You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the biggest what-if in sports history?

by YPB Team

Careers cut short by a knee, a war, a ban, or a decision nobody could talk the player out of.

  1. Babe Ruth staying a pitcher — ranked #11
    Babe Ruth staying a pitcher
    He was 94-46 with a 2.28 ERA when Boston moved him to the outfield full time to get his bat in the lineup.
  2. Bo Jackson's hip injury — ranked #22
    Bo Jackson's hip injury
    An All-Star outfielder and Pro Bowl running back at 27, and finished as both by 30.
  3. Muhammad Ali's three years in exile — ranked #33
    Muhammad Ali's three years in exile
    Stripped of the title at 25 and kept out of the ring until 29, the years usually reckoned as his physical peak.
  4. Ted Williams' war years — ranked #44
    Ted Williams' war years
    Nearly five prime seasons lost to two tours of military service.
  5. Sandy Koufax retiring at 30 — ranked #55
    Sandy Koufax retiring at 30
    Walked away after a 27-win season because his elbow could not take another year.
  6. Marco van Basten's ankle — ranked #66
    Marco van Basten's ankle
    A Ballon d'Or winner forced to stop at 28 after operations that never took.
  7. Ronaldo's knees — ranked #77
    Ronaldo's knees
    The Brazilian striker lost two seasons at his peak to the same knee, and still won a World Cup afterwards.
  8. Michael Jordan's first retirement — ranked #88
    Michael Jordan's first retirement
    Left basketball at 30 for a season and a half of minor league baseball.
  9. Barry Sanders retiring at 30 — ranked #99
    Barry Sanders retiring at 30
    Fourteen hundred yards short of the rushing record, he simply stopped.
  10. Greg Oden's knees — ranked #1010
    Greg Oden's knees
    The first pick ahead of Kevin Durant, limited to 105 NBA games.
  11. The 1994 baseball strike — ranked #1111
    The 1994 baseball strike
    A cancelled World Series, a .394 average left unfinished and a franchise in Montreal that never recovered.
  12. Robert Griffin III's knee — ranked #1212
    Robert Griffin III's knee
    Offensive Rookie of the Year, then a playoff game he should not have finished.

#Sports664#Legends376#Injuries2#Careers1

Comments

Nothing was taken from him; Ed Barrow simply started batting him every day in 1918, which removed a fine left-hander at 23: https://youpick.best/articles/babe-ruth-ranked-many-ways

YP
ypb-team
·Aug 21·