You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the best dish to order at an Italian restaurant?

By YPB Team

Some of these turn up on nearly every menu; others are the reason a kitchen gets a reputation. Pick the plate you would actually order.

  1. Steak — ranked #11
    Steak
    A grilled steak such as the Florentine T-bone, now on the menu at almost nine in ten Italian restaurants in America.
  2. Ravioli — ranked #22
    Ravioli
    Stuffed pasta pillows, once ricotta and spinach under tomato sauce, now filled with everything from short rib to squash.
  3. Caesar Salad — ranked #33
    Caesar Salad
    Romaine dressed with egg, Parmigiano, garlic, lemon and anchovy, finished with croutons.
  4. Antipasto Plate — ranked #44
    Antipasto Plate
    A mixed board of cured meats, cheeses and pickled vegetables, also called tagliere or affettati misti.
  5. Fresh Pasta — ranked #55
    Fresh Pasta
    House-made pasta such as tagliatelle or pappardelle, the calling card of a serious Italian kitchen.
  6. Potatoes as a Side — ranked #66
    Potatoes as a Side
    The potato contorno, roasted or fried, a side with a long tradition in Italian trattorias.
  7. Fried Calamari — ranked #77
    Fried Calamari
    Rings and tentacles of squid, lightly floured and fried, served with lemon or marinara.
  8. Gnocchi — ranked #88
    Gnocchi
    Soft dumplings of potato or ricotta, often served with butter and sage or a tomato sauce.
  9. Risotto — ranked #99
    Risotto
    Short-grain rice cooked slowly in broth until creamy, with cheese, mushrooms, seafood or saffron.
  10. Chicken Parmesan — ranked #1010
    Chicken Parmesan
    Breaded chicken cutlet baked under tomato sauce and melted mozzarella, an Italian-American classic.
  11. Pork Entrée — ranked #1111
    Pork Entrée
    Pork as a main course, from porchetta and chops to braised shoulder.
  12. Insalata Caprese — ranked #1212
    Insalata Caprese
    Sliced tomato, fresh mozzarella and basil with olive oil, in the colours of the Italian flag.
  13. Meatballs — ranked #1313
    Meatballs
    Meatballs of beef, pork and veal in tomato sauce, now a popular starter on their own.
  14. Lasagna — ranked #1414
    Lasagna
    Layers of flat pasta with ricotta, mozzarella, tomato and meat sauce, baked until bubbling.
  15. Prosciutto — ranked #1515
    Prosciutto
    Prosciutto crudo, thinly sliced Italian dry-cured ham served on its own or with melon.
  16. Linguine with Clams — ranked #1616
    Linguine with Clams
    Pasta with clams in the shell, white wine, garlic, lemon and chili flakes.
  17. Burrata — ranked #1717
    Burrata
    A Puglian cheese with a thin mozzarella shell around a soft, creamy heart of stracciatella.
  18. Beef Carpaccio — ranked #1818
    Beef Carpaccio
    Paper-thin slices of raw beef, lightly dressed and topped with arugula and shaved cheese.
  19. Eggplant Parmesan — ranked #1919
    Eggplant Parmesan
    Fried eggplant baked with tomato sauce, mozzarella and Parmigiano, the parmigiana of southern Italy.

Photo credits

Comments