You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 41 Best North American Defenders of All Time

By YPB Team

Composed ball-players and rugged stoppers from Mexico, the USA, Canada, Honduras, Panama and Costa Rica stake their claim. Who defended best?

  1. Rafael Marquez — ranked #11
    Rafael Marquez
    Mexican captain and elegant ball-playing defender with Barcelona pedigree.
    1000pts
  2. Cristian Gamboa — ranked #22
    Cristian Gamboa
    Costa Rica right-back who started as Los Ticos reached the 2014 World Cup quarter-finals and later played in the Premier League with West Brom.
    999pts
  3. Duilio Davino — ranked #33
    Duilio Davino
    Mexico centre-back who played at the 1998 and 2002 World Cups and won the 1999 Confederations Cup with El Tri.
    780pts
  4. Antonee Robinson — ranked #44
    Antonee Robinson
    Fulham's attacking left-back who started all four USA matches at the 2022 World Cup and became one of the Premier League's most creative defenders.
    743pts
  5. Alphonso Davies — ranked #55
    Alphonso Davies
    Canada's captain and Bayern Munich left-back, who won the 2020 Champions League and scored Canada's first-ever men's World Cup goal in 2022.
    673pts
  6. Hector Moreno — ranked #66
    Hector Moreno
    Reliable Mexican centre-back with extensive European experience.
    593pts
  7. Sergiño Dest — ranked #77
    Sergiño Dest
    USA right-back who joined Barcelona from Ajax and started at the 2022 World Cup, setting up Christian Pulisic's winner against Iran.
    593pts
  8. Marcelo Balboa — ranked #88
    Marcelo Balboa
    Pioneering USA centre-back famed for his bicycle kicks.
    593pts
  9. Román Torres — ranked #99
    Román Torres
    Panama captain whose late goal against Costa Rica in 2017 sent his country to its first World Cup.
    593pts
  10. Claudio Suarez — ranked #1010
    Claudio Suarez
    El Emperador, Mexico's second most-capped player and a dependable centre-back.
    500pts
  11. Oguchi Onyewu — ranked #1111
    Oguchi Onyewu
    Powerful, physically imposing USA centre-back.
    500pts
  12. Steve Cherundolo — ranked #1212
    Steve Cherundolo
    Dependable USA right-back and long-serving Bundesliga performer.
    500pts
  13. Carlos Bocanegra — ranked #1313
    Carlos Bocanegra
    USA captain and reliable centre-back of the 2000s and 2010s.
    500pts
  14. Frankie Hejduk — ranked #1414
    Frankie Hejduk
    USA's tireless right-sided defender, who played at the 1998 and 2002 World Cups and captained Columbus Crew to the 2008 MLS Cup.
    500pts
  15. Omar Gonzalez — ranked #1515
    Omar Gonzalez
    Towering USA centre-back who started at the 2014 World Cup and won three MLS Cups with LA Galaxy and another with Toronto FC.
    500pts
  16. Johan Vásquez — ranked #1616
    Johan Vásquez
    Genoa centre-back who became a mainstay of Mexico's defence in the 2020s, winning the Gold Cup in 2023 and 2025.
    500pts
  17. Jesús Gallardo — ranked #1717
    Jesús Gallardo
    Mexico left-back who started at the 2018 and 2022 World Cups and won several Gold Cups with El Tri.
    500pts
  18. DaMarcus Beasley — ranked #1818
    DaMarcus Beasley
    Versatile USA player and the first American to play in four World Cups.
    455pts
  19. John Brooks — ranked #1919
    John Brooks
    USA centre-back remembered for his late winner at the 2014 World Cup.
    455pts
  20. Alexi Lalas — ranked #2020
    Alexi Lalas
    USA's red-bearded centre-back at the 1994 World Cup, who became the first American to play in Serie A with Padova.
    455pts
  21. Diego Reyes — ranked #2121
    Diego Reyes
    Mexican defender comfortable at centre-back or in midfield.
    455pts
  22. Jeff Agoos — ranked #2222
