You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the best Ian McKellen movie role?

By YPB Team

Wizards and war criminals, Shakespeare's tyrant and an elderly Sherlock: McKellen's screen career swings between blockbuster franchises and small, sharp character studies. Some of these parts won him Oscar nominations, others just stuck with audiences.

  1. Gandalf (Lord of the Rings) — ranked #11
    Gandalf (Lord of the Rings)
    The wizard McKellen played in Peter Jackson's Lord of the Rings trilogy (2001-2003), earning an Oscar nomination for The Fellowship of the Ring.
    1000pts
  2. Sherlock Holmes (Mr. Holmes) — ranked #22
    Sherlock Holmes (Mr. Holmes)
    A 93-year-old retired Sherlock Holmes struggling with failing memory in Bill Condon's 2015 film.
    731pts
  3. Roy Courtnay (The Good Liar) — ranked #33
    Roy Courtnay (The Good Liar)
    A con man targeting a wealthy widow played by Helen Mirren in Bill Condon's 2019 thriller.
    500pts
  4. Magneto (X-Men) — ranked #44
    Magneto (X-Men)
    The mutant leader Erik Lehnsherr, first played by McKellen in Bryan Singer's X-Men (2000) and again in X2, X-Men: The Last Stand and X-Men: Days of Future Past.
    409pts
  5. James Whale (Gods and Monsters) — ranked #55
    James Whale (Gods and Monsters)
    The ageing Frankenstein director James Whale in Bill Condon's 1998 drama, a role that earned McKellen an Oscar nomination for Best Actor.
    409pts
  6. Leigh Teabing (Da Vinci Code) — ranked #66
    Leigh Teabing (Da Vinci Code)
    The British Holy Grail historian Sir Leigh Teabing in Ron Howard's 2006 adaptation of Dan Brown's novel.
    409pts
  7. Toad (Flushed Away) — ranked #77
    Toad (Flushed Away)
    The voice of the villainous Toad of the sewer city beneath London in the 2006 Aardman and DreamWorks animated film.
    409pts
  8. John Profumo (Scandal) — ranked #88
    John Profumo (Scandal)
    The British Secretary of State for War at the centre of the Profumo affair in Michael Caton-Jones's 1989 film Scandal.
    300pts
  9. Kurt Dussander (Apt Pupil) — ranked #99
    Kurt Dussander (Apt Pupil)
    A Nazi war criminal hiding in a California suburb in Bryan Singer's 1998 adaptation of the Stephen King novella.
    300pts
  10. Richard III (1995 film) — ranked #1010
    Richard III (1995 film)
    Shakespeare's murderous king in Richard Loncraine's 1995 adaptation set in a fascist 1930s Britain, which McKellen co-wrote.
    0pts

Comments