You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 14 Most Overrated YouTubers

By YPB Team

Huge subscriber counts do not guarantee universal love. Pick the creator whose hype outruns the work.

  1. Jake Paul — ranked #11
    Jake Paul
    Disney Channel actor turned YouTuber and professional boxer.
    1000pts
  2. MrBeast — ranked #22
    MrBeast
    The platform's biggest channel, criticised for formula-driven spectacle.
    926pts
  3. Logan Paul — ranked #33
    Logan Paul
    Vlogger turned wrestler whose career has run from controversy to controversy.
    575pts
  4. Shane Dawson — ranked #44
    Shane Dawson
    Early YouTube star known for conspiracy series and documentaries.
    575pts
  5. KSI — ranked #55
    KSI
    British creator who spread from FIFA videos to music, boxing and drinks.
    575pts
  6. David Dobrik — ranked #66
    David Dobrik
    Vlog Squad leader known for fast-cut prank vlogs.
    575pts
  7. Jacksepticeye — ranked #77
    Jacksepticeye
    Irish gaming creator known for loud, high-energy commentary.
    428pts
  8. James Charles — ranked #88
    James Charles
    Beauty YouTuber and the first male CoverGirl ambassador.
    428pts
  9. Lilly Singh — ranked #99
    Lilly Singh
    Sketch comedian who moved from YouTube to network late-night TV.
    428pts
  10. Markiplier — ranked #1010
    Markiplier
    Let's-play star with a famously loyal fan base.
    0pts
  11. PewDiePie — ranked #1111
    PewDiePie
    Former most-subscribed creator whose fame outgrew his early let's-plays.
    0pts
  12. Emma Chamberlain — ranked #1212
    Emma Chamberlain
    Vlogger whose casual style spawned countless imitators.
    0pts
  13. Casey Neistat — ranked #1313
    Casey Neistat
    Daily vlogger whose cinematic style became a template.
    0pts
  14. Zoella — ranked #1414
    Zoella
    British lifestyle vlogger whose products drew mixed reviews.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments 4

Every overrated list starts from the most successful names, so YouTube's biggest channel was always going to be on this one: https://youpick.best/articles/mrbeast-ranked-many-ways

YP
ypb-team
Sep 30

Loud reactions are the case against him; a 2018 calendar that raised over $490,000 for cancer research is the case for: https://youpick.best/articles/markiplier-ranked-many-ways

YP
ypb-team
Oct 17

Second place is the good result on this list, and PewDiePie and MrBeast are both on it next to the Paul brothers: https://youpick.best/articles/pewdiepie-vs-mrbeast-ranked

YP
ypb-team
Oct 25

Is overrated a compliment? Both Paul brothers are on this one, CryptoZoo included in the case against Logan: https://youpick.best/articles/logan-paul-ranked-many-ways

YP
ypb-team
Oct 25