You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 15 Biggest Box Office Disappointments in Animation History

By YPB Team2 votes

Big studios, big budgets, empty theatres. A few of these later became cult favourites, which only sharpens the question.

  1. Lightyear — ranked #11
    Lightyear
    Pixar's 2022 Toy Story spin-off took $226M against a $200M budget and reportedly lost around $106M.
    1000pts
  2. Mars Needs Moms — ranked #22
    Mars Needs Moms
    The motion-capture experiment that took $39M against a reported $150M budget in 2011.
    1000pts
  3. The Good Dinosaur — ranked #33
    The Good Dinosaur
    Pixar's only feature to lose money before Lightyear, after a mid-production reboot.
    945pts
  4. Sing 2 — ranked #44
    Sing 2
    A well-reviewed sequel that opened into a pandemic winter and never caught its predecessor.
    764pts
  5. Home on the Range — ranked #55
    Home on the Range
    The 2004 western that ended Disney's hand-drawn era for five years.
    647pts
  6. Titan A.E. — ranked #66
    Titan A.E.
    Fox's 2000 space opera, which closed the studio's traditional animation division.
    647pts
  7. Atlantis: The Lost Empire — ranked #77
    Atlantis: The Lost Empire
    Disney's 2001 pulp adventure, expensive and quickly shelved as a franchise.
    647pts
  8. Rise of the Guardians — ranked #88
    Rise of the Guardians
    The 2012 DreamWorks film whose write-down triggered studio layoffs.
    647pts
  9. Strange World — ranked #99
    Strange World
    Disney's 2022 pulp adventure grossed $73M worldwide and became the year's largest write-off.
    503pts
  10. The Iron Giant — ranked #1010
    The Iron Giant
    A film now treated as a classic that Warner Bros. barely marketed in 1999.
    503pts
  11. Wish — ranked #1111
    Wish
    Disney's 2023 centenary film, which underperformed against a $200M budget.
    503pts
  12. Ruby Gillman, Teenage Kraken — ranked #1212
    Ruby Gillman, Teenage Kraken
    DreamWorks' 2023 comedy, which took under $50M worldwide.
    503pts
  13. Delgo — ranked #1313
    Delgo
    The 2008 independent film that recorded one of the worst wide-release openings ever.
    0pts
  14. Elemental — ranked #1414
    Elemental
    Pixar's 2023 release opened to the studio's worst debut before a long recovery run.
    0pts
  15. Fantasia — ranked #1515
    Fantasia
    Disney's 1940 experiment, which took decades of re-releases to turn a profit.
    0pts

Comments 1

The franchise's own spin-off turns up on the list nobody wants to be on: https://youpick.best/articles/toy-story-ranked-many-ways

YP
ypb-team
Aug 25