You Pick BestYouPickBest

Who is the best MLB player born in 1991?

By YPB Team

Born in 1991, this class mixes MVP and Cy Young winners with relievers and utility men whose fame rests on one big October or a single All-Star summer.

  1. Mike Trout — ranked #11
    Mike Trout
    Los Angeles Angels outfielder born August 7, 1991, three-time AL MVP (2014, 2016, 2019) and 2012 AL Rookie of the Year.
    1000pts
  2. Nolan Arenado — ranked #22
    Nolan Arenado
    Third baseman born April 16, 1991, who won a Gold Glove in each of his first ten seasons (2013-2022) with the Rockies and Cardinals.
    959pts
  3. J.T. Realmuto — ranked #33
    J.T. Realmuto
    Catcher born March 18, 1991, who played for the Marlins and Phillies and in 2022 became the second catcher, after Ivan Rodriguez, with 20 home runs and 20 steals in a season.
    816pts
  4. Kevin Gausman — ranked #44
    Kevin Gausman
    Right-hander born January 6, 1991, the fourth overall pick in 2012, a 2021 All-Star with the Giants and the 2023 AL strikeout leader (237) with Toronto.
    787pts
  5. Christian Yelich — ranked #55
    Christian Yelich
    Outfielder born December 5, 1991, the 2018 NL MVP with the Brewers and NL batting champion in 2018 and 2019.
    717pts
  6. Yandy Díaz — ranked #66
    Yandy Díaz
    Cuban infielder born August 8, 1991, who won the 2023 AL batting title with a .330 average for the Rays.
    625pts
  7. Yusei Kikuchi — ranked #77
    Yusei Kikuchi
    Japanese left-hander born June 17, 1991, who came to MLB from the Seibu Lions in 2019 and was a 2021 All-Star with the Mariners.
    625pts
  8. Jonathan Schoop — ranked #88
    Jonathan Schoop
    Second baseman from Curaçao born October 16, 1991, a 2017 All-Star with the Orioles after hitting 32 home runs with 105 RBI.
    625pts
  9. Robbie Ray — ranked #99
    Robbie Ray
    Left-hander born October 1, 1991, who won the 2021 AL Cy Young Award with Toronto after leading the league in ERA (2.84) and strikeouts (248).
    625pts
  10. Marcus Stroman — ranked #1010
    Marcus Stroman
    Right-hander born May 1, 1991, MVP of the 2017 World Baseball Classic for Team USA, 2017 Gold Glove winner and an All-Star in 2019 and 2023.
    625pts
  11. Eddie Rosario — ranked #1111
    Eddie Rosario
    Puerto Rican outfielder born September 28, 1991, who played six seasons for the Twins and was the 2021 NLCS MVP for the champion Braves.
    625pts
  12. Mitch Garver — ranked #1212
    Mitch Garver
    Catcher born January 15, 1991, who hit 31 home runs and won a Silver Slugger for the Twins in 2019, then won the 2023 World Series with Texas.
    568pts
  13. Eugenio Suárez — ranked #1313
    Eugenio Suárez
    Venezuelan third baseman born July 18, 1991, who hit 49 home runs for the Reds in 2019 and was an All-Star in 2018 and 2025.
    568pts
  14. Odúbel Herrera — ranked #1414
    Odúbel Herrera
    Venezuelan center fielder born December 29, 1991, taken by the Phillies in the 2014 Rule 5 draft and a 2016 All-Star.
    500pts
  15. Wilmer Flores — ranked #1515
    Wilmer Flores
    Venezuelan infielder born August 6, 1991, remembered for crying on the field after a voided Mets trade in July 2015, and later a regular for the Giants.
    500pts
  16. Adam Frazier — ranked #1616
    Adam Frazier
    Infielder born December 14, 1991, who was a 2021 All-Star with the Pirates.
    500pts
  17. Trevor Bauer — ranked #1717
    Trevor Bauer
    Right-hander born January 17, 1991, who won the 2020 NL Cy Young Award with the Reds after posting a 1.73 ERA in the shortened season.
    500pts
  18. Carlos Martínez — ranked #1818
