You Pick BestYouPickBest

Who is the best third-party presidential candidate in U.S. history?

By YPB Team

None of them won. Several of them changed the result anyway, and a few carried states nobody expected.

  1. Theodore Roosevelt — ranked #11
    Theodore Roosevelt
    Ran as the Progressive "Bull Moose" candidate in 1912 and took 27.4% of the vote and 88 electoral votes, beating the sitting Republican president.
  2. Ross Perot — ranked #22
    Ross Perot
    The Texas businessman who took 18.9% of the popular vote in 1992 with a self-funded campaign built on deficit charts.
  3. Robert La Follette — ranked #33
    Robert La Follette
    The Wisconsin senator whose 1924 Progressive run took a sixth of the vote and carried his home state.
  4. Eugene V. Debs — ranked #44
    Eugene V. Debs
    The Socialist candidate who ran five times and took nearly a million votes in 1920 from a federal prison cell.
  5. Millard Fillmore — ranked #55
    Millard Fillmore
    The former president who returned in 1856 on the Know Nothing ticket and carried Maryland.
  6. John C. Frémont — ranked #66
    John C. Frémont
    The explorer who carried eleven states in 1856 as the brand-new Republican Party's first nominee.
  7. Ralph Nader — ranked #77
    Ralph Nader
    The consumer advocate whose 2000 Green Party run drew under 3% and an argument that has never stopped.
  8. John Bell — ranked #88
    John Bell
    The Constitutional Union nominee who carried three states in the four-way election of 1860.
  9. William Wirt — ranked #99
    William Wirt
    The Anti-Masonic nominee in 1832, the first third-party candidate to win a state.
  10. Martin Van Buren — ranked #1010
    Martin Van Buren
    The former president who ran again in 1848 on the Free Soil ticket and took a tenth of the national vote.
  11. James B. Weaver — ranked #1111
    James B. Weaver
    The Populist candidate who won five states in 1892 on a platform of silver, railroads and farm debt.
  12. John Anderson — ranked #1212
    John Anderson
    The Illinois congressman whose 1980 independent run took nearly 7% without carrying a state.

Comments 1

27.4% of the vote and 88 electoral votes in 1912, ahead of the sitting president. Ross Perot managed 18.9% in 1992 and no electoral votes: https://youpick.best/articles/theodore-roosevelt-ranked-many-ways

YP
ypb-team
Aug 21