You Pick BestYouPickBest

Who is the best MLB first baseman of 2026?

By YPB Team

Gold Gloves, Silver Slugger nods, a record-setting rookie and a Japanese import who homered right away: 2026 gave first base plenty of cases to argue. Pick the one you'd want in the lineup.

  1. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. — ranked #11
    Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
    Toronto Blue Jays first baseman and 2026 AL Gold Glove finalist who hit .397 with eight home runs in the 2025 postseason.
  2. Matt Olson — ranked #22
    Matt Olson
    Atlanta Braves first baseman who won the 2026 National League Gold Glove at first base and was a 2026 Silver Slugger finalist.
  3. Freddie Freeman — ranked #33
    Freddie Freeman
    Los Angeles Dodgers first baseman, the 2020 National League MVP and the 2024 World Series MVP.
  4. Nick Kurtz — ranked #44
    Nick Kurtz
    Athletics first baseman who hit 36 home runs in his first 117 games as a 2025 rookie and won that year's AL Rookie of the Year.
  5. Pete Alonso — ranked #55
    Pete Alonso
    Baltimore Orioles first baseman and 2026 AL Silver Slugger finalist in his first season after seven years with the New York Mets.
  6. Rafael Devers — ranked #66
    Rafael Devers
    San Francisco Giants first baseman who hit 37 home runs in 2026 and was a National League Silver Slugger finalist at the position.
  7. Bryce Harper — ranked #77
    Bryce Harper
    Philadelphia Phillies first baseman and two-time National League MVP (2015, 2021) who moved to first base in 2023.
  8. Willson Contreras — ranked #88
    Willson Contreras
    Longtime catcher who played first base for the Boston Red Sox in 2026 after a trade from St. Louis and was an AL Silver Slugger finalist at the position.
  9. Munetaka Murakami — ranked #99
    Munetaka Murakami
    Japanese slugger and 2022 NPB Triple Crown winner who joined the Chicago White Sox in 2026 and homered in each of his first three MLB games.
  10. Sal Stewart — ranked #1010
    Sal Stewart
    Cincinnati Reds rookie who in 2026 became the first Reds rookie with a 30-homer, 100-RBI season.
  11. Jonathan Aranda — ranked #1111
    Jonathan Aranda
    Tampa Bay Rays first baseman who hit .316 with a 146 wRC+ in 2025 and stayed among the hit leaders at the position in 2026.
  12. Vinnie Pasquantino — ranked #1212
    Vinnie Pasquantino
    Kansas City Royals first baseman who drove in 113 runs in 2025 and was a 2026 AL Gold Glove finalist.
  13. Christian Walker — ranked #1313
    Christian Walker
    Houston Astros first baseman who won the 2026 American League Gold Glove at first base, the fourth of his career.
  14. Jake Bauers — ranked #1414
    Jake Bauers
    Milwaukee Brewers first baseman who topped 20 home runs for the first time in 2026 and was a National League Silver Slugger finalist.
  15. Alec Burleson — ranked #1515
    Alec Burleson
    St. Louis Cardinals first baseman and a 2026 National League Silver Slugger finalist.

Photo credits

Comments