    Carlos Martínez
    Dominican right-hander born September 21, 1991, who spent nine seasons with the Cardinals and was an All-Star in 2015 and 2017.
    500pts
  19. Avisaíl García — ranked #1919
    Avisaíl García
    Venezuelan outfielder born June 12, 1991, a 2017 All-Star with the White Sox after batting .330 that season.
    500pts
  20. Jonathan Villar — ranked #2020
    Jonathan Villar
    Dominican infielder born May 2, 1991, who led the majors with 62 stolen bases for the Brewers in 2016.
    500pts
  21. Jameson Taillon — ranked #2121
    Jameson Taillon
    Right-hander born November 18, 1991, the second overall pick in 2010, who returned from testicular cancer surgery in 2017 and later pitched for the Yankees and Cubs.
    500pts
  22. Kiké Hernández — ranked #2222
    Kiké Hernández
    Puerto Rican utility player born August 24, 1991, who won World Series titles with the Dodgers in 2020, 2024 and 2025 and hit three home runs in the 2017 NLCS clincher.
    440pts
  23. Martín Pérez — ranked #2323
    Martín Pérez
    Venezuelan left-hander born April 4, 1991, who spent most of his career with the Rangers and was a 2022 All-Star.
    440pts
  24. Robert Suarez — ranked #2424
    Robert Suarez
    Venezuelan reliever born March 1, 1991, who saved games for Hanshin in Japan before closing for the Padres and making the All-Star team in 2024 and 2025.
    440pts
  25. Kyle Finnegan — ranked #2525
    Kyle Finnegan
    Right-handed reliever born September 4, 1991, who closed for the Nationals and made the 2024 All-Star team.
    440pts
  26. Yordano Ventura — ranked #2626
    Yordano Ventura
    Dominican right-hander born June 3, 1991, who started Game 6 of the 2014 World Series and won the 2015 title with the Royals before his death in January 2017.
    440pts
  27. Julio Teherán — ranked #2727
    Julio Teherán
    Colombian right-hander born January 27, 1991, who pitched for the Braves from 2011 to 2019 and was an All-Star in 2014 and 2016.
    440pts
  28. Alex Wood — ranked #2828
    Alex Wood
    Left-hander born January 12, 1991, who went 16-3 for the Dodgers in 2017 and made that year's All-Star team.
    440pts
  29. Corey Knebel — ranked #2929
    Corey Knebel
    Right-handed reliever born November 26, 1991, a 2017 All-Star with the Brewers after recording 39 saves that season.
    440pts
  30. Matt Strahm — ranked #3030
    Matt Strahm
    Left-handed reliever born November 12, 1991, a 2024 All-Star with the Phillies.
    440pts
  31. Mike Zunino — ranked #3131
    Mike Zunino
    Catcher born March 25, 1991, the third overall pick in 2012 by Seattle and a 2021 All-Star with the Rays after hitting 33 home runs.
    440pts
  32. Tucker Barnhart — ranked #3232
    Tucker Barnhart
    Catcher born January 7, 1991, who won NL Gold Glove Awards with the Reds in 2017 and 2020.
    440pts
  33. Michael Wacha — ranked #3333
    Michael Wacha
    Right-hander born July 1, 1991, the 2013 NLCS MVP as a Cardinals rookie and a 2015 All-Star.
    0pts
  34. Mike Foltynewicz — ranked #3434
    Mike Foltynewicz
    Right-hander born October 7, 1991, a 2018 All-Star with the Braves after posting a 2.85 ERA that season.
    0pts
  35. Matthew Boyd — ranked #3535
    Matthew Boyd
    Left-hander born February 2, 1991, who started for the Tigers from 2015 to 2021 and was a first-time All-Star with the Cubs in 2025.
    0pts
  36. Luke Voit — ranked #3636
    Luke Voit
    First baseman born February 13, 1991, who led the majors with 22 home runs for the Yankees in the shortened 2020 season.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments