You Pick BestYouPickBest

Which painting tells its story through where people look?

By YPB Team2 votes

Some of these pictures hide the plot in a glance, others in a pointing finger or a look nobody returns. Follow the eyes and decide which one tells it best.

  1. The Conjurer — ranked #11
    The Conjurer
    Bosch-school panel where the crowd stares at a ball while a thief looking up at the sky cuts a purse.
    1000pts
  2. Las Meninas — ranked #22
    Las Meninas
    Velázquez's 1656 court scene where the painter, the princess and her maids all look out at the king and queen, seen only in a mirror.
    1000pts
  3. The Raft of the Medusa — ranked #33
    The Raft of the Medusa
    Géricault's shipwreck survivors all strain toward a tiny ship on the horizon.
    945pts
  4. The Calling of Saint Matthew — ranked #44
    The Calling of Saint Matthew
    Caravaggio's 1600 scene where Christ points at a tax collector, who looks back as if asking: me?
    862pts
  5. The Cardsharps — ranked #55
    The Cardsharps
    Caravaggio's card game where an older cheat peeks over the victim's shoulder and signals his partner.
    764pts
  6. The Cheat with the Ace of Diamonds — ranked #66
    The Cheat with the Ace of Diamonds
    Georges de La Tour's card game told almost entirely by sideways glances between the cheats.
    647pts
  7. A Bar at the Folies-Bergère — ranked #77
    A Bar at the Folies-Bergère
    Manet's 1882 barmaid stares past us while the mirror behind her shows a man we cannot see in front.
    647pts
  8. The Last Supper (Leonardo) — ranked #88
    The Last Supper (Leonardo)
    Leonardo's mural in Milan where the apostles turn to each other at the words that one of them will betray Christ.
    647pts
  9. Unexpected Visitors — ranked #99
    Unexpected Visitors
    Ilya Repin's 1884 painting of an exile returning home, where every family member meets him with a different look.
    503pts
  10. Olympia — ranked #1010
    Olympia
    Manet's 1863 nude who looks the viewer straight in the eye, which scandalized Paris.
    503pts
  11. The Tête à Tête — ranked #1111
    The Tête à Tête
    Hogarth's newlyweds look anywhere but at each other after a night apart.
    503pts
  12. The Ambassadors — ranked #1212
    The Ambassadors
    Holbein's 1533 double portrait with a stretched skull that only snaps into shape when you look from the side.
    503pts
  13. The Last Supper (Rubens) — ranked #1313
    The Last Supper (Rubens)
    Rubens's Last Supper in the Brera, where Judas alone turns away from Christ and looks at the viewer.
    0pts
  14. American Gothic — ranked #1414
    American Gothic
    Grant Wood's 1930 farmer stares at us while the woman beside him looks away.
    0pts
  15. The Swing — ranked #1515
    The Swing
    Fragonard's rococo swing scene where a young man in the bushes looks up the woman's skirt.
    0pts
  16. Landscape with the Fall of Icarus — ranked #1616
    Landscape with the Fall of Icarus
    A Bruegel-school painting where nobody, not the ploughman nor the shepherd, looks at Icarus falling into the sea.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments