You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the greatest Pittsburgh Pirates team of all time?

By YPB Team

Dead-ball era pennant winners, five World Series champions and a couple of teams that fell one game short, spread across more than a century of Pittsburgh baseball.

  1. 1979 Pirates — ranked #11
    1979 Pirates
    The 98–64 'We Are Family' team that rallied from 3–1 down to beat Baltimore in the World Series, with Willie Stargell named Series MVP.
    1000pts
  2. 1903 Pirates — ranked #22
    1903 Pirates
    Won a third straight NL pennant at 91–49 and played in the first modern World Series, losing to Boston five games to three.
    647pts
  3. 1925 Pirates — ranked #33
    1925 Pirates
    A 95–58 team with Kiki Cuyler and Pie Traynor that came back from a 3–1 deficit to beat Walter Johnson's Washington Senators in the World Series.
    624pts
  4. 1902 Pirates — ranked #44
    1902 Pirates
    Went 103–36, won the National League pennant by 27½ games and set a franchise record .741 winning percentage that still stands.
    485pts
  5. 2015 Pirates — ranked #55
    2015 Pirates
    Won 98 games, the second-best record in the majors, but lost the NL Wild Card Game to Jake Arrieta and the Cubs.
    485pts
  6. 1927 Pirates — ranked #66
    1927 Pirates
    A 94–60 NL champion led by MVP Paul Waner and rookie Lloyd Waner that was swept by the Yankees in the World Series.
    485pts
  7. 2013 Pirates — ranked #77
    2013 Pirates
    Ended a run of 20 straight losing seasons at 94–68, beat Cincinnati in the Wild Card Game and had MVP Andrew McCutchen.
    397pts
  8. 1971 Pirates — ranked #88
    1971 Pirates
    A 97–65 team that beat Baltimore in a seven-game World Series, with Roberto Clemente named Series MVP.
    291pts
  9. 1991 Pirates — ranked #99
    1991 Pirates
    Posted the National League's best record at 98–64 before losing a seven-game NLCS to the Atlanta Braves.
    291pts
  10. 1909 Pirates — ranked #1010
    1909 Pirates
    Honus Wagner's club opened Forbes Field, won a franchise-record 110 games and beat Detroit in a seven-game World Series.
    291pts
  11. 1960 Pirates — ranked #1111
    1960 Pirates
    A 95–59 team that won the World Series on Bill Mazeroski's Game 7 walk-off home run against the Yankees, with Dick Groat as NL MVP.
    291pts
  12. 1901 Pirates — ranked #1212
    1901 Pirates
    Fred Clarke's 90–49 club that won the first of the franchise's three straight National League pennants.
    291pts
  13. 1972 Pirates — ranked #1313
    1972 Pirates
    A 96–59 NL East champion that saw Roberto Clemente's 3,000th hit and lost the NLCS to Cincinnati on a ninth-inning wild pitch in Game 5.
    291pts

Photo credits

Comments