You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the biggest what-if in the space race?

By YPB Team

Cancelled programmes, dead designers, rockets that never worked. Each one moved a deadline that is still moving.

  1. The Cancelled Apollo 18, 19 and 20 — ranked #11
    The Cancelled Apollo 18, 19 and 20
    Three funded lunar landings were scrapped, and the hardware ended up in museums.
    1000pts
  2. Apollo 8 Flying Without a Lunar Module — ranked #22
    Apollo 8 Flying Without a Lunar Module
    The mission was rewritten months before launch into a risk NASA had never planned to take.
    927pts
  3. The Cancellation of the Constellation Programme — ranked #33
    The Cancellation of the Constellation Programme
    A planned return to the Moon was shut down in 2010, delaying the next crewed lunar flight by more than a decade.
    800pts
  4. Apollo 13's Oxygen Tank — ranked #44
    Apollo 13's Oxygen Tank
    A damaged tank ruptured 200,000 miles out, and the landing became a survival problem instead.
    600pts
  5. Gagarin's Fatal Crash — ranked #55
    Gagarin's Fatal Crash
    The first person in space died in a training flight in 1968 at 34, having been barred from flying again.
    466pts
  6. The Space Shuttle Instead of a Moon Base — ranked #66
    The Space Shuttle Instead of a Moon Base
    NASA spent the 1970s building a reusable truck to low Earth orbit rather than staying at the Moon.
    466pts
  7. Von Braun's Mars Plan — ranked #77
    Von Braun's Mars Plan
    A crewed Mars expedition was sketched for the early 1980s using Apollo-derived hardware, and never funded.
    466pts
  8. Skylab's Re-entry — ranked #88
    Skylab's Re-entry
    America's first station was abandoned after three crews and burned up in 1979 with no replacement ready.
    466pts
  9. The Soviet Moonsuit — ranked #99
    The Soviet Moonsuit
    The Krechet suit was built and tested for a landing that was cancelled before anyone wore it beyond Earth.
    466pts
  10. The Apollo 1 Fire — ranked #1010
    The Apollo 1 Fire
    A cabin fire during a launch rehearsal on 27 January 1967 killed Gus Grissom, Ed White and Roger Chaffee.
    0pts
  11. Korolev's Death in 1966 — ranked #1111
    Korolev's Death in 1966
    The Soviet chief designer died during routine surgery, and the lunar programme lost the only person able to hold it together.
    0pts

Comments 1

Four of these eleven what-ifs belong to Apollo itself: https://youpick.best/articles/apollo-program-ranked-many-ways

YP
ypb-team
Aug 25