The 14 Most Overrated YouTubers

Huge subscriber counts do not guarantee universal love. Pick the creator whose hype outruns the work.

1. 1
   MrBeast

   The platform's biggest channel, criticised for formula-driven spectacle.
   1000pts
2. 2
   Zoella

   British lifestyle vlogger whose products drew mixed reviews.
   943pts
3. 3
   PewDiePie

   Former most-subscribed creator whose fame outgrew his early let's-plays.
   840pts
4. 4
   Jacksepticeye

   Irish gaming creator known for loud, high-energy commentary.
   709pts
5. 5
   Shane Dawson

   Early YouTube star known for conspiracy series and documentaries.
   600pts
6. 6
   Casey Neistat

   Daily vlogger whose cinematic style became a template.
   600pts
7. 7
   David Dobrik

   Vlog Squad leader known for fast-cut prank vlogs.
   600pts
8. 8
   Lilly Singh

   Sketch comedian who moved from YouTube to network late-night TV.
   466pts
9. 9
   Logan Paul

   Vlogger turned wrestler whose career has run from controversy to controversy.
   466pts
10. 10
    James Charles

    Beauty YouTuber and the first male CoverGirl ambassador.
    466pts
11. 11
    KSI

    British creator who spread from FIFA videos to music, boxing and drinks.
    0pts
12. 12
    Jake Paul

    Disney Channel actor turned YouTuber and professional boxer.
    0pts
13. 13
    Emma Chamberlain

    Vlogger whose casual style spawned countless imitators.
    0pts
14. 14
    Markiplier

    Let's-play star with a famously loyal fan base.
    0pts

Comments 1