You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the greatest Washington Commanders team of all time?

By YPB Team

Leather-helmet champions, three Super Bowl winners and a recent rookie-led surprise all have a claim to the franchise's best roster.

  1. 1991 Washington Redskins — ranked #11
    1991 Washington Redskins
    A 14–2 team that led the NFL in points scored, went 3–0 in the playoffs and beat Buffalo 37–24 in Super Bowl XXVI with Mark Rypien as MVP.
    1000pts
  2. 1937 Washington Redskins — ranked #22
    1937 Washington Redskins
    The franchise's first season in Washington, with rookie Sammy Baugh at quarterback, ended with a 28–21 win over the Chicago Bears in the NFL Championship Game.
    478pts
  3. 2024 Washington Commanders — ranked #33
    2024 Washington Commanders
    Rookie quarterback Jayden Daniels led a 12–5 team under first-year coach Dan Quinn to playoff wins at Tampa Bay and Detroit and the franchise's first NFC Championship Game since 1991.
    422pts
  4. 1942 Washington Redskins — ranked #44
    1942 Washington Redskins
    Ray Flaherty's 10–1 team beat the previously unbeaten Chicago Bears 14–6 in the NFL Championship Game, avenging the 73–0 title-game loss of 1940.
    357pts
  5. 1986 Washington Redskins — ranked #55
    1986 Washington Redskins
    A 12–4 wild-card team behind Jay Schroeder and Dexter Manley that beat the Rams at home and the Bears in Chicago before losing the NFC Championship Game to the Giants.
    357pts
  6. 1982 Washington Redskins — ranked #66
    1982 Washington Redskins
    In a strike-shortened 8–1 season, Joe Gibbs's team won Super Bowl XVII 27–17 over Miami, with John Riggins named MVP after a 43-yard fourth-quarter touchdown run.
    357pts
  7. 1987 Washington Redskins — ranked #77
    1987 Washington Redskins
    An 11–4 team in a strike year that won Super Bowl XXII 42–10 over Denver, scoring 35 points in the second quarter with Doug Williams named MVP.
    281pts
  8. 1972 Washington Redskins — ranked #88
    1972 Washington Redskins
    George Allen's 11–3 "Over-the-Hill Gang" won the NFC with Larry Brown as league MVP and lost Super Bowl VII 14–7 to the unbeaten Miami Dolphins.
    192pts
  9. 2012 Washington Redskins — ranked #99
    2012 Washington Redskins
    Rookie Robert Griffin III and fellow rookie Alfred Morris led a seven-game winning streak to a 10–6 NFC East title, ended by a wild-card loss to Seattle.
    192pts
  10. 1983 Washington Redskins — ranked #1010
    1983 Washington Redskins
    A 14–2 team that scored a then-NFL-record 541 points, with Joe Theismann as league MVP, before losing Super Bowl XVIII 38–9 to the Los Angeles Raiders.
    192pts

Photo credits

Comments