You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 15 Best All-American Rejects Songs of All Time

By YPB Team5 votes

The All-American Rejects gave us the soundtrack to the early 2000s. Which of their songs hits hardest?

  1. Gives You Hell — ranked #11
    Gives You Hell
    Their 4× Platinum 2009 breakup anthem, their highest-charting US single, reaching #4 on the Billboard Hot 100.
    1000pts
  2. It Ends Tonight — ranked #22
    It Ends Tonight
    The piano-driven 2006 power ballad from Move Along that swells into a cathartic finale and reached No. 8 on the Billboard Hot 100.
    999pts
  3. Dirty Little Secret — ranked #33
    Dirty Little Secret
    Their 2005 eternal homecoming dance classic — a lighthearted, impossibly sticky pop-punk hook built around PostSecret confessions.
    847pts
  4. Time Stands Still — ranked #44
    Time Stands Still
    The wistful third single from their 2002 self-titled debut, a mid-tempo breakup song that showed the softer side of Tyson Ritter's songwriting.
    745pts
  5. Kids in the Street — ranked #55
    Kids in the Street
    The nostalgic title track of their 2012 album, a synth-tinged anthem looking back on reckless teenage nights that many fans rank among their finest songs.
    684pts
  6. Swing, Swing — ranked #66
    Swing, Swing
    Their 2002 breakthrough debut single — jubilant, bouncy, and loaded with teenage angst that defined early 2000s pop-punk.
    615pts
  7. The Last Song — ranked #77
    The Last Song
    Their melancholic 2002 album track beloved by fans for its raw emotional sincerity and stripped-back delivery.
    534pts
  8. I Wanna — ranked #88
    I Wanna
    Their infectious 2008 stadium-ready pop-punk track with a massive singalong chorus and driving guitar riff.
    481pts
  9. Move Along — ranked #99
    Move Along
    Their certified platinum 2005 underdog anthem with an empowering message about pushing through adversity.
    481pts
  10. My Paper Heart — ranked #1010
    My Paper Heart
    The opening track of their 2002 self-titled debut, a heartfelt pop-punk song about vulnerability that remains a longtime fan favourite.
    468pts
  11. Beekeeper's Daughter — ranked #1111
    Beekeeper's Daughter
    The brassy, sneering 2012 lead single from Kids in the Street, a darkly playful song that pushed the band beyond their pop-punk roots.
    468pts
  12. Your Star — ranked #1212
    Your Star
    A tender, slow-building ballad from the 2002 self-titled debut that early fans cherish for its earnest, lovelorn lyrics and Tyson Ritter's vocal.
    468pts
  13. One More Sad Song — ranked #1313
    One More Sad Song
    A bouncy cut from the 2002 self-titled debut whose upbeat melody belies its bitter, sarcastic take on being left behind by an ex.
    408pts
  14. Mona Lisa (When the World Comes Down) — ranked #1414
    Mona Lisa (When the World Comes Down)
    A sweeping 2008 track that shares its title with the album When the World Comes Down, pairing big orchestral swells with Tyson Ritter's bittersweet lyrics.
    408pts
  15. The Wind Blows — ranked #1515
    The Wind Blows
    The second single from When the World Comes Down, a moody 2009 rock song about watching a relationship drift away, released between Gives You Hell and I Wanna.
    0pts

Comments