    Jeff Agoos
    USA defender who earned 134 caps, played at the 2002 World Cup and won five MLS Cups with D.C. United and San Jose.
    455pts
  23. Carlos Salcido — ranked #2323
    Carlos Salcido
    Versatile Mexican defender comfortable across the back line.
    400pts
  24. Eddie Pope — ranked #2424
    Eddie Pope
    Composed USA centre-back and three-time World Cup participant.
    400pts
  25. Cesar Montes — ranked #2525
    Cesar Montes
    Modern Mexican centre-back known for his aerial strength.
    400pts
  26. Matt Besler — ranked #2626
    Matt Besler
    Sporting Kansas City captain who started at centre-back for the USA at the 2014 World Cup and lifted the 2013 MLS Cup.
    400pts
  27. Tim Ream — ranked #2727
    Tim Ream
    Veteran USA centre-back who started every match at the 2022 World Cup and became a long-serving Fulham leader in the Premier League.
    400pts
  28. Gustavo Peña — ranked #2828
    Gustavo Peña
    Mexico's commanding centre-back of the 1960s, who captained El Tri as hosts at the 1970 World Cup.
    400pts
  29. Víctor Bernárdez — ranked #2929
    Víctor Bernárdez
    Honduras' commanding centre-back at the 2010 and 2014 World Cups, later a long-time stalwart of San Jose Earthquakes in MLS.
    400pts
  30. Maynor Figueroa — ranked #3030
    Maynor Figueroa
    Honduras' record appearance holder, a versatile defender who played at two World Cups and won the 2013 FA Cup with Wigan Athletic.
    400pts
  31. Óscar Duarte — ranked #3131
    Óscar Duarte
    Costa Rica centre-back who scored against Uruguay at the 2014 World Cup, sealing a shock 3-1 win on the way to the quarter-finals.
    400pts
  32. DeAndre Yedlin — ranked #3232
    DeAndre Yedlin
    Speedy USA right-back who played at the 2014 World Cup as a 20-year-old and returned for the 2022 tournament.
    0pts
  33. Paul Caligiuri — ranked #3333
    Paul Caligiuri
    USA defender and midfielder with 110 caps whose 1989 'Shot heard round the world' against Trinidad and Tobago sent the team to its first World Cup since 1950.
  34. Francisco Javier Rodríguez — ranked #3434
    Francisco Javier Rodríguez
    Mexico centre-back known as Maza, who played at three World Cups and moved from Guadalajara to PSV Eindhoven and VfB Stuttgart in Europe.
  35. Ricardo Osorio — ranked #3535
    Ricardo Osorio
    Mexico defender who played all four matches at the 2006 World Cup, then joined VfB Stuttgart and won the 2006-07 Bundesliga, playing 27 of 34 league games.
  36. Walker Zimmerman — ranked #3636
    Walker Zimmerman
    Two-time MLS Defender of the Year with Nashville SC who appeared in every USA game at the 2022 World Cup.
  37. Jay DeMerit — ranked #3737
    Jay DeMerit
    Climbed from English non-league football to head Watford's opener in the 2006 play-off final, then started all four USA matches at the 2010 World Cup.
  38. Chris Richards — ranked #3838
    Chris Richards
    FC Dallas academy product who helped Crystal Palace win the 2025 FA Cup and 2026 Conference League, then played for the USA at the 2026 World Cup.
  39. Giancarlo González — ranked #3939
    Giancarlo González
    Costa Rica's centre-back on the run to the 2014 World Cup quarter-finals, who then moved to Serie A with Palermo and Bologna.
  40. Kendall Waston — ranked #4040
    Kendall Waston
    Costa Rica centre-back and former Vancouver Whitecaps captain whose header against Switzerland in 2018 ended the team's run of 424 World Cup minutes without a goal.
  41. Alistair Johnston — ranked #4141
    Alistair Johnston
    Canada's right-back at the 2022 and 2026 World Cups, who joined Celtic in January 2023 and has won Scottish Premiership titles there.

Photo credits

Comments