You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the greatest scam ever painted?

By YPB Team

Card cheats, fake fortune-tellers, quack surgeons and purse-cutters, each caught mid-trick by a painter between the 1500s and the 1700s. Pick the con you would be least likely to spot.

  1. The Conjurer (Bosch) — ranked #11
    The Conjurer (Bosch)
    Painted around 1502 by Hieronymus Bosch or his workshop and kept in Saint-Germain-en-Laye, it shows a fairground conjurer doing the cups-and-balls trick while an accomplice cuts a spectator's purse; other versions hang in Philadelphia and Jerusalem.
    1000pts
  2. The Cardsharps (Caravaggio) — ranked #22
    The Cardsharps (Caravaggio)
    Caravaggio's canvas of about 1594–97, now in the Kimbell Art Museum in Fort Worth, where an older man reads a young player's hand and signals to a partner who keeps extra cards tucked behind his back.
    926pts
  3. The Card Sharp (La Tour) — ranked #33
    The Card Sharp (La Tour)
    Georges de La Tour's The Card Sharp with the Ace of Diamonds, c. 1636–38, bought by the Louvre in 1972: a player draws the ace from his belt while a courtesan and her maid keep a rich youth busy; an earlier version with the ace of clubs is in the Kimbell.
    778pts
  4. The Misanthrope (Bruegel) — ranked #44
    The Misanthrope (Bruegel)
    Pieter Bruegel the Elder's 1568 tempera in the Capodimonte Museum, Naples: a hooded old man turns his back on the world while a small thief inside a glass orb cuts his purse.
    575pts
  5. The Fortune Teller (Caravaggio) — ranked #55
    The Fortune Teller (Caravaggio)
    Caravaggio painted it twice, around 1594 and 1595 (Capitoline Museums, Rome, and the Louvre): a Romani girl reads a young man's palm and slips the ring off his finger as she does.
    575pts
  6. The Fortune Teller (La Tour) — ranked #66
    The Fortune Teller (La Tour)
    La Tour's canvas of about 1630, bought by the Metropolitan Museum of Art in 1960: as an old woman tells a young man's fortune, one girl takes the purse from his pocket and another cuts a medal from his chain.
    428pts
  7. Cutting the Stone (Bosch) — ranked #77
    Cutting the Stone (Bosch)
    Hieronymus Bosch's panel in the Prado, also called The Extraction of the Stone of Madness, shows a quack surgeon wearing a funnel on his head cutting a supposed stone of folly out of a man's skull.
    428pts
  8. The Quack Doctor (Dou) — ranked #88
    The Quack Doctor (Dou)
    Gerrit Dou's 1652 panel in Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, Rotterdam, of a market quack praising his remedies to villagers, with Dou himself leaning from a window behind.
    428pts
  9. The Tavern Scene (Hogarth) — ranked #99
    The Tavern Scene (Hogarth)
    The third canvas of William Hogarth's A Rake's Progress, painted in the early 1730s and kept at Sir John Soane's Museum, London, where a woman lifts the drunken rake's watch during a night at the Rose Tavern.
    428pts
  10. The Fortune Teller (Manfredi) — ranked #1010
    The Fortune Teller (Manfredi)
    Bartolomeo Manfredi's canvas of about 1616–17 in the Detroit Institute of Arts: while a young man listens to his fortune an accomplice takes his money, and his friend steals a chicken from the fortune-teller.
    0pts
  11. The Cheats (Valentin) — ranked #1111
    The Cheats (Valentin)
    Valentin de Boulogne's Soldiers Playing Cards and Dice, c. 1618–20, in the National Gallery of Art in Washington, takes up Caravaggio's card-cheat theme with a young soldier absorbed in his hand and a tense cheat across the table.
    0pts
  12. Cardsharps and Fortune Teller (Régnier) — ranked #1212
    Cardsharps and Fortune Teller (Régnier)
    Nicolas Régnier's tavern scene of about 1623–26 in the Museum of Fine Arts, Budapest, joins a card cheat and a fortune-teller in one crowded table of victims and thieves.
    0pts
  13. The Quack (Jan Steen) — ranked #1313
    The Quack (Jan Steen)
    Jan Steen's village scene of about 1650–60 in the Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, of a travelling quack selling his cures to a crowd.
    0pts
  14. Ill-Matched Lovers (Massys) — ranked #1414
    Ill-Matched Lovers (Massys)
    Quentin Massys's panel of about 1520–25 in the National Gallery of Art, Washington: a young woman charms an old man and passes his purse to a fool standing behind him.
    0pts

Comments