You Pick BestYouPickBest

Top 29 MLB Players of the 1920s

By YPB Team

Sluggers who rewrote the record book share space with spitballers allowed to keep the pitch after the ban and Negro leagues stars whose numbers MLB now counts.

  1. Babe Ruth — ranked #11
    Babe Ruth
    Hit 54 home runs in 1920, 59 in 1921 and 60 in 1927 for the Yankees, winning the 1923 AL MVP and three World Series during the decade.
    1000pts
  2. Ty Cobb — ranked #22
    Ty Cobb
    Detroit's player-manager from 1921 to 1926 who batted .401 in 1922 and closed his career with the Philadelphia Athletics in 1927 and 1928.
    961pts
  3. Rogers Hornsby — ranked #33
    Rogers Hornsby
    Won six straight NL batting titles from 1920 to 1925, including a .424 mark in 1924, and two Triple Crowns with the Cardinals.
    917pts
  4. Tris Speaker — ranked #44
    Tris Speaker
    Managed Cleveland to the 1920 World Series title while batting .388 as its everyday center fielder.
    882pts
  5. Hack Wilson — ranked #55
    Hack Wilson
    Cubs center fielder who led the NL in home runs in 1926, 1927 and 1928, two years before his 191-RBI season.
    836pts
  6. Lou Gehrig — ranked #66
    Lou Gehrig
    Became the Yankees' everyday first baseman in June 1925 and was named 1927 AL MVP while batting behind Babe Ruth.
    784pts
  7. Grover Cleveland Alexander — ranked #77
    Grover Cleveland Alexander
    Won the 1920 pitching Triple Crown with the Cubs and struck out Tony Lazzeri with the bases loaded in Game 7 of the 1926 World Series.
    784pts
  8. Oscar Charleston — ranked #88
    Oscar Charleston
    Negro National League center fielder for Indianapolis and St. Louis whose 1920s statistics are now part of MLB's official record; inducted into Cooperstown in 1976.
    747pts
  9. Harry Heilmann — ranked #99
    Harry Heilmann
    Detroit outfielder who won four AL batting titles between 1921 and 1927, hitting .403 in 1923.
    727pts
  10. Dazzy Vance — ranked #1010
    Dazzy Vance
    Brooklyn right-hander who led the NL in strikeouts every year from 1922 to 1928 and won the 1924 NL MVP with 28 wins.
    586pts
  11. George Sisler — ranked #1111
    George Sisler
    St. Louis Browns first baseman who collected 257 hits in 1920, batted .420 in 1922 and won that year's AL MVP.
    586pts
  12. Paul Waner — ranked #1212
    Paul Waner
    Pirates right fielder nicknamed Big Poison who won the 1927 NL MVP with a .380 average and 237 hits.
    586pts
  13. Kiki Cuyler — ranked #1313
    Kiki Cuyler
    Batted .357 with 26 triples and a league-best 144 runs for the 1925 World Series champion Pirates.
    586pts
  14. Frankie Frisch — ranked #1414
    Frankie Frisch
    Switch-hitting second baseman who won the 1921 and 1922 World Series with the Giants before a trade to St. Louis for Rogers Hornsby.
    500pts
  15. Joe Sewell — ranked #1515
    Joe Sewell
    Took over at shortstop for Cleveland's 1920 champions after Ray Chapman's death and struck out only 114 times in his career.
    500pts
  16. Burleigh Grimes — ranked #1616
    Burleigh Grimes
    Spitball pitcher who won 20 or more games five times between 1920 and 1928, mostly for Brooklyn.
    500pts
  17. Waite Hoyt — ranked #1717
    Waite Hoyt
    Yankees right-hander who allowed no earned runs in 27 innings of the 1921 World Series and went 22-7 in 1927.
    500pts
  18. Biz Mackey — ranked #1818
    Biz Mackey
    Catcher for the Hilldale Club who won the 1925 Colored World Series; elected to the Hall of Fame in 2006.
    451pts
  19. Pie Traynor — ranked #1919
    Pie Traynor
    Pittsburgh third baseman with a .320 career average who won the 1925 World Series with the Pirates.
    451pts
  20. Al Simmons — ranked #2020
    Al Simmons
    Philadelphia Athletics outfielder who hit .392 in 1927 and led the AL with 157 RBI for the 1929 champions.
    451pts
  21. Herb Pennock — ranked #2121
    Herb Pennock
    Yankees left-hander who won two games in each of the 1923 and 1926 World Series.
    451pts
  22. Walter Johnson — ranked #2222
    Walter Johnson
    Washington right-hander who won the 1924 AL MVP and pitched four scoreless extra innings to win Game 7 of that year's World Series.
    451pts
  23. Red Faber — ranked #2323
    Red Faber
    White Sox spitballer who led the AL in ERA in 1921 and 1922.
    394pts
  24. Goose Goslin — ranked #2424
    Goose Goslin
    Hit three home runs for Washington in the 1924 World Series and won the 1928 AL batting title at .379.
    394pts
  25. Tony Lazzeri — ranked #2525
    Tony Lazzeri
    Yankees second baseman from 1926 who drove in 114 runs as a rookie and was part of the 1927 Murderers' Row lineup.
    394pts
  26. Ken Williams — ranked #2626
    Ken Williams
    Browns outfielder who led the AL with 39 home runs and 155 RBI in 1922 and stole 37 bases, the first 30-30 season.
    394pts
  27. Dolf Luque — ranked #2727
    Dolf Luque
    Havana-born Reds pitcher who went 27-8 with a 1.93 ERA in 1923, leading the NL in both wins and ERA.
    394pts
  28. Urban Shocker — ranked #2828
    Urban Shocker
    Tied for the American League lead with 27 wins for the 1921 St. Louis Browns and later pitched for the 1927 Yankees.
    0pts
  29. Stan Coveleski — ranked #2929
    Stan Coveleski
    Won three complete games for Cleveland in the 1920 World Series and the 1925 AL ERA title with Washington.
    0pts

Comments