You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the best Christmas cookie?

By YPB Team

Old recipes from Germany, Greece and Norway sit beside the American cookie-swap regulars, and several of them need a special iron or carved mould to make.

  1. Gingerbread Man — ranked #11
    Gingerbread Man
    Cookie cut in a human shape from spiced gingerbread dough and usually decorated with icing.
    1000pts
  2. Sugar Cookie — ranked #22
    Sugar Cookie
    Rolled dough of butter, sugar and flour cut into holiday shapes and decorated with icing or sprinkles.
    810pts
  3. Snickerdoodle — ranked #33
    Snickerdoodle
    Butter cookie rolled in cinnamon sugar before baking, traditionally made with cream of tartar.
    636pts
  4. Vanillekipferl — ranked #44
    Vanillekipferl
    Crescent-shaped Austrian and German cookie made with ground nuts and dusted with vanilla sugar.
    598pts
  5. Speculaas — ranked #55
    Speculaas
    Spiced shortcrust cookie from the Netherlands and Belgium, stamped with images and traditionally eaten around St. Nicholas' Day.
    555pts
  6. Gingersnap — ranked #66
    Gingersnap
    Crisp cookie flavoured with ground ginger and molasses.
    454pts
  7. Spritz — ranked #77
    Spritz
    German butter cookie pushed through a cookie press into shapes such as wreaths, trees and stars.
    454pts
  8. Rosette — ranked #88
    Rosette
    Thin, crisp Scandinavian cookie made by dipping a decorative iron into batter and then into hot oil.
    454pts
  9. Krumkake — ranked #99
    Krumkake
    Norwegian waffle cookie baked on a decorative iron and rolled into a cone while still warm.
    454pts
  10. Pfeffernüsse — ranked #1010
    Pfeffernüsse
    Small spiced cookies, often with black pepper and a sugar glaze, eaten at Christmas in Germany and Denmark and around Sinterklaas in the Netherlands.
    454pts
  11. Pizzelle — ranked #1111
    Pizzelle
    Thin Italian waffle cookie from Abruzzo, pressed in a patterned iron and often flavoured with anise.
    394pts
  12. Springerle — ranked #1212
    Springerle
    Anise-flavoured German cookie with a picture pressed into the dough by a carved mould or rolling pin.
    394pts
  13. Linzer Cookie — ranked #1313
    Linzer Cookie
    Nut shortbread sandwich cookie with a cut-out top that shows the jam filling, modelled on the Austrian Linzer torte.
    394pts
  14. Thumbprint Cookie — ranked #1414
    Thumbprint Cookie
    Butter cookie with a hollow pressed into the centre and filled with jam.
    394pts
  15. Lebkuchen — ranked #1515
    Lebkuchen
    German spiced honey cookie closely associated with Nuremberg, whose Nürnberger Lebkuchen has EU protected geographical status.
    394pts
  16. Zimtstern — ranked #1616
    Zimtstern
    Star-shaped German cookie of ground almonds and cinnamon with a meringue glaze.
    394pts
  17. Biscochito — ranked #1717
    Biscochito
    Anise-and-cinnamon butter cookie that New Mexico adopted as its official state cookie in 1989.
    394pts
  18. Peanut Butter Blossom — ranked #1818
    Peanut Butter Blossom
    Peanut butter cookie with a Hershey's Kiss pressed into the top, entered in the 1957 Pillsbury Bake-Off by Freda Smith of Ohio.
    324pts
  19. Melomakarona — ranked #1919
    Melomakarona
    Greek Christmas cookie made with olive oil, soaked in honey syrup and topped with chopped walnuts.
    324pts
  20. Kourabiedes — ranked #2020
    Kourabiedes
    Greek almond butter cookie coated in powdered sugar and made for Christmas.
    151pts
  21. Kolaczki — ranked #2121
    Kolaczki
    Polish-style cookie of cream-cheese dough folded around a jam filling.
    151pts
  22. Chocolate Crinkle — ranked #2222
    Chocolate Crinkle
    Fudgy chocolate cookie rolled in powdered sugar before baking so the surface cracks in the oven.
    151pts
  23. Mexican Wedding Cookie — ranked #2323
    Mexican Wedding Cookie
    Crumbly butter cookie made with ground nuts and rolled in powdered sugar, also known as a Russian tea cake.
    0pts
  24. Shortbread — ranked #2424
    Shortbread
    Scottish biscuit of butter, sugar and flour, traditionally baked for Christmas and Hogmanay.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments