You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the greatest optical illusion painting?

By YPB Team

Renaissance ceilings that open into fake skies share this list with 1960s canvases that seem to bulge and shimmer. Each one was painted to make your eyes argue with your brain.

  1. The Ambassadors (Holbein) — ranked #11
    The Ambassadors (Holbein)
    Hans Holbein the Younger's 1533 double portrait in the National Gallery, London, has a stretched shape across the floor that turns into a skull when seen from the side.
    1000pts
  2. Sant'Ignazio Ceiling (Pozzo) — ranked #22
    Sant'Ignazio Ceiling (Pozzo)
    Andrea Pozzo painted the nave vault of Sant'Ignazio in Rome in 1691–1694 so that, from a marked spot on the floor, the walls seem to rise into open sky.
    815pts
  3. Swans Reflecting Elephants (Dalí) — ranked #33
    Swans Reflecting Elephants (Dalí)
    In Salvador Dalí's 1937 double image, three swans on a lake are mirrored in the water as three elephants.
    778pts
  4. Camera degli Sposi Oculus (Mantegna) — ranked #44
    Camera degli Sposi Oculus (Mantegna)
    In the Ducal Palace of Mantua, Andrea Mantegna finished in 1474 a painted opening in the ceiling where women, a potted plant and winged putti lean over a balustrade into the room.
    736pts
  5. Escaping Criticism (Borrell del Caso) — ranked #55
    Escaping Criticism (Borrell del Caso)
    Pere Borrell del Caso's 1874 canvas, held by the Bank of Spain in Madrid, shows a boy climbing out of the painted frame toward the viewer.
    500pts
  6. The Vegetable Gardener (Arcimboldo) — ranked #66
    The Vegetable Gardener (Arcimboldo)
    Giuseppe Arcimboldo's reversible panel of about 1590 in the Museo Civico Ala Ponzone, Cremona, is a bowl of vegetables that becomes a man's face when turned upside down.
    500pts
  7. Movement in Squares (Riley) — ranked #77
    Movement in Squares (Riley)
    Bridget Riley's 1961 black-and-white painting in the Arts Council Collection narrows a checkerboard toward a point right of centre so the flat surface seems to fold.
    500pts
  8. Slave Market (Dalí) — ranked #88
    Slave Market (Dalí)
    Dalí's 1940 Slave Market with the Disappearing Bust of Voltaire, at the Dalí Museum in St. Petersburg, Florida, lets two women in 17th-century dress and an arch read as Houdon's bust of Voltaire.
    455pts
  9. Metamorphosis of Narcissus (Dalí) — ranked #99
    Metamorphosis of Narcissus (Dalí)
    Dalí's 1937 painting in the Tate collection repeats the crouching figure of Narcissus as a stone hand holding an egg with a narcissus flower.
    400pts
  10. The Blank Signature (Magritte) — ranked #1010
    The Blank Signature (Magritte)
    René Magritte's 1965 canvas at the National Gallery of Art, Washington, shows a rider whose horse passes in front of and behind the same tree trunks at once.
    400pts
  11. The Old Violin (Harnett) — ranked #1111
    The Old Violin (Harnett)
    William Michael Harnett's 1886 trompe-l'oeil, now in the National Gallery of Art in Washington, shows a violin, bow and sheet music hanging on a painted door.
    400pts
  12. Vega-Nor (Vasarely) — ranked #1212
    Vega-Nor (Vasarely)
    Victor Vasarely's 1969 oil on canvas at the Buffalo AKG Art Museum is a grid of circles and squares that appears to bulge out of the picture plane.
    400pts
  13. Sala dei Giganti (Giulio Romano) — ranked #1313
    Sala dei Giganti (Giulio Romano)
    Giulio Romano covered the walls and vault of a room in Palazzo Te, Mantua, in 1532–1535 with giants crushed by falling buildings, so the room itself seems to collapse.
    400pts
  14. Reverse of a Framed Painting (Gysbrechts) — ranked #1414
    Reverse of a Framed Painting (Gysbrechts)
    Around 1670 Cornelis Norbertus Gysbrechts painted the back of a framed canvas, down to its stretcher and a numbered tag; the picture hangs in the National Gallery of Denmark, Copenhagen.
    0pts
  15. Portrait of a Carthusian (Christus) — ranked #1515
    Portrait of a Carthusian (Christus)
    Petrus Christus signed this 1446 portrait, now at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, with a painted fly that appears to sit on the frame.
    0pts
  16. View Down a Corridor (Hoogstraten) — ranked #1616
    View Down a Corridor (Hoogstraten)
    Samuel van Hoogstraten's 1662 perspective painting at Dyrham Park, England, shows a tiled corridor running deep into a house beyond an open door.
    0pts
  17. Holy Trinity (Masaccio) — ranked #1717
    Holy Trinity (Masaccio)
    Masaccio's fresco of about 1427 in Santa Maria Novella, Florence, uses one-point perspective to paint a barrel-vaulted chapel onto a flat wall.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments