Expansion-year originals line up against the side that ran away with a Supporters' Shield. Pick the one Geodis Park would cheer loudest.
1Hany MukhtarGerman attacking midfielder who won the 2022 MLS MVP and Golden Boot for Nashville.1000pts
2Patrick YazbekAustralian midfielder who became a fixture in Nashville's midfield.927pts
3Aníbal GodoyPanamanian midfielder who anchored Nashville's midfield from 2020.800pts
4Dax McCartyVeteran midfielder who captained Nashville in its first MLS seasons from 2020.709pts
5Randall LealCosta Rican winger and creative outlet in Nashville's early MLS seasons.600pts
6CJ SapongStriker who scored the club's first goals in its debut MLS season in 2020.600pts
7Dave RomneyCentre-back who partnered Zimmerman in the league's stingiest defence of 2020-2022.600pts
8Brian SchwakeGoalkeeper who kept 15 clean sheets in the 2026 Supporters' Shield season.600pts
9Sam SurridgeEnglish striker who became Nashville's main goal threat after arriving in 2024.600pts
10Walker ZimmermanCentre-back and captain who won MLS Defender of the Year twice with Nashville.466pts
11Daniel LovitzLeft-back who started for Nashville from its first MLS game and played for the US national team.466pts
12Alex MuylVersatile wide player who gave Nashville years of energy on either flank.466pts
13Jeisson PalaciosColombian centre-back central to Nashville's build-up in the 2026 Shield campaign.466pts
14Jack MaherCentre-back drafted in 2020 who grew into a regular starter in Nashville's back line.466pts
15Jacob ShaffelburgCanadian winger whose pace made him a key attacker and a Canada regular.466pts
16Shaq MooreUS international right-back who joined in 2022 and starred down the right side.0pts
17Andy NájarHonduran full-back who brought experience to the 2026 Supporters' Shield side.0pts
Photo credits
- Sam Surridge — Bryan Berlin, CC BY-SA 4.0
- Jack Maher — Bryan Berlin, CC BY-SA 4.0
- Jacob Shaffelburg — Bryan Berlin, CC BY-SA 4.0
