Huge subscriber counts do not guarantee universal love. Pick the creator whose hype outruns the work.
1Jake PaulDisney Channel actor turned YouTuber and professional boxer.1000pts
2MrBeastThe platform's biggest channel, criticised for formula-driven spectacle.926pts
3Logan PaulVlogger turned wrestler whose career has run from controversy to controversy.575pts
4Shane DawsonEarly YouTube star known for conspiracy series and documentaries.575pts
5KSIBritish creator who spread from FIFA videos to music, boxing and drinks.575pts
6David DobrikVlog Squad leader known for fast-cut prank vlogs.575pts
7JacksepticeyeIrish gaming creator known for loud, high-energy commentary.428pts
8James CharlesBeauty YouTuber and the first male CoverGirl ambassador.428pts
9Lilly SinghSketch comedian who moved from YouTube to network late-night TV.428pts
10MarkiplierLet's-play star with a famously loyal fan base.0pts
11PewDiePieFormer most-subscribed creator whose fame outgrew his early let's-plays.0pts
12Emma ChamberlainVlogger whose casual style spawned countless imitators.0pts
13Casey NeistatDaily vlogger whose cinematic style became a template.0pts
14ZoellaBritish lifestyle vlogger whose products drew mixed reviews.0pts
Photo credits
- MrBeast — Fidias, CC BY 3.0
- Logan Paul — Diego Serrano, CC BY 2.0
- Shane Dawson — The Bui Brothers, CC BY 2.0
- KSI — MILLION DOLLAZ WORTH OF GAME, CC BY 3.0
- David Dobrik — ADHD w/ Travis Mills, CC BY 3.0
- Jacksepticeye — Gage Skidmore, CC BY-SA 3.0
- James Charles — Stay Tuned, CC BY 3.0
- Lilly Singh — Jay Dixit, CC BY 4.0
- Markiplier — Ethan Nestor, CC BY 3.0
- PewDiePie — Cold Ones Clips, CC BY 3.0
- Emma Chamberlain — John Park, CC BY 3.0
- Casey Neistat — Tessa Bury, CC BY 4.0
- Zoella — Gage Skidmore, CC BY-SA 2.0
Comments 4
Every overrated list starts from the most successful names, so YouTube's biggest channel was always going to be on this one: https://youpick.best/articles/mrbeast-ranked-many-ways
Loud reactions are the case against him; a 2018 calendar that raised over $490,000 for cancer research is the case for: https://youpick.best/articles/markiplier-ranked-many-ways
Second place is the good result on this list, and PewDiePie and MrBeast are both on it next to the Paul brothers: https://youpick.best/articles/pewdiepie-vs-mrbeast-ranked
Is overrated a compliment? Both Paul brothers are on this one, CryptoZoo included in the case against Logan: https://youpick.best/articles/logan-paul-ranked-many-ways



















