You Pick BestYouPickBest

Who is the best MLB player born in 1958?

By YPB Team

Speed, batting titles and October heroics all trace back to the same birth year here, with Cooperstown names standing next to role players fans still remember.

  1. Rickey Henderson — ranked #11
    Rickey Henderson
    Hall of Fame leadoff hitter born December 25, 1958, the all-time leader in stolen bases and runs scored and the 1990 AL MVP.
    1000pts
  2. Wade Boggs — ranked #22
    Wade Boggs
    Hall of Fame third baseman born June 15, 1958, who won five AL batting titles and finished with 3,010 hits.
    724pts
  3. Julio Franco — ranked #33
    Julio Franco
    Dominican hitter born August 23, 1958, who won the 1991 AL batting title with Texas and kept playing in the majors until 2007.
    690pts
  4. Dickie Thon — ranked #44
    Dickie Thon
    Houston Astros shortstop born June 20, 1958, who made the 1983 All-Star team before a 1984 beaning damaged his vision.
    517pts
  5. Mike Scioscia — ranked #55
    Mike Scioscia
    Dodgers catcher born November 27, 1958, who won World Series titles in 1981 and 1988 and later managed the Angels to the 2002 title.
    517pts
  6. Gary Gaetti — ranked #66
    Gary Gaetti
    Third baseman born August 19, 1958, who was 1987 ALCS MVP on the way to Minnesota's first World Series title.
    517pts
  7. Willie McGee — ranked #77
    Willie McGee
    Cardinals center fielder born November 2, 1958, who won the 1985 NL MVP and NL batting titles in 1985 and 1990.
    517pts
  8. Atlee Hammaker — ranked #88
    Atlee Hammaker
    San Francisco Giants left-hander born January 24, 1958, who led the NL with a 2.25 ERA in 1983.
    423pts
  9. Pat Tabler — ranked #99
    Pat Tabler
    Cleveland infielder and outfielder born February 2, 1958, a 1987 All-Star famed for hitting nearly .500 with the bases loaded.
    423pts
  10. Alan Trammell — ranked #1010
    Alan Trammell
    Hall of Fame shortstop born February 21, 1958, who spent 20 seasons with Detroit and was MVP of the 1984 World Series.
    423pts
  11. Bruce Hurst — ranked #1111
    Bruce Hurst
    Left-hander born March 24, 1958, who won two starts for Boston in the 1986 World Series.
    310pts
  12. Pete O'Brien — ranked #1212
    Pete O'Brien
    First baseman born February 9, 1958, a slick fielder who played for the Texas Rangers from 1982 to 1988.
    310pts
  13. Orel Hershiser — ranked #1313
    Orel Hershiser
    Dodgers right-hander born September 16, 1958, who won the 1988 Cy Young Award, threw a record 59 consecutive scoreless innings and was MVP of both the 1988 NLCS and World Series.
    310pts
  14. Gary Pettis — ranked #1414
    Gary Pettis
    Center fielder born April 3, 1958, who won five Gold Gloves with the Angels, Tigers and Rangers.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments