You Pick BestYouPickBest

Which animal in a famous painting carries the best hidden meaning?

By YPB Team

Some of these creatures stand for a vow, others for a warning or a sin, and a few still split the scholars who read them.

  1. Dog in the Arnolfini Portrait — ranked #11
    Dog in the Arnolfini Portrait
    The small terrier between the couple in Jan van Eyck's 1434 portrait (National Gallery, London) is read as a sign of marital fidelity and was added after the underdrawing.
    1000pts
  2. Cat in Olympia — ranked #22
    Cat in Olympia
    In his 1863 Olympia (Musée d'Orsay) Manet swapped Titian's sleeping dog for a black cat with an arched back, an animal tied to night and licence.
    817pts
  3. Goldfinch in the Madonna del Cardellino — ranked #33
    Goldfinch in the Madonna del Cardellino
    In Raphael's panel of about 1506 (Uffizi) the infant John hands Christ a goldfinch, whose red head the museum links to the Passion.
    586pts
  4. Lizard in Boy Bitten by a Lizard — ranked #44
    Lizard in Boy Bitten by a Lizard
    In Caravaggio's youth of about 1594–1596 (versions in Florence's Fondazione Longhi and London's National Gallery) a lizard hidden among the fruit bites a finger, often read as the sting of love beside the rose in his hair.
    586pts
  5. Owl in The Conjurer — ranked #55
    Owl in The Conjurer
    An owl peers from the basket of the trickster in The Conjurer (Saint-Germain-en-Laye), Bosch or a follower, read by Jeffrey Hamburger as a sign of folly and spiritual blindness.
    586pts
  6. Dog in Rubens's Last Supper — ranked #66
    Dog in Rubens's Last Supper
    Under Judas in Rubens's Last Supper (1631–1632, Pinacoteca di Brera) a dog gnaws a bone, read by some as fidelity set against the traitor and by others as his companion in greed.
    586pts
  7. Lamb in Zurbarán's Agnus Dei — ranked #77
    Lamb in Zurbarán's Agnus Dei
    Francisco de Zurbarán's Agnus Dei of about 1635–1640 (Museo del Prado) shows a lamb with bound legs on a bare ledge, an image of Christ's sacrifice.
    476pts
  8. Bull in Guernica — ranked #88
    Bull in Guernica
    Picasso told Jerome Seckler in 1945 that the bull in Guernica (1937, Museo Reina Sofía) stood for brutality and darkness rather than fascism, and later insisted it was just a bull.
    476pts
  9. Unicorn in Lady with a Unicorn — ranked #99
    Unicorn in Lady with a Unicorn
    Raphael's sitter of about 1506 (Galleria Borghese) holds a small unicorn, a symbol of chastity; X-rays in 1960 found a lapdog painted beneath it.
    476pts
  10. Peacock in Ghirlandaio's Last Supper — ranked #1010
    Peacock in Ghirlandaio's Last Supper
    Domenico Ghirlandaio's Last Supper fresco of about 1486 in the San Marco convent, Florence, sets a peacock in the window, a bird associated with resurrection and eternal life.
    476pts
  11. Hummingbird in Kahlo's Self-Portrait — ranked #1111
    Hummingbird in Kahlo's Self-Portrait
    Frida Kahlo's 1940 Self-Portrait with Thorn Necklace and Hummingbird (Harry Ransom Center, Austin) hangs a dead hummingbird, a Mexican folk charm for luck in love, from a necklace of thorns.
    476pts
  12. Ermine in Lady with an Ermine — ranked #1212
    Ermine in Lady with an Ermine
    Leonardo's ermine (1489–1491, National Museum in Kraków) points to Ludovico Sforza, a knight of the Order of the Ermine, and puns on the sitter's surname Gallerani.
    0pts
  13. Rabbit in the Madonna of the Rabbit — ranked #1313
    Rabbit in the Madonna of the Rabbit
    The white rabbit under the Virgin's hand in Titian's painting of about 1530 (Louvre) is read as a sign of fertility turned into a symbol of the Incarnation.
    0pts
  14. Snail in del Cossa's Annunciation — ranked #1414
    Snail in del Cossa's Annunciation
    Francesco del Cossa's Annunciation of about 1470 (Dresden) has a snail crawling along its lower edge, tied to the virgin birth and, for Daniel Arasse, to the limits of seeing.
    0pts
  15. Fly in Portrait of a Carthusian — ranked #1515
    Fly in Portrait of a Carthusian
    Petrus Christus painted a fly on the illusionistic frame of his 1446 Portrait of a Carthusian (Metropolitan Museum), a trompe-l'oeil trick that blurs the line between the picture and the viewer's room.
    0pts
  16. Cat in The Graham Children — ranked #1616
    Cat in The Graham Children
    In Hogarth's 1742 group portrait (National Gallery, London) a cat climbs the chair towards a caged goldfinch, which the gallery reads as an allusion to the youngest child, who died while the picture was being painted.
    0pts
  17. Dog in the Venus of Urbino — ranked #1717
    Dog in the Venus of Urbino
    Titian's 1538 nude in the Uffizi has a small dog asleep at her feet, which the museum reads as a token of faithfulness in marriage.
    0pts
  18. Monkeys in Two Monkeys (Bruegel) — ranked #1818
    Monkeys in Two Monkeys (Bruegel)
    Pieter Bruegel the Elder's 1562 panel in Berlin's Gemäldegalerie chains two monkeys in a window over Antwerp, read as people bound by folly for a nutshell's worth.
    0pts
  19. Lamb in the Ghent Altarpiece — ranked #1919
    Lamb in the Ghent Altarpiece
    The Lamb of God on the van Eyck brothers' 1432 altarpiece in St Bavo's Cathedral stands for Christ; the 2019 restoration uncovered its original, strikingly human face.
    0pts
  20. Frog in The Conjurer — ranked #2020
    Frog in The Conjurer
    Frogs sit on the table and at the lips of the bent-over spectator in The Conjurer, a motif Jeffrey Hamburger tied to the frog-like spirits of Revelation 16:13 and to heresy.
    0pts
  21. Cat in Bassano's Last Supper — ranked #2121
    Cat in Bassano's Last Supper
    Jacopo Bassano's Last Supper (1546–1548, Galleria Borghese) puts a cat at Judas's end of the scene, an animal long linked with betrayal, though the museum calls it a detail from life.
    0pts
  22. Cats in Goya's Manuel Osorio — ranked #2222
    Cats in Goya's Manuel Osorio
    Three wide-eyed cats stare at the boy's pet magpie in Goya's portrait of Manuel Osorio Manrique de Zúñiga (Metropolitan Museum), read as a threat to childhood innocence; the boy died at eight.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments