You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the greatest New York Red Bulls team of all time?

By YPB Team

Shield winners, two sides that reached MLS Cup and lost, and a striker's record-tying year, all from a club still waiting on its first MLS Cup.

  1. 2013 New York Red Bulls — ranked #11
    2013 New York Red Bulls
    Won the Supporters' Shield at 17–9–8, the club's first major trophy, with Tim Cahill and Thierry Henry in the side.
    1000pts
  2. 2018 New York Red Bulls — ranked #22
    2018 New York Red Bulls
    Won the Supporters' Shield with 22 wins and a then-MLS-record 71 points, and reached the CONCACAF Champions League semifinals.
    909pts
  3. 2010 New York Red Bulls — ranked #33
    2010 New York Red Bulls
    The first season at Red Bull Arena, with Thierry Henry and Rafael Márquez signed mid-year; the 15–9–6 team topped the Eastern Conference.
    500pts
  4. 2015 New York Red Bulls — ranked #44
    2015 New York Red Bulls
    Jesse Marsch's first team won the Supporters' Shield with 60 points and reached the Eastern Conference final, lost to Columbus.
    500pts
  5. 2008 New York Red Bulls — ranked #55
    2008 New York Red Bulls
    Squeezed into the playoffs on the final day at 10–11–9, then knocked out Houston and Real Salt Lake before losing MLS Cup 3–1 to Columbus.
    444pts
  6. 2014 New York Red Bulls — ranked #66
    2014 New York Red Bulls
    Bradley Wright-Phillips scored 27 league goals to tie the MLS record in Henry's final season, and the team reached the Eastern Conference final.
    0pts
  7. 2016 New York Red Bulls — ranked #77
    2016 New York Red Bulls
    Finished top of the Eastern Conference at 16–9–9 as Bradley Wright-Phillips won his second Golden Boot with 24 goals.
    0pts
  8. 2024 New York Red Bulls — ranked #88
    2024 New York Red Bulls
    Entered the playoffs as the East's seventh seed, beat Columbus, NYCFC and Orlando, and lost MLS Cup 2–1 to the LA Galaxy.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments