You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 27 Biggest What-Ifs in Men's Tennis History

By YPB Team

Injuries, walk-aways and talent that never quite converted. The careers that leave you wondering.

  1. Juan Martin del Potro — ranked #11
    Juan Martin del Potro
    Won the US Open at 20, then lost years to wrist and knee surgery.
    1000pts
  2. Bjorn Borg — ranked #22
    Bjorn Borg
    Won eleven majors and walked away from the sport at 26.
    710pts
  3. Marat Safin — ranked #33
    Marat Safin
    Beat Sampras and Federer in major finals, and won only two major titles before knee injuries.
    643pts
  4. Grigor Dimitrov — ranked #44
    Grigor Dimitrov
    Dubbed 'Baby Fed' for his all-court game, he won the ATP Finals in 2017 but never reached a major final.
    643pts
  5. Nick Kyrgios — ranked #55
    Nick Kyrgios
    Beat every member of the Big Three and reached one major final.
    643pts
  6. Andy Murray — ranked #66
    Andy Murray
    Reached world No. 1 in 2016 with three majors, then a hip injury and resurfacing surgery cut his prime short.
    643pts
  7. Milos Raonic — ranked #77
    Milos Raonic
    One of the great serves of his generation and one major final.
    602pts
  8. Dominic Thiem — ranked #88
    Dominic Thiem
    Won the 2020 US Open after three lost major finals, then a wrist injury in 2021 ended his time at the top.
    555pts
  9. David Nalbandian — ranked #99
    David Nalbandian
    Beat Federer, Nadal and Djokovic, won the 2005 Masters Cup, yet never won a major and was slowed by injuries.
    500pts
  10. Andre Agassi — ranked #1010
    Andre Agassi
    Won five of his eight majors after turning 28, having fallen to No. 141 at 27.
    500pts
  11. Mark Philippoussis — ranked #1111
    Mark Philippoussis
    A huge server who reached Wimbledon and US Open finals but lost years to three knee operations.
    500pts
  12. Marcelo Ríos — ranked #1212
    Marcelo Ríos
    Became the first Latin American world No. 1 in 1998, the only top-ranked man never to win a major, and was finished by injuries at 28.
    455pts
  13. Ernests Gulbis — ranked #1313
    Ernests Gulbis
    A French Open semi-finalist whose talent never settled into a career.
    455pts
  14. Tommy Haas — ranked #1414
    Tommy Haas
    Reached No. 2 in the world and spent much of his prime injured.
    455pts
  15. Lew Hoad — ranked #1515
    Lew Hoad
    Won four majors by 22 and was rated by peers as the most gifted player ever, before a chronic back injury cut him down.
    455pts
  16. Jo-Wilfried Tsonga — ranked #1616
    Jo-Wilfried Tsonga
    Reached the 2008 Australian Open final and beat all of the Big Three, but knee injuries kept him from a major title.
    400pts
  17. Gustavo Kuerten — ranked #1717
    Gustavo Kuerten
    Three French Opens and a world No. 1 ranking, ended early by a hip injury.
    400pts
  18. Richard Gasquet — ranked #1818
    Richard Gasquet
    Hailed as a future champion at 9 on a magazine cover, owner of a famous backhand, he never reached a major final.
    400pts
  19. Andy Roddick — ranked #1919
    Andy Roddick
    Won the 2003 US Open and reached No. 1 at 21, then lost four major finals to Federer, including Wimbledon 2009, 16-14 in the fifth.
    400pts
  20. Robin Soderling — ranked #2020
    Robin Soderling
    The first man to beat Nadal at the French Open, in 2009, before glandular fever ended his career at 26.
    400pts
  21. Richard Krajicek — ranked #2121
    Richard Krajicek
    Won Wimbledon in 1996 and lost years to knee and elbow trouble.
    400pts
  22. Pancho Gonzales — ranked #2222
    Pancho Gonzales
    The dominant player of the 1950s, barred from the majors for 18 years after turning professional in 1949.
    0pts
  23. Patrick Rafter — ranked #2323
    Patrick Rafter
    Won two US Opens and reached two Wimbledon finals, then a shoulder injury ended his career at 29 in 2002.
    0pts
  24. Goran Ivanisevic — ranked #2424
    Goran Ivanisevic
    Lost three Wimbledon finals before finally winning as a wildcard.
    0pts
  25. Rod Laver — ranked #2525
    Rod Laver
    Won two calendar Grand Slams, but turning pro kept him out of the majors for five seasons at his peak, from 1963 to 1967.
    0pts
  26. Thomas Muster — ranked #2626
    Thomas Muster
    Was hit by a drunk driver hours after reaching the 1989 Miami final, came back to win Roland-Garros and reach No. 1.
    0pts
  27. Alexander Zverev — ranked #2727
    Alexander Zverev
    Olympic champion and three-time major finalist who tore ankle ligaments mid-match against Nadal in the 2022 Roland-Garros semi-final.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments 1

Retired at 26 with 11 majors, Borg is the only name here who left by choice, the what-if behind Borg vs McEnroe; Andy Murray went from No. 1 to hip surgery, and Andre Agassi put himself on this list in his own book.

YP
ypb-team
Aug 25