You Pick BestYouPickBest

Top 26 North American Goalkeepers of All Time

By YPB Team

Flamboyant showmen and World Cup heroes guard the goal across CONCACAF. Which keeper comes out on top?

  1. Jorge Campos — ranked #11
    Jorge Campos
    Flamboyant Mexican keeper famed for his colourful kits and acrobatics.
    1000pts
  2. Keylor Navas — ranked #22
    Keylor Navas
    Costa Rican great and Champions League winner with Real Madrid.
    965pts
  3. Lars Hirschfeld — ranked #33
    Lars Hirschfeld
    Canada goalkeeper who won the Golden Glove at the 2002 Gold Cup and was his country's first choice for much of the 2000s.
    832pts
  4. Ignacio Calderón — ranked #44
    Ignacio Calderón
    Chivas legend who kept goal for Mexico at the 1966 and 1970 World Cups, helping El Tri reach the quarter-finals on home soil.
    741pts
  5. Pablo Larios — ranked #55
    Pablo Larios
    Mexico's goalkeeper at the 1986 World Cup on home soil, a Cruz Azul and Puebla idol regarded as one of El Tri's finest keepers.
    680pts
  6. Tim Howard — ranked #66
    Tim Howard
    USA keeper whose record save haul at the 2014 World Cup became legendary.
    611pts
  7. Óscar Pérez — ranked #77
    Óscar Pérez
    Mexico's agile goalkeeper 'El Conejo', who started at the 2002 and 2010 World Cups despite standing only 1.72 metres tall.
    529pts
  8. Nick Rimando — ranked #88
    Nick Rimando
    USA goalkeeper who won the 2013 Gold Cup and retired as MLS's record holder for wins and clean sheets after a long career at Real Salt Lake.
    529pts
  9. Oswaldo Sanchez — ranked #99
    Oswaldo Sanchez
    Long-serving Mexican number one and a reliable shot-stopper.
    433pts
  10. Matt Turner — ranked #1010
    Matt Turner
    Modern USA number one known for sharp reflexes and shot-stopping.
    433pts
  11. Tony Meola — ranked #1111
    Tony Meola
    USA number one at the 1990 and 1994 World Cups.
    433pts
  12. Brad Friedel — ranked #1212
    Brad Friedel
    USA keeper and Premier League great known for his shot-stopping.
    433pts
  13. Brad Guzan — ranked #1313
    Brad Guzan
    Dependable USA keeper and long-time squad member.
    433pts
  14. Guillermo Ochoa — ranked #1414
    Guillermo Ochoa
    Memo Ochoa, Mexico's World Cup hero famed for stunning save displays.
    317pts
  15. Milan Borjan — ranked #1515
    Milan Borjan
    Canada's first-choice goalkeeper who helped his country top CONCACAF qualifying and reach the 2022 World Cup, its first in 36 years.
    317pts
  16. Jaime Penedo — ranked #1616
    Jaime Penedo
    Panamanian keeper and hero of their historic World Cup qualification.
    317pts
  17. Noel Valladares — ranked #1717
    Noel Valladares
    Honduras' long-time captain and goalkeeper, who played at the 2010 and 2014 World Cups and won the Golden Glove at the 2011 Gold Cup.
    317pts
  18. Andre Blake — ranked #1818
    Andre Blake
    Jamaica captain and three-time MLS Goalkeeper of the Year, who won the Golden Glove as the Reggae Boyz reached the 2017 Gold Cup final.
    317pts
  19. Kasey Keller — ranked #1919
    Kasey Keller
    Consistent USA keeper across four World Cup cycles.
    317pts
  20. Pat Onstad — ranked #2020
    Pat Onstad
    Canadian keeper and Gold Cup-winning number one.
    317pts
  21. Antonio Carbajal — ranked #2121
    Antonio Carbajal
    Mexican pioneer and the first player to appear in five World Cups.
    0pts
  22. Alfredo Talavera — ranked #2222
    Alfredo Talavera
    Mexico goalkeeper who starred at the 2017 Confederations Cup and was part of El Tri's squads at the 2014, 2018 and 2022 World Cups.
    0pts
  23. Zack Steffen — ranked #2323
    Zack Steffen
    USA goalkeeper who was MLS Goalkeeper of the Year with Columbus Crew in 2018, then backed up Ederson at Manchester City.
  24. Jesús Corona — ranked #2424
    Jesús Corona
    Cruz Azul goalkeeper who captained Mexico to Olympic gold in 2012, won 54 caps and was in the 2014 and 2018 World Cup squads.
  25. Marcus Hahnemann — ranked #2525
    Marcus Hahnemann
    USA keeper who missed just one game as Reading won the 2005-06 Championship with a record 106 points and reached the top flight for the first time.
  26. Kevin Hartman — ranked #2626
    Kevin Hartman
    Won two MLS Cups with LA Galaxy, was 1999 MLS Goalkeeper of the Year and held the MLS career saves record until Nick Rimando passed him in 2017.

Photo credits

Comments