You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 34 Best Columbus Crew Players of All Time

By YPB Team

Ohio's original MLS club has three championship squads, a Golden Boot winner and plenty of grinders who simply never left; weigh trophies against loyalty however you like.

  1. Brian McBride — ranked #11
    Brian McBride
    U.S. striker who played for Columbus from 1996 to 2003, scored 79 goals in all competitions, a club record, and was the first inductee into the Crew Circle of Honor.
    1000pts
  2. Frankie Hejduk — ranked #22
    Frankie Hejduk
    U.S. international right back who captained Columbus to the 2008 MLS Cup and scored in the final against New York.
    933pts
  3. Wil Trapp — ranked #33
    Wil Trapp
    Homegrown midfielder from Gahanna, Ohio, who made 205 appearances for Columbus and served as club captain.
    933pts
  4. Chad Marshall — ranked #44
    Chad Marshall
    Centre-back who holds the club appearance record with 277 games and was MLS Defender of the Year in 2008 and 2009.
    933pts
  5. Justin Meram — ranked #55
    Justin Meram
    Iraq international winger with 43 goals and 234 appearances for Columbus across two spells.
    800pts
  6. Cucho Hernández — ranked #66
    Cucho Hernández
    Colombian forward who was MVP of the 2023 MLS Cup final and scored 58 goals for the club before his 2025 sale to Real Betis.
    716pts
  7. Robert Warzycha — ranked #77
    Robert Warzycha
    Polish midfielder from the club's first season in 1996 who holds the Crew record with 71 assists and later coached the team.
    618pts
  8. Zack Steffen — ranked #88
    Zack Steffen
    Goalkeeper who won 2018 MLS Goalkeeper of the Year in Columbus before moving to Manchester City.
    618pts
  9. Diego Rossi — ranked #99
    Diego Rossi
    Uruguayan forward who joined in 2023, won MLS Cup that season and has scored 51 goals for the club.
    618pts
  10. Edson Buddle — ranked #1010
    Edson Buddle
    Forward who scored 52 goals for Columbus in all competitions in the early 2000s.
    618pts
  11. Federico Higuaín — ranked #1111
    Federico Higuaín
    Argentine playmaker who spent 2012 to 2019 in Columbus and posted 59 goals and 69 assists in all competitions.
    618pts
  12. Guillermo Barros Schelotto — ranked #1212
    Guillermo Barros Schelotto
    Argentine forward who joined in 2007 and was both the 2008 MLS MVP and MVP of the 2008 MLS Cup final.
    500pts
  13. Gyasi Zardes — ranked #1313
    Gyasi Zardes
    U.S. forward who scored 61 goals for Columbus from 2018 to 2022, including the 2020 MLS Cup-winning season.
    500pts
  14. Aidan Morris — ranked #1414
    Aidan Morris
    Homegrown midfielder who started for the 2023 MLS Cup champions before a 2024 transfer to Middlesbrough.
    500pts
  15. Harrison Afful — ranked #1515
    Harrison Afful
    Ghana international right back who joined in 2015 and won the 2020 MLS Cup with Columbus.
    500pts
  16. Darlington Nagbe — ranked #1616
    Darlington Nagbe
    Midfielder who joined in 2020 and won MLS Cup with Columbus in 2020 and 2023, later serving as club captain.
    500pts
  17. Stern John — ranked #1717
    Stern John
    Trinidad and Tobago striker who won the 1998 MLS Golden Boot with 26 league goals for Columbus.
    444pts
  18. Brian Maisonneuve — ranked #1818
    Brian Maisonneuve
    U.S. international midfielder who played his whole MLS career in Columbus, with 208 appearances and 41 assists.
    444pts
  19. Jon Busch — ranked #1919
    Jon Busch
    Starting goalkeeper of the 2004 Supporters' Shield-winning team and a finalist for that year's MLS Goalkeeper of the Year award.
    444pts
  20. Jonathan Mensah — ranked #2020
    Jonathan Mensah
    Ghana international centre-back who captained Columbus to the 2020 MLS Cup title.
    444pts
  21. Yaw Yeboah — ranked #2121
    Yaw Yeboah
    Ghanaian winger who scored the second goal in Columbus's 2-1 win over LAFC in the 2023 MLS Cup final.
    444pts
  22. Pedro Santos — ranked #2222
    Pedro Santos
    Portuguese winger with 35 assists for Columbus, who had six goals and eight assists in the 2020 title season but missed the final after a positive COVID-19 test.
    444pts
  23. Duncan Oughton — ranked #2323
    Duncan Oughton
    New Zealand international who spent his entire MLS career with Columbus from 2001 to 2010, including the 2008 title.
    444pts
  24. Jeff Cunningham — ranked #2424
    Jeff Cunningham
    Forward who scored 74 goals in 243 appearances for Columbus, second on the club's all-time scoring list.
    0pts
  25. Lucas Zelarayán — ranked #2525
    Lucas Zelarayán
    Argentine-born Armenia international who scored twice in the 2020 MLS Cup final and was named its MVP.
    0pts
  26. Kei Kamara — ranked #2626
    Kei Kamara
    Sierra Leone striker who scored 22 league goals in 2015, tied for the MLS lead, as Columbus reached MLS Cup.
    0pts
  27. William Hesmer — ranked #2727
    William Hesmer
    Goalkeeper who started for Columbus in its 2008 MLS Cup final win over New York.
    0pts
  28. Ethan Finlay — ranked #2828
    Ethan Finlay
    Winger who started all 34 league games in 2015 with 12 goals and 13 assists, earning MLS Best XI honours as Columbus reached MLS Cup.
    0pts
  29. Artur — ranked #2929
    Artur
    Brazilian defensive midfielder who anchored the 2020 MLS Cup-winning side.
    0pts
  30. Eloy Room — ranked #3030
    Eloy Room
    Curaçao goalkeeper who started for Columbus in the 2020 MLS Cup final win over Seattle.
    0pts
  31. Patrick Schulte — ranked #3131
    Patrick Schulte
    Goalkeeper who started for Columbus in its 2023 MLS Cup final win over LAFC.
    0pts
  32. 32
    Mike Clark
    Indianapolis-born defender who played for Columbus from 1996 to 2003, making 265 appearances in all competitions, second in club history.
    0pts
  33. Eddie Gaven — ranked #3333
    Eddie Gaven
    Midfielder who made 241 appearances for Columbus, won the 2008 MLS Cup and retired in October 2013, days after turning 27.
    0pts
  34. Alejandro Moreno — ranked #3434
    Alejandro Moreno
    Venezuelan forward who scored the opening goal of the 2008 MLS Cup final for Columbus.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments