You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 27 Biggest What-Ifs in Men's Tennis History

By YPB Team

Injuries, walk-aways and talent that never quite converted. The careers that leave you wondering.

  1. Bjorn Borg — ranked #11
    Bjorn Borg
    Won eleven majors and walked away from the sport at 26.
    1000pts
  2. Juan Martin del Potro — ranked #22
    Juan Martin del Potro
    Won the US Open at 20, then lost years to wrist and knee surgery.
    512pts
  3. Goran Ivanisevic — ranked #33
    Goran Ivanisevic
    Lost three Wimbledon finals before finally winning as a wildcard.
    512pts
  4. Milos Raonic — ranked #44
    Milos Raonic
    One of the great serves of his generation and one major final.
    444pts
  5. Richard Krajicek — ranked #55
    Richard Krajicek
    Won Wimbledon in 1996 and lost years to knee and elbow trouble.
    444pts
  6. Gustavo Kuerten — ranked #66
    Gustavo Kuerten
    Three French Opens and a world No. 1 ranking, ended early by a hip injury.
    363pts
  7. Marat Safin — ranked #77
    Marat Safin
    Beat Sampras and Federer in major finals, and won only two major titles before knee injuries.
    363pts
  8. Nick Kyrgios — ranked #88
    Nick Kyrgios
    Beat every member of the Big Three and reached one major final.
    363pts
  9. Andre Agassi — ranked #99
    Andre Agassi
    Won five of his eight majors after turning 28, having fallen to No. 141 at 27.
    363pts
  10. Ernests Gulbis — ranked #1010
    Ernests Gulbis
    A French Open semi-finalist whose talent never settled into a career.
    266pts
  11. Tommy Haas — ranked #1111
    Tommy Haas
    Reached No. 2 in the world and spent much of his prime injured.
    0pts
  12. Robin Soderling — ranked #1212
    Robin Soderling
    The first man to beat Nadal at the French Open, in 2009, before glandular fever ended his career at 26.
    0pts
  13. Dominic Thiem — ranked #1313
    Dominic Thiem
    Won the 2020 US Open after three lost major finals, then a wrist injury in 2021 ended his time at the top.
  14. Andy Murray — ranked #1414
    Andy Murray
    Reached world No. 1 in 2016 with three majors, then a hip injury and resurfacing surgery cut his prime short.
  15. Marcelo Ríos — ranked #1515
    Marcelo Ríos
    Became the first Latin American world No. 1 in 1998, the only top-ranked man never to win a major, and was finished by injuries at 28.
  16. Mark Philippoussis — ranked #1616
    Mark Philippoussis
    A huge server who reached Wimbledon and US Open finals but lost years to three knee operations.
  17. Lew Hoad — ranked #1717
    Lew Hoad
    Won four majors by 22 and was rated by peers as the most gifted player ever, before a chronic back injury cut him down.
  18. Rod Laver — ranked #1818
    Rod Laver
    Won two calendar Grand Slams, but turning pro kept him out of the majors for five seasons at his peak, from 1963 to 1967.
  19. Pancho Gonzales — ranked #1919
    Pancho Gonzales
    The dominant player of the 1950s, barred from the majors for 18 years after turning professional in 1949.
  20. Thomas Muster — ranked #2020
    Thomas Muster
    Was hit by a drunk driver hours after reaching the 1989 Miami final, came back to win Roland-Garros and reach No. 1.
  21. Grigor Dimitrov — ranked #2121
    Grigor Dimitrov
    Dubbed 'Baby Fed' for his all-court game, he won the ATP Finals in 2017 but never reached a major final.
  22. David Nalbandian — ranked #2222
    David Nalbandian
    Beat Federer, Nadal and Djokovic, won the 2005 Masters Cup, yet never won a major and was slowed by injuries.
  23. Richard Gasquet — ranked #2323
    Richard Gasquet
    Hailed as a future champion at 9 on a magazine cover, owner of a famous backhand, he never reached a major final.
  24. Jo-Wilfried Tsonga — ranked #2424
    Jo-Wilfried Tsonga
    Reached the 2008 Australian Open final and beat all of the Big Three, but knee injuries kept him from a major title.
  25. Alexander Zverev — ranked #2525
    Alexander Zverev
    Olympic champion and three-time major finalist who tore ankle ligaments mid-match against Nadal in the 2022 Roland-Garros semi-final.
  26. Andy Roddick — ranked #2626
    Andy Roddick
    Won the 2003 US Open and reached No. 1 at 21, then lost four major finals to Federer, including Wimbledon 2009, 16-14 in the fifth.
  27. Patrick Rafter — ranked #2727
    Patrick Rafter
    Won two US Opens and reached two Wimbledon finals, then a shoulder injury ended his career at 29 in 2002.

Photo credits

Comments 3

The unflattering list, and he put himself on it in his own book: https://youpick.best/articles/andre-agassi-ranked-many-ways

YP
ypb-team
Aug 25

Retired at 26 with 11 majors, Borg is the only name here who left by choice. His what-if, set against McEnroe's long career: https://youpick.best/articles/borg-vs-mcenroe-ranked

YP
ypb-team
Sep 26

Which career lost most to injury? Murray went from world No. 1 in 2016 to hip surgery. The unflattering list in this sixteen-part set: https://youpick.best/articles/andy-murray-ranked-many-ways

YP
ypb-team
Oct 23