You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the best MLS rivalry?

By YPB Team

Hatred runs deep in some of these and is half marketing in others, with grudges older than the league itself next to derbies that only began in the last decade.

  1. Sounders vs. Timbers — ranked #11
    Sounders vs. Timbers
    Seattle Sounders against Portland Timbers, a Cascadia rivalry that dates to the clubs' NASL meetings in 1975 and is fought for the supporter-run Cascadia Cup.
    1000pts
  2. Hudson River Derby — ranked #22
    Hudson River Derby
    New York Red Bulls against New York City FC, a New York-area derby first played in MLS in 2015.
    843pts
  3. Atlantic Cup — ranked #33
    Atlantic Cup
    D.C. United against the New York Red Bulls, an original-1996 MLS rivalry contested for the Atlantic Cup trophy.
    539pts
  4. El Tráfico — ranked #44
    El Tráfico
    LA Galaxy against LAFC, a Los Angeles derby that began in 2018 when LAFC joined MLS and Zlatan Ibrahimović scored twice on debut in a 4-3 Galaxy comeback.
    539pts
  5. Hell Is Real Derby — ranked #55
    Hell Is Real Derby
    Columbus Crew against FC Cincinnati, an Ohio rivalry named after a 'Hell Is Real' billboard on Interstate 71 between the two cities.
    539pts
  6. Florida Derby — ranked #66
    Florida Derby
    Inter Miami against Orlando City, an in-state rivalry played in MLS since Inter Miami's first season in 2020.
    481pts
  7. California Clásico — ranked #77
    California Clásico
    LA Galaxy against San Jose Earthquakes, a north-versus-south California rivalry between two founding MLS clubs dating to 1996.
    438pts
  8. Rocky Mountain Cup — ranked #88
    Rocky Mountain Cup
    Colorado Rapids against Real Salt Lake, a Rocky Mountain rivalry contested since 2005 for a supporter-created trophy.
    438pts
  9. Canadian Classique — ranked #99
    Canadian Classique
    Toronto FC against CF Montréal, a rivalry between Canada's two largest cities that has been played in MLS since Montréal joined in 2012.
    385pts
  10. Timbers vs. Whitecaps — ranked #1010
    Timbers vs. Whitecaps
    Portland Timbers against Vancouver Whitecaps, a Cascadia rivalry rooted in the 1970s NASL and renewed in MLS in 2011.
    385pts
  11. Texas Derby — ranked #1111
    Texas Derby
    Houston Dynamo against FC Dallas, an in-state rivalry played since 2006 for the El Capitán trophy, a replica cannon.
    0pts
  12. Trillium Cup — ranked #1212
    Trillium Cup
    Columbus Crew against Toronto FC, a rivalry played since 2008 for a trophy named after the trillium, Ontario's provincial flower and Ohio's state wildflower.
    0pts
  13. Sounders vs. Whitecaps — ranked #1313
    Sounders vs. Whitecaps
    Seattle Sounders against Vancouver Whitecaps, a cross-border Cascadia rivalry between cities about 140 miles apart, played in MLS since 2011.
    0pts
  14. Brimstone Cup — ranked #1414
    Brimstone Cup
    Chicago Fire against FC Dallas, a rivalry contested since 2001 for a trophy created by the two clubs' supporters.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments