You Pick BestYouPickBest

Who is the best player in FC Cincinnati history?

By YPB Team

Young as the club is, its story already splits in two: the USL years that packed the stands and the MLS era that brought a Supporters' Shield. Some names here own the record books, others own one unforgettable night.

  1. Roman Celentano — ranked #11
    Roman Celentano
    Drafted in 2022, the goalkeeper holds the club record for clean sheets and won MLS Save of the Year in 2023 and 2025.
    1000pts
  2. Luciano Acosta — ranked #22
    Luciano Acosta
    The Argentine playmaker scored a club-record 54 goals from 2021 to 2024, led MLS with 19 assists in 2022 and won the 2023 MLS MVP.
    720pts
  3. Brenner — ranked #33
    Brenner
    The Brazilian forward joined from São Paulo in 2021, scored 18 MLS goals in 2022 and returned to the club in 2025.
    720pts
  4. Yuya Kubo — ranked #44
    Yuya Kubo
    The Japanese forward played 179 matches for the club from 2020 to 2025, the second-most in its history.
    622pts
  5. Nick Hagglund — ranked #55
    Nick Hagglund
    A Cincinnati-area native and Xavier product, the defender has been with the club since its 2019 MLS debut and leads its all-time appearance list.
    622pts
  6. Brandon Vázquez — ranked #66
    Brandon Vázquez
    The striker scored 43 goals for the club from 2020 to 2023, including 18 MLS goals in 2022, when he made the MLS Best XI.
    500pts
  7. Kévin Denkey — ranked #77
    Kévin Denkey
    The Togo striker joined from Cercle Brugge in January 2025 as a club-record signing, scored on his MLS debut and passed 30 goals for the club by 2026.
    500pts
  8. Harrison Delbridge — ranked #88
    Harrison Delbridge
    The Australian center back made the USL All-League First Team in 2016 and 2017.
    500pts
  9. Obinna Nwobodo — ranked #99
    Obinna Nwobodo
    The Nigerian defensive midfielder joined in 2022 and anchored the midfield of the 2023 Supporters' Shield winners.
    500pts
  10. Pavel Bucha — ranked #1010
    Pavel Bucha
    The Czech midfielder joined from Viktoria Plzeň in 2024 and passed 100 appearances for the club in his third season.
    500pts
  11. Danni König — ranked #1111
    Danni König
    The Danish striker scored 22 goals for the club across the 2017 and 2018 USL seasons.
    500pts
  12. Evander — ranked #1212
    Evander
    The Brazilian midfielder joined in 2025 and made that season's MLS Best XI with 18 goals and 15 assists.
    0pts
  13. Sean Okoli — ranked #1313
    Sean Okoli
    The striker scored 16 goals in the club's first season in 2016 to win the USL Golden Boot and MVP award.
    0pts
  14. Djiby Fall — ranked #1414
    Djiby Fall
    The Senegalese striker scored the only goal of the 2017 U.S. Open Cup win over Columbus Crew.
    0pts
  15. Corben Bone — ranked #1515
    Corben Bone
    The midfielder played more than 100 matches for the club from 2016 to 2019 and made the USL All-League Second Team in 2018.
    0pts
  16. Jimmy McLaughlin — ranked #1616
    Jimmy McLaughlin
    A member of the inaugural 2016 squad, the winger stayed with the club through its move to MLS in 2019.
    0pts
  17. Matt Miazga — ranked #1717
    Matt Miazga
    The center back won 2023 MLS Defender of the Year and made the 2023 MLS Best XI.
    0pts
  18. Alvas Powell — ranked #1818
    Alvas Powell
    The Jamaican full-back played for the club in 2019 and again from 2022, passing 150 appearances.
    0pts
  19. Emmanuel Ledesma — ranked #1919
    Emmanuel Ledesma
    The Argentine winger was 2018 USL MVP and the league's assists leader as Cincinnati won the USL regular-season title.
    0pts
  20. Mitch Hildebrandt — ranked #2020
    Mitch Hildebrandt
    The goalkeeper was 2016 USL Goalkeeper of the Year and saved three penalties in the 2017 U.S. Open Cup shootout win over Chicago Fire.
    0pts
  21. Forrest Lasso — ranked #2121
    Forrest Lasso
    The center back was named 2018 USL Defender of the Year and made the All-League First Team.
    0pts
  22. Evan Newton — ranked #2222
    Evan Newton
    The goalkeeper won the USL Golden Glove in 2018 for the regular-season champions.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments