossover given the Mustang name in 2019, which many owners of the coupe never accepted.
    768pts
  5. Volkswagen Golf TDI — ranked #55
    Volkswagen Golf TDI
    The diesel hatchback at the centre of the 2015 emissions-testing scandal.
    634pts
  6. BMW 7 Series (E65) — ranked #66
    BMW 7 Series (E65)
    Chris Bangle's 2001 saloon, whose rear deck earned its own insult and changed car design anyway.
    634pts
  7. Porsche Cayenne — ranked #77
    Porsche Cayenne
    The SUV purists said would ruin Porsche, and which instead paid for the sports cars.
    550pts
  8. Hummer H2 — ranked #88
    Hummer H2
    A civilian military look-alike that became shorthand for excess in the 2000s.
    476pts
  9. Cadillac Cimarron — ranked #99
    Cadillac Cimarron
    A compact Chevrolet with a Cadillac badge and a Cadillac price, sold in 1982.
    476pts
  10. Ford Mustang II — ranked #1010
    Ford Mustang II
    The 1974 Mustang shrunk onto small-car underpinnings, which sold well and pleased almost no enthusiast.
    476pts
  11. DeLorean DMC-12 — ranked #1111
    DeLorean DMC-12
    A stainless-steel sports car whose company collapsed almost as fast as it launched.
    419pts
  12. Lamborghini Urus — ranked #1212
    Lamborghini Urus
    The SUV that became Lamborghini's best seller within two years of launch.
    419pts
  13. Chevrolet Corvair — ranked #1313
    Chevrolet Corvair
    The rear-engined compact at the centre of Ralph Nader's Unsafe at Any Speed.
    419pts
  14. Ferrari Purosangue — ranked #1414
    Ferrari Purosangue
    Ferrari's four-door, four-seat car, which the company still declines to call an SUV.
    419pts
  15. Fiat Multipla — ranked #1515
    Fiat Multipla
    A people carrier with an extra row of windows and a face nobody forgot.
    0pts
  16. Jaguar X-Type — ranked #1616
    Jaguar X-Type
    A Jaguar built on a Ford Mondeo platform, which buyers noticed immediately.
    0pts
  17. Aston Martin Cygnet — ranked #1717
    Aston Martin Cygnet
    A rebadged Toyota city car sold as an Aston Martin to meet fleet emissions rules.
    0pts
  18. Chrysler PT Cruiser — ranked #1818
    Chrysler PT Cruiser
    A retro-styled hatchback that sold in huge numbers and aged badly in the eyes of critics.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments 1

Ralph Nader put the Corvair on trial in 1965 and Ford recalled 1.5 million Pintos in 1978, so each brand of Ford vs Chevy has an entry it would rather forget; the Ford Mustang nameplate appears twice and the Cadillac Cimarron once.

YP
ypb-team
Aug 25