You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 38 Best Pittsburgh Pirates Players of All Time

By YPB Team

Dead-ball batting champions share this clubhouse with MVPs, World Series heroes and a few cult-favorite relievers.

  1. Roberto Clemente — ranked #11
    Roberto Clemente
    Right fielder who won the 1966 NL MVP award and four batting titles, and recorded his 3,000th hit for Pittsburgh in 1972.
    1000pts
  2. Bill Mazeroski — ranked #22
    Bill Mazeroski
    Second baseman who hit the walk-off home run in Game 7 of the 1960 World Series and won eight Gold Gloves.
    796pts
  3. Honus Wagner — ranked #33
    Honus Wagner
    Shortstop who won eight National League batting titles with Pittsburgh between 1900 and 1911.
    769pts
  4. Willie Stargell — ranked #44
    Willie Stargell
    Slugger whose 475 career home runs are the Pirates franchise record, and who was NL co-MVP and World Series MVP in 1979.
    712pts
  5. Barry Bonds — ranked #55
    Barry Bonds
    Left fielder who won the NL MVP award with Pittsburgh in 1990 and 1992.
    712pts
  6. Gerrit Cole — ranked #66
    Gerrit Cole
    Right-hander drafted first overall by Pittsburgh in 2011 who won 19 games and made the All-Star team in 2015.
    690pts
  7. Dave Parker — ranked #77
    Dave Parker
    Right fielder who won NL batting titles in 1977 and 1978 and the 1978 NL MVP award with Pittsburgh.
    666pts
  8. Andrew McCutchen — ranked #88
    Andrew McCutchen
    Center fielder who won the 2013 NL MVP award as Pittsburgh reached the playoffs for the first time since 1992.
    640pts
  9. Ralph Kiner — ranked #99
    Ralph Kiner
    Outfielder who led or tied for the NL home run lead in each of his first seven seasons, 1946 to 1952, all with Pittsburgh.
    611pts
  10. Fred Clarke — ranked #1010
    Fred Clarke
    Player-manager who led Pittsburgh to four NL pennants and the 1909 World Series title.
    611pts
  11. Paul Skenes — ranked #1111
    Paul Skenes
    Right-hander drafted first overall in 2023 who won the 2024 NL Rookie of the Year award and started that year's All-Star Game.
    611pts
  12. Paul Waner — ranked #1212
    Paul Waner
    Outfielder nicknamed Big Poison who won the 1927 NL MVP award and three batting titles with Pittsburgh.
    578pts
  13. Lloyd Waner — ranked #1313
    Lloyd Waner
    Center fielder nicknamed Little Poison who collected 223 hits as a Pirates rookie in 1927.
    542pts
  14. Max Carey — ranked #1414
    Max Carey
    Center fielder who led the National League in stolen bases ten times as a Pirate.
    542pts
  15. Andy Van Slyke — ranked #1515
    Andy Van Slyke
    Center fielder who won five straight Gold Gloves with Pittsburgh from 1988 to 1992.
    542pts
  16. Brian Giles — ranked #1616
    Brian Giles
    Outfielder who hit at least 35 home runs in each season from 1999 to 2002 for Pittsburgh.
    542pts
  17. Pie Traynor — ranked #1717
    Pie Traynor
    Third baseman who spent his whole playing career with Pittsburgh from 1920 to 1937, hit .320 and later managed the club.
    500pts
  18. Arky Vaughan — ranked #1818
    Arky Vaughan
    Hall of Fame shortstop who played for Pittsburgh from 1932 to 1941 and hit .385 to win the 1935 NL batting title, still the Pirates single-season record.
    500pts
  19. Bobby Bonilla — ranked #1919
    Bobby Bonilla
    Third baseman and outfielder who made four All-Star teams with Pittsburgh and finished second in the 1990 NL MVP vote.
    500pts
  20. Deacon Phillippe — ranked #2020
    Deacon Phillippe
    Right-hander who won all three of Pittsburgh's victories in the first modern World Series in 1903.
    500pts
  21. Bill Madlock — ranked #2121
    Bill Madlock
    Third baseman who won NL batting titles with Pittsburgh in 1981 and 1983 after joining the 1979 champions midseason.
    412pts
  22. Jason Bay — ranked #2222
    Jason Bay
    Left fielder who won the 2004 NL Rookie of the Year award with Pittsburgh.
    412pts
  23. Neil Walker — ranked #2323
    Neil Walker
    Pittsburgh-born second baseman who won the 2014 NL Silver Slugger award at his position for the Pirates.
    412pts
  24. Doug Drabek — ranked #2424
    Doug Drabek
    Right-hander who won the 1990 NL Cy Young Award after a 22-win season for Pittsburgh.
    412pts
  25. Bryan Reynolds — ranked #2525
    Bryan Reynolds
    Outfielder who was named an NL All-Star in 2021 and signed an eight-year extension with Pittsburgh in 2023.
    412pts
  26. Dick Groat — ranked #2626
    Dick Groat
    Shortstop who won the 1960 NL MVP award and batting title for the champion Pirates.
    412pts
  27. Tommy Leach — ranked #2727
    Tommy Leach
    Infielder and outfielder who hit four triples for Pittsburgh in the 1903 World Series.
    412pts
  28. Kiki Cuyler — ranked #2828
    Kiki Cuyler
    Outfielder who hit .357 in 1925 and doubled in the go-ahead runs in Game 7 of that year's World Series.
    412pts
  29. Babe Adams — ranked #2929
    Babe Adams
    Right-hander who won three complete games as a rookie in the 1909 World Series.
    357pts
  30. Wilbur Cooper — ranked #3030
    Wilbur Cooper
    Left-hander whose 202 wins are the most by any pitcher in Pirates history.
    357pts
  31. Al Oliver — ranked #3131
    Al Oliver
    Outfielder and first baseman who played for Pittsburgh from 1968 to 1977, including the 1971 championship season.
    357pts
  32. Mark Melancon — ranked #3232
    Mark Melancon
    Closer who set the Pirates single-season record with 51 saves in 2015.
    357pts
  33. Sam Leever — ranked #3333
    Sam Leever
    Right-hander who spent his entire 13-season career with Pittsburgh and led the NL with a 2.06 ERA in 1903.
    357pts
  34. Ke'Bryan Hayes — ranked #3434
    Ke'Bryan Hayes
    Third baseman who won the 2023 NL Gold Glove award with Pittsburgh.
    357pts
  35. Steve Blass — ranked #3535
    Steve Blass
    Right-hander who threw two complete-game wins in the 1971 World Series, including Game 7.
    0pts
  36. Kent Tekulve — ranked #3636
    Kent Tekulve
    Submarine-style reliever who saved three games in the 1979 World Series.
    0pts
  37. Freddy Sanchez — ranked #3737
    Freddy Sanchez
    Infielder who won the 2006 NL batting title with a .344 average for Pittsburgh.
    0pts
  38. Starling Marte — ranked #3838
    Starling Marte
    Left fielder who won Gold Glove awards with Pittsburgh in 2015 and 2016.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments