You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 28 Greatest Premier League Goalkeepers of All Time

By YPB Team5 votes

Record clean-sheet keepers and modern sweeper-keepers all starred in the Premier League. Which one tops it?

  1. Peter Schmeichel — ranked #11
    Peter Schmeichel
    Manchester United's dominant keeper and the cornerstone of the 1999 treble.
    1000pts
  2. Alisson Becker — ranked #22
    Alisson Becker
    Liverpool keeper whose brilliance underpinned title and Champions League wins.
    751pts
  3. David Seaman — ranked #33
    David Seaman
    Arsenal number one famed for his reliability and big saves.
    693pts
  4. Jens Lehmann — ranked #44
    Jens Lehmann
    Arsenal's German number one who played every league match of the unbeaten 2003–04 Invincibles title-winning season.
    603pts
  5. Jordan Pickford — ranked #55
    Jordan Pickford
    Everton and England number one renowned for shot-stopping and distribution, with well over 250 Premier League appearances since 2017.
    586pts
  6. Thomas Sørensen — ranked #66
    Thomas Sørensen
    Dependable Danish keeper who spent over a decade in the Premier League with Sunderland, Aston Villa and Stoke City.
    532pts
  7. Emiliano Martínez — ranked #77
    Emiliano Martínez
    Aston Villa keeper and World Cup winner whose penalty heroics and command of his box helped Villa reach the Champions League.
    532pts
  8. Tim Howard — ranked #88
    Tim Howard
    Long-serving keeper at Manchester United and Everton with great reflexes.
    524pts
  9. David de Gea — ranked #99
    David de Gea
    Manchester United shot-stopper and multiple Player of the Year winner.
    524pts
  10. David James — ranked #1010
    David James
    Liverpool, Aston Villa, West Ham, Manchester City and Portsmouth keeper who made over 570 Premier League appearances and won the 2008 FA Cup with Portsmouth.
    469pts
  11. Petr Cech — ranked #1111
    Petr Cech
    Chelsea's record clean-sheet keeper and one of the league's greatest.
    469pts
  12. Łukasz Fabiański — ranked #1212
    Łukasz Fabiański
    Polish keeper who served Arsenal, Swansea City and West Ham across more than fifteen Premier League seasons, admired for his consistency.
    469pts
  13. Hugo Lloris — ranked #1313
    Hugo Lloris
    Tottenham captain and goalkeeper for more than a decade, making over 350 Premier League appearances and leading Spurs to the 2019 Champions League final.
    469pts
  14. Ederson — ranked #1414
    Ederson
    Manchester City sweeper-keeper renowned for his elite distribution.
    407pts
  15. Mark Schwarzer — ranked #1515
    Mark Schwarzer
    Dependable keeper across a record-length Premier League career.
    407pts
  16. Tim Flowers — ranked #1616
    Tim Flowers
    Blackburn Rovers keeper whose saves were central to Kenny Dalglish's side winning the 1994–95 Premier League title.
    397pts
  17. Ben Foster — ranked #1717
    Ben Foster
    Long-serving keeper of Manchester United, Birmingham, West Brom and Watford whose Premier League career stretched across more than a decade.
    397pts
  18. Joe Hart — ranked #1818
    Joe Hart
    Manchester City number one and four-time Golden Glove winner.
    335pts
  19. Shay Given — ranked #1919
    Shay Given
    Consistent shot-stopper across a long Premier League career, notably at Newcastle.
    335pts
  20. Thibaut Courtois — ranked #2020
    Thibaut Courtois
    Chelsea keeper who won two Premier League titles and the 2016–17 Golden Glove before leaving for Real Madrid.
    313pts
  21. Neville Southall — ranked #2121
    Neville Southall
    Everton's legendary keeper who carried his 1980s brilliance into the early Premier League seasons and won the 1995 FA Cup with the Toffees.
    313pts
  22. David Raya — ranked #2222
    David Raya
    Brentford and Arsenal keeper who won the Premier League Golden Glove in his first two seasons at Arsenal, 2023–24 and 2024–25.
    313pts
  23. Kasper Schmeichel — ranked #2323
    Kasper Schmeichel
    Leicester City keeper and son of Peter Schmeichel who was ever-present in the Foxes' fairytale 2015–16 Premier League title.
    313pts
  24. Edwin van der Sar — ranked #2424
    Edwin van der Sar
    Manchester United keeper whose calm and clean-sheet record set records.
    253pts
  25. Brad Friedel — ranked #2525
    Brad Friedel
    Durable American keeper famed for a record consecutive-appearance run.
    253pts
  26. Jussi Jääskeläinen — ranked #2626
    Jussi Jääskeläinen
    Finnish keeper who spent more than a decade at Bolton Wanderers as a pillar of their Premier League years before joining West Ham.
    213pts
  27. Nick Pope — ranked #2727
    Nick Pope
    Burnley and Newcastle keeper whose clean sheets helped Burnley into Europe and Newcastle into the Champions League.
    213pts
  28. Pepe Reina — ranked #2828
    Pepe Reina
    Liverpool keeper and three-time Golden Glove winner known for distribution.
    156pts

Photo credits

Comments