You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the best mixer for a cocktail?

By YPB Team

Tonic gets the glory, but half of these do more work in a highball than the spirit does.

  1. Tonic Water — ranked #11
    Tonic Water
    Quinine-bitter sparkling water that turned gin and tonic into the world's default highball.
  2. Ginger Beer — ranked #22
    Ginger Beer
    Spicy, cloudy brewed ginger soda that carries the Moscow Mule and the Dark 'n' Stormy.
  3. Club Soda — ranked #33
    Club Soda
    Plain carbonated water with a pinch of minerals, used to lengthen a drink without changing its flavor.
  4. Coca-Cola — ranked #44
    Coca-Cola
    The caramel-sweet cola that anchors the Cuba Libre and the whiskey and Coke.
  5. Pepsi — ranked #55
    Pepsi
    Coke's sweeter, citrus-forward rival, poured over ice with rum or bourbon just as often.
  6. Ginger Ale — ranked #66
    Ginger Ale
    The mild, sweet cousin of ginger beer, mixed with whiskey in the Presbyterian and the Horse's Neck.
  7. Lime Juice — ranked #77
    Lime Juice
    Fresh-squeezed acid that defines the Daiquiri, the Margarita and the Gimlet.
  8. Lemon Juice — ranked #88
    Lemon Juice
    The sour half of every Whiskey Sour, Tom Collins and French 75.
  9. Orange Juice — ranked #99
    Orange Juice
    Breakfast-sweet citrus that made the Screwdriver and the Mimosa household names.
  10. Cranberry Juice — ranked #1010
    Cranberry Juice
    Tart red juice behind the Cosmopolitan and the Cape Codder.
  11. Grapefruit Juice — ranked #1111
    Grapefruit Juice
    Bitter-sweet citrus at the heart of the Paloma and the Greyhound.
  12. Pineapple Juice — ranked #1212
    Pineapple Juice
    Tropical, foam-building juice that gives the Piña Colada and the Painkiller their body.
  13. Simple Syrup — ranked #1313
    Simple Syrup
    Dissolved sugar in water, the invisible mixer that balances almost every sour.
  14. Grenadine — ranked #1414
    Grenadine
    Pomegranate syrup that sinks to the bottom and gives the Tequila Sunrise its gradient.
  15. Tomato Juice — ranked #1515
    Tomato Juice
    Savory, thick base of the Bloody Mary and the Red Snapper.
  16. Lemon-Lime Soda — ranked #1616
    Lemon-Lime Soda
    Clear citrus fizz that lifts vodka, gin and tequila in easy highballs.
  17. Bitter Lemon — ranked #1717
    Bitter Lemon
    Quinine-laced lemon soda, a sharper alternative to tonic for gin and vodka.
  18. Cream of Coconut — ranked #1818
    Cream of Coconut
    Thick, sweetened coconut cream that makes the Piña Colada what it is.

Comments 1

Rum and Coke is ordered by brand rather than by category, which no marketing department engineered. Eighteen mixers, and one is named in a cocktail: https://youpick.best/articles/coca-cola-vs-pepsi-ranked

YP
ypb-team
Aug 21