You Pick BestYouPickBest

Who is the greatest jazz bandleader of all time?

By YPB Team

Running a band is a separate talent from playing in one. Some of these built institutions; others rebuilt their lineup every few years.

  1. Duke Ellington — ranked #11
    Duke Ellington
    Led his orchestra for nearly fifty years and wrote most of its book, treating the band itself as his instrument.
    1000pts
  2. Woody Herman — ranked #22
    Woody Herman
    Reinvented his Herds through five decades of changing styles without losing the band's identity.
    897pts
  3. Fletcher Henderson — ranked #33
    Fletcher Henderson
    Wrote the arranging playbook the entire swing era borrowed, including for Benny Goodman's band.
    636pts
  4. Art Blakey — ranked #44
    Art Blakey
    Ran the Jazz Messengers as a finishing school, launching more careers than any other bandstand in jazz.
    636pts
  5. Dizzy Gillespie — ranked #55
    Dizzy Gillespie
    Took bebop's language into a full big band and opened jazz to Afro-Cuban rhythm.
    538pts
  6. Stan Kenton — ranked #66
    Stan Kenton
    Pushed progressive jazz into orchestral scale, dividing audiences between ambition and bombast.
    538pts
  7. Wynton Marsalis — ranked #77
    Wynton Marsalis
    Directs Jazz at Lincoln Center and its orchestra, the most institutionally powerful bandstand in the music today.
    538pts
  8. John Coltrane — ranked #88
    John Coltrane
    His classic quartet with Tyner, Garrison and Jones is the small group most often called the greatest in jazz.
    418pts
  9. Charles Mingus — ranked #99
    Charles Mingus
    Drove his Jazz Workshop through rehearsal, argument and improvisation into some of the most ambitious writing in the music.
    418pts
  10. Thelonious Monk — ranked #1010
    Thelonious Monk
    Led quartets that bent to his compositions rather than the other way round, most famously with Coltrane in 1957.
    418pts
  11. Sun Ra — ranked #1111
    Sun Ra
    Kept the Arkestra running as a cosmic collective for four decades, complete with costumes, philosophy and communal living.
    418pts
  12. Herbie Hancock — ranked #1212
    Herbie Hancock
    Led acoustic quintets, the Headhunters and electronic projects, changing the band every time the music demanded it.
    418pts
  13. Chick Corea — ranked #1313
    Chick Corea
    Fronted Return to Forever, acoustic trios and Elektric Band projects across five decades of shifting lineups.
    418pts
  14. Count Basie — ranked #1414
    Count Basie
    Built the Kansas City swing machine whose rhythm section set the standard for every big band that followed.
    0pts
  15. Miles Davis — ranked #1515
    Miles Davis
    Assembled and dissolved era-defining bands for four decades, from the First Great Quintet to the electric groups.
    0pts
  16. Benny Goodman — ranked #1616
    Benny Goodman
    The King of Swing whose 1938 Carnegie Hall concert moved jazz into the concert hall and integrated his own bandstand.
    0pts

Comments 1

Running a band is a separate craft: Ellington held an orchestra together for nearly fifty years and wrote most of what it played: https://youpick.best/articles/miles-davis-vs-john-coltrane-ranked

YP
ypb-team
Sep 6