You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the best New York sports team of all time?

By YPB Team

Baseball royalty, a guaranteed Super Bowl, a 54-year wait for a Cup and a soccer club Pelé made famous. One city, many leagues, one home crowd to win over.

  1. New York Yankees — ranked #11
    New York Yankees
    The Bronx Bombers, 27 World Series titles since their first in 1923.
    1000pts
  2. New York Giants — ranked #22
    New York Giants
    The NFL's Big Blue, eight league titles including four Super Bowls.
    754pts
  3. New York Rangers — ranked #33
    New York Rangers
    An Original Six NHL club, Stanley Cup winners in 1994 after a 54-year wait.
    692pts
  4. New York Mets — ranked #44
    New York Mets
    The Queens club of the 1969 Miracle Mets and the 1986 champions.
    558pts
  5. New York Islanders — ranked #55
    New York Islanders
    The Long Island club that won four straight Stanley Cups from 1980.
    500pts
  6. New York Knicks — ranked #66
    New York Knicks
    Madison Square Garden's NBA team, champions in 1970 and 1973.
    500pts
  7. Brooklyn Dodgers — ranked #77
    Brooklyn Dodgers
    Jackie Robinson's Dodgers, 1955 champions before the move to Los Angeles.
    500pts
  8. New York Jets — ranked #88
    New York Jets
    Joe Namath's Jets, winners of the guaranteed Super Bowl III.
    462pts
  9. New York Liberty — ranked #99
    New York Liberty
    The WNBA's original New York franchise and 2024 champions.
    462pts
  10. New York City FC — ranked #1010
    New York City FC
    The MLS club that won the 2021 MLS Cup in its seventh season.
    417pts
  11. New Jersey Devils — ranked #1111
    New Jersey Devils
    The trap-defense Devils, three Stanley Cups between 1995 and 2003.
    364pts
  12. Brooklyn Nets — ranked #1212
    Brooklyn Nets
    The former New Jersey Nets, back in Brooklyn since 2012.
    364pts
  13. New York Cosmos — ranked #1313
    New York Cosmos
    Pelé's 1970s soccer club that filled Giants Stadium.
    364pts
  14. New York Red Bulls — ranked #1414
    New York Red Bulls
    New York's original MLS club, formerly the MetroStars.
    0pts
  15. New York Giants (baseball) — ranked #1515
    New York Giants (baseball)
    Willie Mays's Polo Grounds club, five World Series titles before 1958.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments 1

Queens has two titles and lost the only Subway Series, in 2000, while the Yankees hold the Bronx half of that debate and the Knicks bring three championships, the number behind Knicks vs Celtics.

YP
ypb-team
Oct 8