You Pick BestYouPickBest

Who is the best MLB player born in 1957?

By YPB Team

A Hall of Fame closer shares this birth year with a batting champion, a slugger who jumped straight from college to the majors and a few 1980s glove men who rarely made headlines. October heroes sit next to steady compilers here.

  1. Bob Horner — ranked #11
    Bob Horner
    Atlanta Braves slugger who went straight from Arizona State to the majors, won the 1978 NL Rookie of the Year and hit four homers in one 1986 game; born August 6, 1957.
    1000pts
  2. Dave Stieb — ranked #22
    Dave Stieb
    Toronto Blue Jays right-hander, seven-time All-Star with 176 career wins who threw the franchise's first no-hitter in 1990; born July 22, 1957.
    840pts
  3. Brett Butler — ranked #33
    Brett Butler
    Leadoff center fielder who hit .290 with 558 stolen bases over 17 seasons, mostly with Atlanta, Cleveland, San Francisco and the Dodgers; born June 15, 1957.
    749pts
  4. Johnny Ray — ranked #44
    Johnny Ray
    Pittsburgh Pirates second baseman who was The Sporting News NL Rookie of the Year in 1982 and an All-Star with the Angels in 1988; born March 1, 1957.
    639pts
  5. Tony Peña — ranked #55
    Tony Peña
    Catcher with five All-Star selections and four Gold Gloves, later the 2003 AL Manager of the Year with Kansas City; born June 4, 1957.
    638pts
  6. Tim Wallach — ranked #66
    Tim Wallach
    Montreal Expos third baseman, five-time All-Star and three-time Gold Glove winner who led the NL with 42 doubles in 1987; born September 14, 1957.
    500pts
  7. Carney Lansford — ranked #77
    Carney Lansford
    Third baseman who won the 1981 AL batting title (.336) with Boston and a World Series with the 1989 Oakland A's; born February 7, 1957.
    500pts
  8. Bud Black — ranked #88
    Bud Black
    Left-hander with 121 wins and a 1985 title with Kansas City who later managed San Diego and Colorado, winning 2010 NL Manager of the Year; born June 30, 1957.
    500pts
  9. Lou Whitaker — ranked #99
    Lou Whitaker
    Detroit Tigers second baseman (1977–1995), 1978 AL Rookie of the Year, five-time All-Star and 1984 World Series champion with 2,369 hits; born May 12, 1957.
    500pts
  10. Lee Smith — ranked #1010
    Lee Smith
    Hall of Fame closer (inducted 2019) who retired with a record 478 saves and made seven All-Star teams; born December 4, 1957.
    500pts
  11. Doug Jones — ranked #1111
    Doug Jones
    Changeup-throwing closer who made five All-Star teams and finished with 303 saves across 16 seasons; born June 24, 1957.
    500pts
  12. Kirk Gibson — ranked #1212
    Kirk Gibson
    Outfielder who won the 1988 NL MVP and hit a pinch-hit walk-off home run in Game 1 of that year's World Series; also a 1984 champion with Detroit. Born May 28, 1957.
    0pts
  13. Jesse Orosco — ranked #1313
    Jesse Orosco
    Left-handed reliever who pitched in an MLB-record 1,252 games over 24 seasons and won titles with the 1986 Mets and 1988 Dodgers; born April 21, 1957.
    0pts
  14. Mike Boddicker — ranked #1414
    Mike Boddicker
    Baltimore Orioles right-hander, 1983 ALCS MVP for that year's champions, who led the AL with 20 wins and a 2.79 ERA in 1984; born August 23, 1957.
    0pts
  15. Alfredo Griffin — ranked #1515
    Alfredo Griffin
    Shortstop who shared the 1979 AL Rookie of the Year, won a 1985 Gold Glove and collected rings with the 1988 Dodgers and 1992–93 Blue Jays; born October 6, 1957.
    0pts
  16. Glenn Hubbard — ranked #1616
    Glenn Hubbard
    Atlanta Braves second baseman through most of the 1980s, a 1983 All-Star known for his glove, who finished his 12-year career with Oakland; born September 25, 1957.
    0pts
  17. Dave Stewart — ranked #1717
    Dave Stewart
    Pitcher who won 20 or more games in four straight seasons (1987–1990) for Oakland, was 1989 World Series MVP and won three titles; born February 19, 1957.
    0pts
  18. Steve Bedrosian — ranked #1818
    Steve Bedrosian
    Reliever who won the 1987 NL Cy Young Award after saving 40 games for the Philadelphia Phillies; born December 6, 1957.
    0pts
  19. Leon Durham — ranked #1919
    Leon Durham
    Chicago Cubs first baseman and outfielder, an All-Star in 1982 and 1983 and a starter on the 1984 NL East champions; born July 31, 1957.
    0pts
  20. Bob Ojeda — ranked #2020
    Bob Ojeda
    Left-hander who went 18–5 with a 2.57 ERA for the 1986 World Series champion New York Mets; born December 17, 1957.
    0pts
  21. Steve Balboni — ranked #2121
    Steve Balboni
    Kansas City Royals first baseman whose 36 home runs in 1985 stood as the club record for 32 years, on a team that won that year's World Series; born January 16, 1957.
    0pts
  22. Teddy Higuera — ranked #2222
    Teddy Higuera
    Mexican-born Milwaukee Brewers left-hander who won 20 games, made the All-Star team and finished second in the AL Cy Young vote in 1986; born November 9, 1957.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments